In the MCA’s photography exhibition WITNESS, the museum draws from its permanent collection to depict the photographer as both artist and spectator- an exploration of the finite encounter behind the photograph rather than the infinite interpretations the photograph evokes. The exhibition attempts to flesh out the moment between subject and artist, navigating the concept of gaze independent from a camera lens. However, as I passed the conveniently timed Kerry James Marshall photograph and noticed the irony of the Cindy Sherman pieces, the idea of WITNESS began to unfold as a vague concept used to dust off an amazing collection. I imagined the curator being dealt a jumble of photographs from a Scrabble pile and told to thematically string them together to win the game.
But then I saw the Triple Word Score in the gallery, the artwork where it all clicked, the piece which had to inform the concept if not the entire idea for the exhibition: Alfredo Jaar’s 2006 installation The Sound of Silence.
Tucked in the back corner of the gallery, through a miniature hallway, lies Jaar’s major installation. The front facing wall of the metal cube fills the entire room with a sterile light. The sight floats lightly in the bare space. Its glow not enchanting but instead mystifying, implying a distance to be kept before approaching the bug zapper-esque object. After stepping closer, the three horizontal sections break into hundreds of fluorescent light tubes creating a grid of blackness and intense brightness.
Since the room is only occupied by the structure and only lit by the front facing wall, once the light threshold is crossed the back half of the gallery becomes plainly dim. Printed on the floor are the directions “When the light is green, you may enter the structure” as well as the running time of the 8-and-a-half-minute video. In the leftover glow of the fluorescent light sits a simple white bench where you are able to wait for the space age LED lights to signal you inside.
While waiting on the bench, facing a giant metal cube you are about to enter, you really can’t help but feel like you are on the last round of Russian nesting dolls. In a building, in a room, in a room, in a box, the unlit side of the installation eerily mirrors the entry of the museum itself- this time without the cardio of the grand staircase. The same cold, square, metallic tiles give a sense of re-entry to the space, a weighty ritual act of recommitting to the exhibition you were in, yet waiting for patiently on a bench.
With all of the rising action built into the experience, I don’t think anything would have shocked me inside. Would a false floor drop me into the film? Would I be escorted through a series of miniature rooms each containing fragments of a story? Would every wall be a screen pelting me with audiovisual marginalia? But alas, entry demystified the installation revealing the interior as the familiar museum film set-up any other room could have provided.
I’ve always thought of the museum film as the ultimate litmus test separating gawking tourist from cultured aficionado. In the ubiquitous black benched room, larger questions of humility and pride are provided the ultimate battle ground. If I sit down at an insignificant time do I stay after everyone leaves? Are any of these strangers as aware as me that this is a big game of chicken after not checking the run-time? Will those people at the entrance of the room ever sit down?
Despite its familiar aesthetic, The Sound of Silence alleviates the anxieties surrounding the museum film through its dramatic build-up and demand for patience. Once the film begins, the audience is taken on a phrase-by-phrase poetic account of Kevin Carter’s life as a South African photojournalist. The phrases are communicated through slides of white typewriter font printed on the black screen. The font read as unfairly dated compared to the futuristic, graphic exterior of the installation, resembling something from a true crime story on television or end a melodramatic after school special. Although the font required some growing pains, the story of Kevin Carter’s tragic life and Pulitzer Prize winning photo unfurls beautifully.
It is this simplistic beauty of the storytelling that draws you into the screen and divorces the four industrial sized flash heads paired on either side from the equation, fading into the blackness. While their presence is rather obvious when you first enter the tiny room, the implied ellipsis after each careful phrase of the narrative and the exclusion of music make it impossible to know when the flash will go off- no grand crescendo to follow or clear climax to a story dripping with reality and teetering with emotions.
And then it goes off.
Right after Carter ends his life due to questions surrounding his morality in combination with the famine stricken and war torn images that haunt him, the giant flash heads activate and provoke a giant gasp and collective shudder.
This is where the genius of the piece takes flight. Bewildered and disoriented by the flash, here is the short moment where Carter’s award-winning, life-changing, story crux photograph becomes available. As your eyes refocus, you have the opportunity to enter the photograph meaningfully in the same way you had to choose to enter the microcosmic space of the installation. In the shock of the flash, you have access to the moment as if it were happening in real time. No lingering, no loitering, only the ephemeral glance.
As I re-entered the rest of the WITNESS exhibition, the once floating installation felt heavy behind me. In my exit, a part of me wanted that flash to connect to something. The feeling after a roller coaster ride where you search for your screaming photo at the gift shop. The flash as a tool to take, rudely snatching a moment and commodifying it, taking a moment without intervening, taking a moment and making it yours rather than the subject’s, the flash as a distraction from the human behind the camera.
Jaar’s piece added an essential depth to WITNESS, a newfound tone of reflection before facing the photographs again on the way out to the lobby. His imaginative interpretation of photography in a museum context was resonating, adding tight punctuation to the loose theme of the exhibition.
The installation proved as an utterly transformative space. A catalyst revealing the nuance of what is significant and insignificant about photography and a more refined approach to exploring the power of the photographical moment. Each photograph catalogued as a serial number in a tireless collection could carry the same richness or tragedy- but how could I know? Am I supposed to know? …Do I want to know?
Oh, and as for the photograph- I think you should see it yourself.
1,052 Comments
Absolutely pent subject matter, appreciate it for selective information JAMBITOTO
Your writing style is engaging and accessible, making complex concepts easy to understand.
game bài đổi thưởng
here is my offcial website where i am sharing technology, lifestyle and general article please visit here https://xabisinc.com/
Excellent and intriguing essay. Thank you very much! Thank you for sharing this outstanding content. run 3 is a blog that will help you recover your password and regain access to your account if you’ve lost it.
I am grateful for the impact your work has had on me. Nhà cái betgames
I am happy to find this post very useful for me ทางเข้าเล่น spade
I learned a lot from your blog, and you can learn more about older video games to have more engaging experiences. I look forward to playing with you in the past! retro games
Thank you a lot for sharing this with all folks you actually understand what you’re speaking about! Bookmarked. Please also visit my web site =).
We can have a link trade contract among us
Blogor Org
This article offers clear idea in support of the new people of blogging, that genuinely how to do running a blog.
슬롯사이트
Discover the powerful blend of Changa DMT at Alien Psychedelics. Changa DMT is a unique, smokeable mixture combining traditional herbs with DMT, offering a more grounded and extended experience than pure DMT. If you’re looking for Changa DMT for sale, Alien Psychedelics provides top-quality, lab-tested products for a safe and enlightening journey. Changa offers a smoother, longer-lasting effect, making it ideal for those wanting to explore the psychedelic realm at a more controlled pace. Embrace the spiritual benefits of Changa DMT today, and elevate your journey to new dimensions.
https://alienpsychedelics.com/product/changa-dmt/
I truly cherished perusing your online journal. It was extremely very much composed and straightforward. Not at all like different online journals I have perused which are truly not that good.Thanks alot! alexistogel
Slot Gacor Thailand menawarkan pengalaman bermain yang unik dengan sentuhan budaya Asia. Slot Gacor 88
Your writing resonated with me on a personal level, and I am thankful for the connection it fostered. kiemtienonline
This was incredibly informative and well-written. Thanks for the knowledge! 우리카지노
Today, we’re going to delve into the life and career of the legendary wrestler, Kevin Von Erich
Thanks for your personal marvelous posting! explore all about King Javien Conde
PG SLOT, authentic copyright from the direct website, frequent bonus breaks, bet with no minimum. ติดต่อทีมงาน igoal
Your article has left a lasting impression on me, and I am grateful for the opportunity to learn from your work.
หวยบี
จิลิ สล็อต ได้ออกแบบให้สามารถเล่น สล็อตเว็บตรง JILI ผ่านมือถือทุกที่ ทุกเวลา ภาพและเสียง ออกแบบมาเพื่อเล่นผ่านมือถือโดยเฉพาะ คมชัด ไม่ต่างจากเล่นผ่าน คอมพิวเตอร์ เล่นได้ทั้ง iOS และ Android
Seeing the works of Kerry James Marshall and Cindy Sherman in the MCA exhibition really gave me a new understanding of photography. I found some channels on Telegram 中文that focus on art reviews and exhibition analysis, and there are many discussions on how to interpret artworks, which is very helpful.
The “Witness” exhibition made me rethink the meaning of photography by showing the artist’s gaze and the stories behind the photos. I also found many similar exhibition discussions in the art group on TG纸飞机电报中文官网. Everyone shared their understanding and feelings about the exhibition theme, and the communication was very interesting.
The theme connection in the exhibition reminded me of some creative activities, such as Scrabble. If you also like this kind of art exhibition, you can consider joining some art-related discussion groups on TG中文语言包, where there are often similar creative activities and discussions, which can inspire many new ideas.
Nice info
Solar panels
Good day! Very interesting. Thank you for the information.Also visit my web blog ฝากจอดรถยนต์อุบล
The depth of research and clarity of presentation in your writing are remarkable. sòng bạc online
It’s a very interesting website. Came here to read the information shared.
โรงแรมรถอุบล
Today, we’re diving into the story of Paul Inouye Wife, exploring her background, interests, and her life with Paul.
Dr. Rohan Deshmukh is the best eye specialist in Ambernath, renowned for his expertise in advanced ophthalmic treatments. With over 15 years of experience, Dr. Deshmukh offers comprehensive eye care, including LASIK, cataract surgery, and pediatric ophthalmology. His clinic in Ambernath is equipped with state-of-the-art technology, ensuring accurate diagnoses and effective treatments. Patients trust Dr. Deshmukh for his personalized care and dedication to preserving and enhancing vision.
Og Blatancy Is The Creator Of Only Original Music 365. He Is A Internationally Acclaimed Multi-Platinum Rated Composer. https://soundcloud.com/onlyoriginalmusic/epoch
Are you looking for Best Effluent Treatment Plant Manufacturer in India? Look no further than TR Aqua Private Limited, we are a leading ETP Plant Manufacturer and Supplier in India.
Are you looking for Best Dust Collector Manufacturer in India? Look no further than Ventilair India Private Limited, we are a leading Dust Collector Manufacturer and Supplier in India.
I know this is one of the most meaningful information for me. And I’m animated reading your article. But should remark on some general things, the website style is perfect; the articles are great. Thanks for the ton of tangible and attainable help. top handyman service providers Sharjah
It’s not only informative but also engaging, providing valuable insights that keep the reader interested throughout. Visit for more :- Shrink Wrapping Machine Manufacturer
Looking for Best Grain Storage Silos Manufacturer in India? Look no further than Prairies Partners Global Solution, we are a leading Grain Storage Silos Manufacturer and Supplier in India.
Searching for Best Bioreactor Manufacturer in Ghaziabad, India? Look no further than Instech Pharma, we Instech Pharma is a leading Bioreactor Manufacturer and Supplier in India.
I was taking a gander at some of your posts on this site and I consider this site is truly informational! Keep setting up.. megah138
Discover top-notch eye care services in Ghatkopar with our leading eye clinic, renowned for excellence in eye health. Our skilled eye surgeons specialize in advanced retina treatments, ensuring optimal vision and care. As the best eye clinic in Ghatkopar, we offer comprehensive services from routine check-ups to complex surgeries, utilizing the latest technology for precise diagnostics and effective treatments. Trust us for all your eye care needs and experience exceptional care and expertise in every visit.
A debt of gratitude is in order for giving late reports with respect to the worry, I anticipate read more. megah138
Thanks for taking the time to discuss that, 918KISS WALLET
I advise pupils to take full advantage of this website. JILI WALLET
healthcare providers employ different people to handle เว็บหวยวอเลท
or shoot the cop before he catches you! MEGA888 AUTO
Imajinasi Anda adalah satu-satunya batasan. สล็อตฝากถอนวอเลท
the filter’s large size means that it requires less frequent SLOTNAGA168
This is excellent content material for your personal visitors 918KISS AUTO WALLET
One of my last insights is that my decision to buy Instagram likes LIVE22 AUTO WALLET
innovative strategies in the realm of digital marketing. JILI WALLET
Hypnotizing to analyze. GALAXYBETSLOT
I wonder how much AI would take over in the next decade SLOTXO WALLET
bisa bikin betah dan juga ada banyak promo lagi, JOKER WALLET