Drawing from a rich collection at Chicago’s Museum of Contemporary Art, former Curatorial Assistant, Karsten Lund, crafts a dynamic exhibit featuring photographical portraits from the 1940s to 2006. According to Lund, Witness, explores the role of the photographer in perceiving people “unconventionally.” In displaying a wide-range of photographical styles—from Walker Evans’ subway vignettes, to Alfredo Jaar’s large-scale installation—the selection investigates the interactions between object and perspective. The exhibit’s temporal and stylistic diversity offers a historically recurring and significant question: how does a photograph reveal the relationship between subject and “witness.” Through comparing the work of Walker Evans and Thomas Ruff, I propose that the photographer’s perspective is fundamental to the photograph’s—and thus the human subject’s—representation of reality.
Walker Evans’ eight gelatin prints from the 1940s depict various strangers riding the subway in New York. Using a hidden camera, Evans glimpses subjects in moments of transition—lost in thought, waiting, observing others, all while he intently does the same. Placed in a technologically distant era from now, routine, intermediary phases offered a static stretch of time for passengers to either exist within one’s thoughts, or in the observation of one’s physical surroundings. With no pocket-sized window to the virtual and digital, people’s expressions during temporal in-betweens were much more diverse than today’s wash of screen staring. In discussing his untitled series, Evans writes, “The guard is down and the mask is off, even more than when in lone bedrooms (where there are mirrors). People’s faces are in naked repose down in the subway.” Through catching the “naked repose,” Evans’ photographs propose momentary viewings into complex lives. In 1988, German artist, Thomas Ruff, created a series of large-scale, chromogenic portraits. Unlike Evans’ small, unobtrusive windows, Ruff’s work is bold and domineering. The displayed portrait, Portrait (C. Kewer), is crafted to be as systematic and neutral as possible. It stands against the romantic and conventional trope that fine photography exposes a subject’s psychology, and instead presents a passport-like, standardized formula. In viewing the subject through enlarged, hyper-realistic definition, Ruff augments the faces’ porous details to a most grotesque level, exploring how photography can expose the underlying sameness of all human subjects.
The contextual vision of time is critical to the two projects’ conflicting approaches. Evans’ prints feature people static in motion. Though they are stuck still, both in the photograph and train, their environment is moving, bended to the speed of the subway’s transition. Therefore, the photographs investigate a seemingly paradoxical relationship between the stagnancy of photography and waiting, and the motion of history and transition. Motion, a product of time, glues the subjects to the ephemeral, to the mortal. With an inherent beginning, middle and end, motion implies context, narrative. Through freezing stolen moments of transition, Evans’ photographs represent subjects through the experiential. Though I do not know the subjects, nor the intricacies of their lives, I can relate to their contextualized experiences, their hidden, yet foundational narratives. The photographs strike me as deeply empathetic. The subtleties of my own experiences fill the misty gaps, while simultaneously probing the wonder of narratives not my own. Ruff’s portrait, on the other hand, is completely devoid of motion, and therefore, time. Like pressing my eyes up to a brick wall, the portrait is lifeless in its divorce from implied narrative. Its static, blunt presence offers a dull and simple view into a human’s existence. In it’s large-scale, hyper-realism, the undercurrents of a subject’s psychology are washed into a non-expression of neutral flesh.
Stepping outside the frame, Evans and Ruff paradoxically address their roles as “the witness.” While Evans approaches his series through spontaneously stylized snapshots, Ruff carefully positions his camera to veil the photographer’s integral and interjected perspective. Evans plays with moving shadows and ranging angles, defining his perspective as a fellow stranger from across the aisle. For example, his photograph of an elderly women (bottom row, far left) angles slightly up, emphasizing the hidden view from his camera. Thus, the angle portrays not only the photographer’s presence, but his method of secret snapping. Next, the elderly woman’s hands, and a man in the background are slightly blurred. Using a range of definition between the blurry forms and the precision of the woman’s face, Evans softens and veils the subject and environment’s ordinary realism. In black and white, Evans photographs represent a gesture of reality observed through a narratively-driven, cloaked lens. Ruff’s photographical perspective is based in the illusion of transparency. The camera faces its subject, perfectly still and perfectly straight—the effect: neutrality. The photographer’s looming gaze seems to be inexistent; the perspective, therefore, lies in that of an unfeeling, objective machine. In stealthily removing the giveaways of his artistic tinkering, the veil between the subject and viewer is seemingly eradicated. Because the photographer seems to be inexistent, the viewer gazes upon the subject not through the perspective of another feeling human being, but through a total objectivity.
Peering into Walker Evans’ series, I see glancing vignettes of real lives I feel I can relate to, but do not know. And shrinking under Ruff’s engrossing portrait, I see a face, composed of flesh and hair and nothing more. With two conflicting, artistic statements, I see room for synthesis. Perhaps humans are both. Perhaps we are a dynamic collection of thoughts and experiences, with a unifying base of flesh and existence. As I sit on the bus home, I witness the faces around me, and simply do not know.
949 Comments
Discover endless entertainment at 24kbetcasino where you can enjoy a diverse selection of games, exciting promotions, and a premium gaming experience.
I just downloaded the spinrio app and it’s great for discovering new music and creating custom playlists!
spinrio app and it’s great for discovering new music and creating custom playlists!
very good slot game. Therefore, if you want to try it, you can visit our website
https://sayamenang.com
regentplay offers a thrilling array of games, ensuring every player finds their perfect match for excitement and entertainment.
TOTOGEL | DAFTAR TOTOGEL | LINK ALTERNATIF TOTOGEL | Daftar segera di situs TOTOGEL untuk mulai bermain permainan online terlengkap. Situs gacor gampang maxwin. Berapapun kemenangan Anda pasti akan terbayar lunas. Jaminan 10z0% Privasi dan keamanan Anda terjaga dengan baik bersama situs terbaik dan terpercaya TOTOGEL.
games that you can play here and can get attractive prizes if you can win the games you play. Here you can try to join in by playing games that are easy for you to win. For further information please visit the website
https://sikatterus.com
LIATOGEL merupakan situs yang menyediakan berbagai jenis Slot Online, Bandar Togel. Di Jaman sekarang, Teknologi sudah meningkat pesat. Apapun yang kita lakukan sekarang bisa melalui online, termasuk memasang Togel atau bermain game Slot online. Maka demikian LIATOGEL menjadi salah satu situs yang menyediakan Slot Online, Bandar Togel.
has very accurate predictions and is very easy to understand. Therefore, if you want to know more, please visit the website
https://racikansedap.com/
Thank you for the information. This slot game is very exciting and easy to win, that’s why so many people like it. For further information please visit the website
เสื้อใส่เที่ยวทะเล ครบสี ครบไซต์ ทำให้ซื้อไปใส่เป็นทีมใหญ่ หรือ กลุ่มใหญ่ โดยไม่ต้องสั่งตัดแพงๆ ใส่ได้ทั้งผู้ชาย และ ผู้หญิง ดีไซน์ทันสมัย เนื้อผ้าสวมใส่สบาย เหมาะสำหรับการ ทุกฤดูกาล ใส่ได้หลากหลายโอกาส เช่น เที่ยวทะเล ทำบุญ สรงน้ำพระพุทธรูปที่บ้าน รดน้ำดำหัวผู้ใหญ่ในบ้าน สีสันสดใส ใส่สบาย มีหลากหลาย ขนาด สไตล์ สี และ ลวดลายให้เลือกสรร เราคัดสรรที่ดีที่สุดมาให้แล้ว ขายดีอันดับ 1 การันตีจากเสียงลูกค้าที่บอกต่อเยอะมาก เสื้อทีม
I your writing style truly enjoying this internet site . Shop Guitars
is one of the lists of websites or slot agents for easy-to-win pro VIP RTP account slot sites. that’s why I really like it. If you also want to try it, please visit the website
https://goodhoki89.com/
What?s Going down i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this I have found It absolutely useful and it has aided me out loads. I hope to give a contribution & help different customers like its aided me. Great job. Nose Jewelry
Thanks for providing great platform for information.I also want to share some information regarding social experiencing.GB WhatsApp is a modified version of the popular messaging app WhatsApp.It offers extra features that are not available in the official app. People download it from various websites as it’s not available on Google Play Store or the App Store.You can get gbwhatsapp download from https://gbapp.com.pk/
GBWhatsApp Download Latest Version May 2024 For Android and Enjoy Advanced Messaging. GB WhatsApp APK by AlexMODs is an WhatsApp Mod. https://gbapps.ind.in/
LIATOGEL merupakan situs yang menyediakan berbagai jenis Slot Online, Bandar Togel. Di Jaman sekarang, Teknologi sudah meningkat pesat. Apapun yang kita lakukan sekarang bisa melalui online, termasuk memasang Togel atau bermain game Slot online. Maka demikian LIATOGEL menjadi salah satu situs yang menyediakan Slot Online, Bandar Togel.
Thank you for the information. Really fun and easy to win. Therefore, if you want to try it, please visit the website
https://uangeasy.com
Thank you for the information. it’s really very good and also easy to understand. Therefore, if you want to know more information, you can visit our website
https://pantangmundur88.org/
Ide bermain togel online dengan Rajabandot terdengar sangat menyenangkan. Tidak sabar untuk memulai.
I think this is a real great article post
토토사이트 순위
Download GBWhatsApp APK Latest Version 2024. GB WhatsApp is Modified Version of WhatsApp with Many Advanced Features like Anti-Ban & 100% Free. https://gbappss.net.pk/
Hello, I enjoy reading through your post. I wanted to writea little comment to support you.
카지노사이트 모음
Thanks for all your valuable labor on this website. Gloria delights in getting into investigations and it’s obvious why. Most people hear all concerning the dynamic method you present powerful guidelines on this website and as well boost response from other individuals on the subject matter so our own daughter is truly studying a lot of things. Take pleasure in the remaining portion of the new year. You’re the one carrying out a splendid job. kocuce
As a consequence of these websites and also talk computer software people today are given a better chance to come across their own lover. The reason is , everyone is provided the danger to be related wherever some might always be. Almost all different ethnicities along with strolling involving lifetime are able to meet with an effective simply click in the keyboard. islam
This online slot, which has the biggest prizes and is also easy to win, is one of the most exciting slot games. Therefore, if you want to try it, please visit our website
https://halamanvip.org
visit my site Wendys Breakfast Hours
Thanks For The Comment. https://dearlottery.net.in/
I just added this feed to my bookmarks. I have to say, I really enjoy reading your blogs. Thanks! instagram volgers kopen
Lottery Sambad Today Result Nagaland State Dear Lottery Morning, Day, Evenig and Night Live Ticket Draw PDF Download (লটারি সংবাদ).
https://lotterysambad.net.in/
Wholesale Cheap Handbags Will you be ok merely repost this on my site? I’ve to allow credit where it can be due. Have got a great day! dokumenty kolekcjonerskie
is a provider of the best online game lists. With a concept pattern that is easy to win and reliable when you are playing. For further information, please visit our website
https://alternatifvip.com
Paid phone search services usually go with access to unlimited lookups, discounted background and cell phone reports, and an advanced People Search. You can use the peop search application to find old classmates, long lost relatives, or former co-workers. what is my ip
Dear Lottery Result Today Live offers a chance to win big prizes. We Upload Daily Nagaland State Lottery Result For 1 PM, 6 PM and 8 PM Here.
https://dearlottery.net.in/
I was suggested this website by my cousin. I am not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my trouble. You are wonderful! Thanks!Nice blog here! Also your web site loads up fast! What web host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my website loaded up as quickly as yours lol ip adresim
Thanks for all your valuable labor on this website. Gloria delights in getting into investigations and it’s obvious why. Most people hear all concerning the dynamic method you present powerful guidelines on this website and as well boost response from other individuals on the subject matter so our own daughter is truly studying a lot of things. Take pleasure in the remaining portion of the new year. You’re the one carrying out a splendid job. this artilcle on CBS News
EZ2 RESULT TODAY – PCSO official EZ2 Lotto results at 2pm, 5pm and 9pm daily. Get latest EZ2 result today and announcements below. https://ez2resulttoday.ph/
STL RESULT TODAY – Check the PCSO STL results today and yesterday (Pares, Swer2, Swer3, Swer4) at 10:30AM, 3PM, 7PM and 8PM lotto draws. https://stlresulttoday.ph/
MEPCO bill check is an easy process to find your monthly electricity bill with valid resources. Whether it’s a mobile, tablet, or personal computer.https://mepcobillz.com/
zota bet is an innovative online platform that revolutionizes online sports with its user-friendly interface and advanced analytics.
The heycasino app delivers a seamless and entertaining mobile gaming experience, featuring a diverse range of games and user-friendly navigation.
yaacasino online provides an exciting and secure gaming environment with a wide variety of trusted online games and enticing promotions for all types of players.
Your post is very nice. https://gbappss.net.pk/
Thank you for the information. This game is very good because it has very big prizes and is also very easy for us to win. therefore for further information you can visit WAKTOGEL
Bersemangat untuk terjun ke dunia taruhan toto dengan layanan Olxtoto mulus.
ALPHASLOT88 merupakan situs yang menyediakan berbagai jenis Slot Online.
LIATOGEL merupakan situs yang menyediakan berbagai jenis Slot Online, Bandar Togel. Di Jaman sekarang, Teknologi sudah meningkat pesat. Apapun yang kita lakukan sekarang bisa melalui online, termasuk memasang Togel atau bermain game Slot online. Maka demikian LIATOGEL menjadi salah satu situs yang menyediakan Slot Online, Bandar Togel.
GBWhatsApp Download Latest Version May 2024 For Android and Enjoy Advanced Messaging. GB WhatsApp APK by AlexMODs is an WhatsApp Mod. https://gbapps.ind.in/
GB WhatsApp Download Latest Version 2024. GB WhatsApp APK is a Moded Version of WhatsApp with Many Advanced Features Like Anti-Ban.
GB WhatsApp Download Latest Version 2024. GB WhatsApp APK is a Moded Version of WhatsApp with Many Advanced Features Like Anti-Ban. https://gbappss.in/
memang sangat sulit untuk bisa mendapatkan jackpot, tapi jika kamu mainnya di lvonline slot maka kesulitan itu akan hilang
an online game that is very popular. especially the Indonesian people. because it is very exciting and easy to make a profit. Therefore, if you want to know further information, please visit our website
https://aquihacoisa.com/
Esplorare Tenerife non è mai stato così facile e piacevole. Con Mariposa Rent, ogni cliente può godere della libertà di scoprire gli angoli più belli dell’isola al proprio ritmo. Affidatevi a noi per il noleggio di scooter o moto che renderanno il vostro soggiorno a Tenerife un’esperienza davvero memorabile: noleggio scooter tenerife
Thank you for the information. it is very good and also easy to win. therefore you can visit the website
sng04.com
Unlock the Ultimate Slot Gaming Experience with Jepangbet: Indonesia’s Most Reliable Online slot online Agent
To discover everything you need to know about tennis london go to the listed website, at the website I booked tennis lessons near me and also booked up the very best tennis court near me. To find your next tennis coach and tennis lessons go to the website in the link tennis court near me
Thank you for the information. online lottery game with the biggest prizes and very attractive bonuses. therefore I really like it. for further information please visit WAKTOGEL