The Urban Aesthetic: Urban Art Exploitation

On rare weekends between waves of projects and tests, I manage to escape the Northwestern campus and usually treat myself to a day in one of Chicago’s hip neighborhoods such as Wicker Park and Andersonville. However, this attitude and attraction of “hip” neighborhoods results in and perpetuates the toxic gentrification process that pushes low-income residents out of their homes when their neighborhood become too “edgy” for the ones who created it. Sherry Zhong wrote a critique recently for Third Coast Review discussing a recent book release that tackles the complex and sometimes devastating process of “the artists’ role in gentrification” (Zhong). The book Streetopia, Zhong says, “is a collection of works from 24 San Francisco artists and writers,” which is “not a book for a person unwilling to hear narratives with strident, patronizing undertones.” Particularly young artists tend to move into poorer neighborhoods with affordable housing because it’s hard to make a living. But as a side effect their creativity in the area gives it a “cool vibe that attracts consumers willing to pay for… the satisfaction of living somewhere urban, artsy and cool,” which eventually drives the price of living too high for the original residents. Though I don’t live in one of these gentrified Chicago neighborhoods (which follow the same model as gentrified neighborhoods everywhere), I too am guilty of contributing to the exploitation of urban environments.

After reading about this book, the theme of urban exploitation was still fresh in my mind when I stumbled across the favorable critique of an exhibition at the Gage Gallery. Mark Pohlad reviewed the art show “Not Forgotten: Chicago Street Memorials,” and though his critique lacked some specificity of the work, I gauged that the exhibition showcases street memorials through different lenses and media. Images depicting street art combine with “spoken-word soundtracks by survivors, city officials and activists” commemorating those who died on the streets, usually but not always from violent crimes, many of which go unsolved. Pohlad admits that “the glitzy address of Roosevelt University’s Gage Gallery—on Michigan Avenue… belies the grim urban reality this show so vividly documents,” but apart from this introductory sentence, he forgets the context of the show for the rest of the review. After reading Zhong’s piece about exploitation of urban environments, I cringed at the thought of these “temporary tombstones” (created by the living who experience the tragedy of losing loved ones to street violence) on display for those walking down Michigan Avenue. Not many people who find themselves on Michigan Ave, particularly inside that “glitzy art gallery,” likely have any experience with this type of mourning. Street art dedicated to lost loved ones are put on display for those who can afford to step foot on Michigan Ave remind me too much of the same cultural trends and attitudes that drive gentrification. Art in urban areas in seen as cool, hip, and edgy by those who have the luxury of visiting the creativity without having to stay for the violence or live in low income housing.

However, the exhibition at the Gage Gallery is trying to do something other than just appropriate street art and memories for the entertainment of the wealthy. There is some value in creating a space for these stories to be heard. The exhibition brings these tragedies into a different context to remind others of deaths that should not be ignored, even if they go unsolved. Zhong’s critique of Streetopia offers insight into a slightly different but no less complex situation. Artists often have no choice but to live in lower income areas because that’s where they can afford to live, and it’s hardly their fault that the creative environments and the works they create attract people there. Artists probably welcome publicity and exposure the crowds bring with them, but soon the popularity gets out of hand and other residents are being pushed out of another neighborhood that is being appropriated by richer folks. There is a delicate and difficult line that must be walked when experiencing “urban” art; on the one hand, exposure of these ideas is valuable to those who create the art or experience the hardships behind the art as is true of the “Not Forgotten” show. However, this experience can unfortunately become pure entertainment when the origin of the art is overlooked in favor of the aesthetic that is deemed “trendy” by society.

Zhong’s critique seems to capture the nuance of this type of art appreciation that the book Streetwise presents as problematic. She also acknowledges some of the contradictions within the book that reinforce how complicated the issue is:

“One article attempts to encourage activism by declaring that actions determine a person’s value, not race nor class. Only a few pages before that statement did the author thoroughly shit in white suburban transplants for their invocation of gentrification anywhere they go, as if class and race are the only way to talk about a certain subset of people.”

Zhong does not deny the problem, in fact throughout the article she discusses the negative effects of gentrification as portrayed through the book. In this quote she is admitting a shortcoming of one of the authors who perhaps oversimplifies the situation. Nonetheless, Zhong presents the book as a way to gain perspective of this situation while suggesting ways to combat it—a feature that Pohlad’s critique fails to highlight. Based solely on Pohlad’s critique (never having seen the art exhibition), “Not Forgotten” is a moving showcase of urban art and grief, but it stops there. Pohlad compliments the emotional effectiveness of the curation, but its context on Michigan Ave seems to distance it too much from reality. Pohlad describes it in beautiful terms, but if the pieces are seen just as art, then this too separates them from a sense of realness that is necessary for change. If urban art is presented more as an aesthetic than movements, then it will superficially enjoyed instead of absorbed meaningfully by society.

 

 

image: http://art.newcity.com/2016/10/24/meaningful-streets/

4,884 Comments

  • SLOT ONLINE VIRAL2K24 commented on April 29, 2024 Reply

    Online gaming sites provide data and statistics about game performance. Take advantage of this data analysis to play the best Gacor game performance today. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information regarding the most popular news today this year. For more complete information, please visit our website for further information https://hindiwiki.co/

  • KUMPULAN GAME KASINO GAMPANG MENANG commented on April 29, 2024 Reply

    Online gaming sites provide data and statistics about game performance. Take advantage of this data analysis to play the best Gacor game performance today. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information regarding the most popular news today this year. For more complete information, please visit our website for further information https://lkbaiying.com/

  • KUMPULAN GAME KASINO GAMPANG MENANG commented on April 29, 2024 Reply

    This number one best game in Indonesia is equipped with additional features that can be activated at any time while playing. These slots’ extra spins offer everything from practical prizes to multiple wins. Illustrations of some of the features that have been designed for each online game are free spin purchase alternatives, progressive jackpots and small games. For more detailed information, you can visit our website https://lkbaiying.com/

  • PUSAT TARUHAN SLOT GACOR commented on April 29, 2024 Reply

    Online gaming sites provide data and statistics about game performance. Take advantage of this data analysis to play the best Gacor game performance today. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information regarding the most popular news today this year. For more complete information, please visit our website for further information https://f573.com/

  • Prometheas Technologies commented on April 29, 2024 Reply

    OUTSYSTEMS DEVELOPMENT COMPANY IN INDIA

    Prometheas Technologies boasts a team of seasoned OutSystems developers who harness the platform’s full potential to deliver enterprise applications tailored to both present and future market demands. We champion personalized enterprise solutions, offering clients an array of customization and scalability options to ensure solutions align perfectly with their unique needs. Our mastery of OutSystems extends to every phase, from consultancy to final app development, and ongoing support and maintenance services. Count on our unwavering expertise for your success. Visit- https://prometheastech.com , mail- hello@prometheastech.com

  • terea-play commented on April 29, 2024 Reply

    Great post! philboss

  • terea-play commented on April 29, 2024 Reply

    Great post!. philboss

  • bushra commented on April 29, 2024 Reply

    Thanks for a wonderful share. Your article has proved your hard work and experience you have got in this field. Brilliant .i love it reading. kim lee

  • jhon commented on April 29, 2024 Reply

    Super-Duper blog! I am loving it!! Will be back later to read some more. I am taking your feeds also mpo777 login

  • DORAHOKI commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    Trusted gaming agents and sites maintain high standards of quality and service, building good relationships with users through continuous positive experiences in every Gacor slot game. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information regarding the most popular news today this year. For more detailed information, please visit our website at https://blogsactu.info/

  • GTATOGEL commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    The best and most popular online dealer games are now available at gaming. Of course you can get benefits from playing online games that you can achieve. As an online gaming site, you can get convenience in playing playing games which you can get easily and easily. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information regarding the most popular news today this year. For more complete information, please visit our website for further information https://gtatogel4.com/

  • shaikh seo commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    thanks this is good blog. Prestige Raintree Park

  • bushra commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    Thank you for taking the time to publish this information very useful! Kayseri cheap crane

  • SLOT ONLINE VIRAL 2K24 commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    Every time someone plays this newest slot game, they not only try their luck at hitting the jackpot, but also uncover some of the stories hidden behind the symbols. It is said that if someone manages to unite the three legendary jewels of fate on the pay line, they will find the way to untold treasures and long-lost secrets of the kingdom. For further information, you can visit our website https://hindiwiki.co/

  • MEME4D commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    If online game players are newcomers who are currently wondering about choosing the right slot agent site offering the most popular online slot games. These are some of the game collection lists. There are lots of suggestions for choosing a slot provider in Indonesia that is easy and successful. https://anoosy.com

  • DORAHOKI commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    Online gaming has become a phenomenon that has rocked the world of online gaming. With a variety of attractive themes and exhilarating features, online games offer an engaging and exciting gaming experience. For further information, you can visit our website https://probunhai147.org/

  • bushra commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    Thanks for a wonderful share. Your article has proved your hard work and experience you have got in this field. Brilliant .i love it reading. Mighty Oak Landscaping

  • MASTER TOGEL commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    Togel is a challenging number game, requiring perseverance and accuracy in analyzing patterns hidden behind mysterious rows of numbers. For further information, you can visit our website https://focos.com.co/

  • DORAHOKI commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    Trusted gaming agents and sites maintain high standards of quality and service, building good relationships with users through continuous positive experiences in every Gacor slot game. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information regarding the most popular news today this year. For more detailed information, please visit our website at https://r-hydrau-lemans.com/

  • WAKTOGEL commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    WAKTOGEL – The biggest online betting site that will give you advantages in playing online games. Visit the website. https://kucingwoman.com/

  • PUSAT TARUHAN SLOT GACOR commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    Don’t hesitate to try playing online games, because online games are very exciting games to play, when you play them you will feel a very extraordinary sensation in the game, well here we have a very exciting online game site for you. play, if you want to play it please visit our website https://f573.com/

  • WAKTOGEL commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    In an online game full of surprises and entertainment, its thrilling rounds and mouth-watering jackpots will take you on an unforgettable adventure. With stunning graphics and innovative features, every spin is a chance to win big. For further information, you can visit our website https://www.akuhoki.org/

  • BOCARAN JACKPOT SLOT commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    Online slots are a very global game, a very entertaining game, especially as it has many effective themes to ward off boredom, and for slot jackpot leaks, visit the website. https://transport-haenni.com/

  • DORAHOKI commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    The world of online gaming is constantly evolving, with changes and innovations occurring regularly. Follow the latest developments and trends in the gaming industry. Understanding these changes can give you an edge in one of the best slot games today. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information regarding the most popular news today this year. For more complete information please visit our website for further information https://vpagan.com/

  • SLOT SERVER THAILAND commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    Players on online sites will always get maximum service. By playing the best and most trusted games, it makes it easier for online game players to get very comfortable services in playing the most popular online games this year. For more complete information please visit our website https://coin.reise/

  • DORAHOKI commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    With a wide selection of interesting and exciting games you can enjoy an exciting and amazing playing experience, here we have a very interesting online game site and of course it has lots of features that you can play, if you want to play please visit our website https://sirammaxwin88.com/

  • Taya365 commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    Thanks for the informative post. taya365

  • GTATOGEL commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    GTATOGEL is an easy JP online lottery bookie which always provides alternative links to make it easier for our loyal players to access safely and without problems. Visit the website. https://wearecleveland.com

  • DORAHOKI commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    Online games are games that are very interesting and exciting to play, because they contain lots of interesting games, here we have games that will entertain you. If you are interested, please visit our website https://gasmaxwin88.com/

  • shaikh seo commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    thanks this is good blog. Commercial Printing

  • shaikh seo commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    s

  • shaikh seo commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    thanks this is good blog. sell your junk car fast in Orlando

  • jhon commented on April 30, 2024 Reply

    Just wish to say your article is as amazing. The clearness in your post is simply nice and i can assume you’re an expert on this subject. Well with your permission let me to grab your feed to keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please continue the enjoyable work. non dual teacher

  • DASARTOTO commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    Online gaming sites provide data and statistics about game performance. Take advantage of this data analysis to play the best Gacor game performance today. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information regarding the most popular news today this year. For more complete information, please visit our website for further https://postermarketplace.com/

  • DASARTOTO commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    Both the main online game bookie site link and alternative links have been provided very easily and conveniently. We provide a complete selection of alternative links to make it easier for online game players to access using one account and one user ID on several devices, both desktop and mobile. Online slot games are one of the game choices that are in great demand among online game players. Not only sharing happiness and fun, this game can also share income and increase promising income. For more detailed information, you can visit the website https://postermarketplace.com/

  • DASARTOTO commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    Like the games on the site, it provides up to 2 times the profits. gives top priority to customer satisfaction. A professional customer service team is ready to help players in a friendly and fast manner, making the playing experience even more enjoyable and hassle-free. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information regarding the most popular news today this year. For more complete information please https://postermarketplace.com/

  • JAMUSLOT commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    Slot games are a type of online slot game that is very popular throughout the world. A game that is very easy to reach with a big jackpot but safe and reliable, for more complete slot game information you can visit the website. http://174.138.18.197/

  • sheikhqueen682 commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    Nice Informative Blog having nice sharing.. Richardson TX SEO company

  • CAPTOGEL commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    The best and most popular online dealer games are now available at gaming. Of course you can get benefits from playing online games that you can achieve. As an online gaming site, you can get convenience in playing playing games which you can get easily and easily. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information regarding the most popular news today this year. For more complete information, please visit our website for further information https://enomdesk.com/

  • RESTUTOGEL commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    Online gaming sites provide data and statistics about game performance. Take advantage of this data analysis to play the best Gacor game performance today. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information regarding the most popular news today this year. For more complete information, please visit our website for further https://oldorchardit.com/

  • sheikhqueen682 commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    This is my first time i visit here. I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here! keep up the good work handyman in Morehead City

  • wjevo commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    Keep up the fantastic work! philboss

  • ABUTOGEL commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    Trusted gaming agents and sites maintain high standards of quality and service, building good relationships with users through continuous positive experiences in every Gacor slot game. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information regarding the most popular news today this year. For more detailed information, please visit our website at https://gwsengr.com/

  • ABUTOGEL commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    The most popular online slot game agents always pay attention to the entertainment of online slot game players. Therefore, developers have designed bonus rewards for playing your favorite games. The daily winning plan provides opportunities for all online game players on trusted online slot game agent sites to win easily every day and get real money jackpots. For more detailed information, you can visit our website https://gwsengr.com/

  • GTATOGEL commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    If online game players are newcomers who are currently wondering about choosing the right slot agent site offering the most popular online slot games. These are some of the game collection lists. There are lots of suggestions for choosing a slot provider in Indonesia that is easy and successful. https://ceeeya.com/

  • shaikh seo commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    thanks this is good blog. mobila la comanda ploiesti

  • JAMUSLOT commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    Don’t hesitate to try playing online games, because online games are very exciting games to play, when you play them you will feel a very extraordinary sensation in the game, well here we have a very exciting online game site for you. play, if you want to play it please visit our website https://hanhenmetsastys.com/

  • 출장마사지 commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    Your positive feedback on the article is much appreciated! I’m looking forward to sharing more of my adventures and experiences.
    Visit Our Website 출장안마

  • ABUTOGEL commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    The best and most popular online dealer games are now available at gaming. Of course you can get benefits from playing online games that you can achieve. As an online gaming site, you can get convenience in playing playing games which you can get easily and easily. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information regarding the most popular news today this year. For more complete information, please visit our website for further information https://thepointmarketing.com/

  • shaikh seo commented on May 1, 2024 Reply

    thanks this is good blog. Chula vista immigration attorney

Leave a Reply to sheikhqueen682 Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *