Often when I tell people I’m applying to Ph.D. programs in contemporary art I get one of two responses. Either they say with vague congratulations, “Wow,” or the more pesky ones ask: “What’s the difference between contemporary and modern art?” Little do they know that with such a seemingly banal question they have just asked me to summarize and define the contemporary—a term that has been used so often and in so many different ways that it has started to lose any sense of concrete meaning.
For the sake of my own sanity, I often respond with the traditional answer: art from after 1945. Other times I use the more colloquial art historical categorization: art from the 1960s and beyond. And you know what? Almost unanimously after I give a date people stop asking me about it. They genuinely do not seem to care about the conceptual notion of “the contemporary” or how to define it. They just want a date, a chronological boundary.
I understand this impulse. A bookend date makes the realm of contemporary art seem more accessible and less overwhelming. A date makes the realm of contemporary art definable and, therefore, intellectually safe.
There are practical implications of defining the contemporary. Art history Ph.D. programs need to define the program specializations. Contemporary museums need to articulate their mission. It is a word in the english language and, therefore, is assumed to have meaning. When someone uses the word, it refers to something. Currently, there are many definitions of the contemporary that are vying for their spot at the top, elbowing each other and saying, “No, I AM the contemporary.”
To be frank, I’ve grown thoroughly tired of this discussion.
I’m going to assert for a seemingly poor solution to the debate of what the contemporary is, but I want you to stay with me. I think there is an actual answer to the question: What is the contemporary? And it is: Whatever we want it to be.
Ways to define the contemporary:
- Dates: simple, clean, logical, fits the Western impulse to periodize.
- A state of mind: ambiguous, creative, fits the desires of people who do not find satisfaction in nitty gritty pragmatics.
- Temporalities: intellectualizing, abstract, fits the impulse to leave wiggle room in order to do whatever one wants.
- Nothing: utterly unhelpful.
- And so on.
I’m sure there are other ways to define the contemporary. This is the point. In these glib definitions, I have aimed to add a touch of cynicism to these modes of defining the contemporary because if we get caught up in the utopian ideals of the contemporary, then we run the risk of losing sight of its function as AN ACTUAL WORD USED TO REFER TO ACTUAL THINGS.
Let’s consider three case studies.
The dictionary definition: The first definition under the OED’s entry for the contemporary is: “belonging to the same time, age, or period; living, existing, or occurring together in time.” This definition falls back on contemporary as referring to something temporal; it is not clearly concerned with art and art history. To be contemporary is to co-exist amongst other things at the same chronological time. But, how do we define “the same time?” Same year? Same decade? Same “state of mind?” As you can tell, this task gets more complicated as we try to dig a little deeper.
The museum: Under its “Vision and Mission” statement the MCA defines its realm of art, as a contemporary museum, as “the works of living artists.” This definition is surprisingly practical. To be contemporary is to be alive right now. However, here is a thought exercise to consider: What if the artist dies during the exhibition. Is the art torn from the walls? I’d assume not. In other words, does death mark an artist as no longer contemporary? Is the “contemporaneity” of art determined by artists? Again, the definition starts to break down after some prodding.
Are museums NOW?
The academic: In Radical Museology, or, What’s ‘contemporary’ in museums of contemporary art?, Claire Bishop’s argument about what “the contemporary” means is multifaceted. However, it ultimately takes an amorphous or ideological approach to the term. Bishop writes, “The contemporary becomes less a question of periodization or discourse than a method or practice, potentially applicable to all historical periods.” This approach skirts the difficulties of defining the contemporary. It eschews dates and chronology. It instead puts forth a way of doing contemporary. So, when I’m applying to graduate school should I say that I’m interested not in studying contemporary art, but rather in doing the contemporary? How far will that get me? Most importantly, how is this different than what academics (specifically in the humanities) do all the time: make history relevant?
Each definition is valid within a certain set of parameters, but not necessarily applicable to other situations. The MCA’s definition of the contemporary suits its mission, but does not necessarily suit the OED’s dictionary definition or Bishop’s conceptualization. In applying to graduate school, I have a range of possible definitions to use.
Ultimately, these definitions make clear that the contemporary is not beholden to any master. It does not have to be chronological, tied to artists, or defined by a method. It could be all three, two out of the three, one out of the three, or none of the above. It ultimately has become so used and overused that the term has lost a singular meaning. Rather it opens itself up to the appropriation towards any means deemed worthy, by dictionaries, by institutions, by academics or anyone else.
So, ultimately, how do I define the contemporary? Day to day, I think of it as post-1945, occasionally I’m beholden to the 1960s+ categorization. Other days, I wander to the abstract territory of academia, wading into the pools of “method” and “practice.” On a random Thursday, it means nothing at all.
What’s the contemporary? It’s whatever I want it to be. The word is used to refer to many different things, thus the definition of the term depends absolutely on the context in which it is used. The contemporary curatorial “method” is different than the Ph.D. specialization. They both rely on the sounds that make up “contemporary,” but their meanings are distinct.
I think all the confusion and debate about this word has actually arisen from the overlooking of a very fundamental linguistic and sociological truth: the “contemporary” does not have a meaning until we place it in a context. So, in the end, we have to be able to sit with the multiplicity of the “contemporary.” We must lay down our arms in intellectual battle and accept unanimous defeat. No one will come up with a universal definition.
In other words, the “contemporary” means nothing and many things.
I beg:
Can we move on?
—
714 Comments
maxbet Developing resilience to setbacks and learning from mistakes are key aspects of building mental strength in competitive gaming.
tangkas88 The competitive world of Mobile Legend gaming is a dynamic and fast-paced environment where players showcase their skills, strategy, and teamwork.
Baccarat Online Top Mobile Legend players have a bag of tricks up their sleeves when it comes to strategies and techniques.
Roulette online Understanding each role’s strengths and weaknesses will give you an edge during team compositions.
Slot Mahjong In Mobile Legends, players take on the role of powerful heroes with unique abilities and work together in teams to destroy the enemy base.
Gates of Olympus They understand that success doesn’t come overnight but is a result of continuous learning and refinement.
slot thailand Embracing teamwork not only enhances gameplay but also fosters camaraderie among players striving towards a common goal – claiming victory in every match played!
Spaceman demo Origins of the Character
slot bet The popularity of Gatot Kaca in fiction serves as a testament to the enduring appeal of this legendary figure within Indonesian culture.
SV388 The impact of Gatot Kaca on Indonesian culture is undeniable.
slot qris Known for his exceptional skills in combat and loyalty to his cause, Gatot Kaca embodies the values of courage and honor.
Zeus Slot The timeless appeal of Gatot Kaca serves as a reminder of the power of myth and legend to shape societal norms and ideals within Indonesian culture.
slot deposit pulsa With roots deeply entrenched in Javanese mythology, Gatot Kaca’s origin story showcases his supernatural abilities and noble lineage.
bonus new member 100 The representation of Gatot Kaca’s prowess extends beyond physical might;
Garansi Kekalahan 100 By showcasing characters who fall due to their own pride, these stories serve as cautionary tales about staying humble and grounded.
Slot777 Mahjong Ways is an exciting tile-matching game that offers players the chance to win big jackpots.
a href=”https://waikikigangnamstyle.com”>Tokyo88 This adds an extra layer of strategy as you plan your moves carefully.
Tokyo88 Tips for Increasing Your Chances of Hitting the Jackpot
Mahjong Ways Familiarize yourself with the rules and strategies of the game. Understanding how Mahjong Ways works will give you an edge when trying to hit that elusive jackpot.
Extraordinary results! And what a changeover for me! I am really glad that I chose them for work! I would suggest them to everyone. They are amazing in their work! slot online
Great post however , I was wanting to know if you could write a litte more on this subject? I’d be very thankful if you could elaborate a little bit further. Bless you! slot88
A blog like yours should be earning much money from adsense.’~::- situs slot
Hey there, I think your blog might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your blog in Safari, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, awesome blog! https://18.143.141.207/
Made to measure curtains… […]check out the sites listed below, worth a read for interiors and rugs enthusiasts[…]… myflixerz
I have read a few excellent stuff here. Definitely price bookmarking for revisiting. I wonder how much attempt you set to create the sort of fantastic informative site. red light hat
You have a gift for words I will give you that. If only I had the same gift red light therapy cost
It’s a game. Five dollars is free. Try it It’s not an easy game ->-> 토토사이트.com
It’s a game. Five dollars is free. Try it It’s not an easy game
->-> 카지노사이트 .COM
beacons
I must say this information was very interesting. I stumbled onto you using a google search and was rather thankful for your rank for this article. laser engraver
It’s difficult to acquire knowledgeable folks within this topic, however you be understood as there’s more you are discussing! Thanks abonnement iptv smarters pro
Wow, this is really interesting. Thank you very much for sharing with us. ลิงค์รับทรัพย์
Hybe, which is chaired by Bang Si-huk and based in Seoul’s Yongsan area, invoked its 김포출장auditing authority against Ador on Monday and demanded the resignation of CEO Min Hee-jin, whom it accused of attempting to usurp management powers for the label.
Your writing style is very interesting and makes me want to keep reading. I can’t wait to read your next article! Especially if you discuss about 3 Tricks to Break into Olympus Guaranteed to be Effective. I’m sure it will be very exciting!
Hello! I simply wish to supply a massive thumbs up for your wonderful information you might have here on this post. I am returning to your blog post for more soon. Rai88
Thank you for challenging me to think critically and explore new ideas. kiếm tiền online
Great article. The information gained through the article is impeccable. Thanks for the information you provided.
หวยออนไลน์
I like this blog so much, saved to my bookmarks . Skrota bil Kungälv
Thank you for another essential article. I wish I had your passion for writing! https://www.procolored.com/collections/tshirt-printer
Informative insights. Thank you for posting this blog. philboss
Great post! philboss
I love the commentary on this web site, it definitely gives it that community sense! taka77 register
모바일 카지노 API는 모바일 플랫폼에서의 게임 플레이를 지원합니다. 이를 통해 사용자들은 언제 어디서나 모바일 장치를 통해 카지노 게임을 즐길 수 있으며, 더 나은 이용 경험을 제공합니다.
Thanks for the informative post. taya365
Thank you for another essential article. I wish I had your passion for writing! non dual teacher
Keep up the fantastic work! philboss
This is worth reading. Thank you for this post! philboss
Dry cleaning franchises cater to individuals and businesses seeking professional garment care solutions, including dry cleaning, laundering, alterations, and repairs. These franchises typically operate under a well-established brand name, benefiting from the reputation, marketing support, and operational systems provided by the franchisor. franchise dry cleaning
Regards for all your efforts that you have put in this. Very interesting information. non dual teachers
Gone are the days of waiting for taxis or navigating public transportation schedules. Private car services in Salt Lake City offer unparalleled convenience, with the flexibility to tailor your transportation experience according to your specific needs and preferences. Whether you’re heading to a business meeting, catching a flight at Salt Lake City International Airport, or embarking on a leisurely exploration of the city’s attractions, private car services ensure prompt and reliable transportation, allowing you to make the most of your time in this vibrant city. private car service salt lake city utah