1. “[…] an extended use of the adjectival form [cultural] in more specialist and academic languages. And whole fields of knowledge are now described as cultural. If cultural studies and cultural critique led the way here, the fields of cultural psychology, cultural history, cultural geography, and cultural evolution have followed in short order as part of the more general cultural turn in the humanities and social sciences.” (Bennett, 64)
2. “While criticism in its most general sense developed towards censure, criticism in its specialized sense developed toward taste, cultivation, and later culture and discrimination.” (Williams, 85)
“The notion that response was judgment depended, of course, on the social confidence of a class and later a profession. The confidence was variously specified, originally as learning or scholarship, later as cultivation and taste, later still as sensibility. […] Criticism becomes ideological not only when it assumes the position of the consumer but also when it masks this position by a succession of abstractions of its real terms of response.[…] The point would then be […] to get rid of the habit, which depends, fundamentally, on the abstraction of response from its real situation and circumstances: the elevation to ‘judgment,’ and to an apparently general process, when what always needs to be understood is the specificity of the response, which is not an abstract ‘judgment’ but even where including, as often necessarily, positive or negative responses, a definite practice, in active and complex relations with its whole situation and context.” (Williams, 86)
3. Three broad active categories of usage [of culture]: (i) the independent and abstract noun which describes a general process of intellectual, spiritual, and aesthetic development, (ii) the independent noun, whether used generally or specifically, which indicates a particular way of life, whether of a people, a period, a group, or humanity in general, and (iii) the independent and abstract noun which describes the works and practices of intellectual and especially artistic activity. (Williams, 90)
4. “[…] involving claims to superior knowledge, refinement, and distinctions between ‘high’ art (culture) and popular art and entertainment.” (Williams, 92)
5. “Criticism is or ought to be a cognitive activity and that it is a form of knowledge.” (Said, 224)
6. “What matters is the criticism to which such an ideological complex is subjected by the first representatives of the new historical phase. This criticism makes possible a process of differentiation and change in the relative weight that the elements of old ideologies used to possess. What was previously secondary and subordinate, even incidental, is now taken to be primary- becomes the nucleus of a new ideological and theoretical complex. The old collective will dissolve into its contradictory elements since the subordinate ones develop socially.” (Samuel, 237)
7. “Or should we rather bring the sword of criticism to criticism itself and do a bit of soul-searching here: what were we really after when we were so intent on showing the social construction of scientific facts? Nothing guarantees, after all, that we should be right all the time. There is no sure ground even for criticism. Isn’t this what criticism intended to say: that there is no sure ground anywhere?” (Latour, 227)
8. “If this were possible then we could let the critics come ever closer to the matters of concern we cherish, and then at last we could tell then: ‘Yes, please, touch them, explain them, deploy them.’” (Latour, 248)
9. “These ideas have a special interest for critics today who may wish to place themselves skeptically between culture as a massive body of self-congratulating ideas and system or method, anything resembling a sovereign technique that claims to be free of history, subjectivity, or circumstance. […] If it is not to be merely a form of self-validation, criticism must intend knowledge and, what’s more, it must attempt to deal with, identify, and produce knowledge as having something to do with will and with reason.” (Said, 202)
WHAT: A Broad Topic, but Concrete Talks
Williams discusses culture and criticism separately, but the discussions when taken together can help us shed new lights on cultural criticism as a whole. On the one hand, he redefines “culture” by investigating its genealogy, and on the other hand, he sets up requirements for “criticism.”
As for culture, Williams traces its usage to the 17th century when it still meant the tending of natural growth, and summarizes three main definitions of “culture” that derived throughout time, from the general process of intellectual, spiritual, and aesthetic development, to a particular way of life, to the work and practices of intellectual activity.
More importantly, after delineating the development of what the term “culture” refers to, Williams points out that we are not to favor one definition over another by choosing the one that is “true,” “proper,” or “scientific,” but should note and take into account the range and overlap of meanings. In understanding the term “culture,” he highlights the importance of acknowledging its complexity, such as its indication in the duality in material and symbolic production, and the significance of studying the relations between the different meanings.
That said, Williams broadens the subject of cultural criticism by pointing out the complexity that lies in the term “culture.” As a result, criticism of “culture” would not be limited to the usual sense, that is on the artistic activities and products, but also the ways of lives that people lead, and even the general process of human development.
As for criticism, Williams criticizes how criticism is conducted as an abstract judgement, and proposes that it should be about the “specificity […] in active and complex relations with its whole situation and context.”
That is, Williams requires criticism to be specific to both the subject itself and its context, and accordingly provide concrete responses instead of vague judgments.
HOW: One Name, Multiple Jobs
A critic is a teacher, a proxy, a criticizer, a coordinator, and more. With knowledge and taste, he leads its readers into the world of literature, music, and drama (Mendelsohn). With time and attention, he set up connections with the pieces, and convey his private experience to his readers (Ventura). With guts and insights, he points out the faults and pushes the development in the field where his passion lies (Garner). With his presence, as the representative of the spectator, he completes the art work (Schwabsky).
What I would like to elaborate here, however, is the critic as a philosopher. While Said acknowledges neither Derrida and Foucault is a literary critic, he introduces their ideas to explain literary criticism, which pursue philosophical inquiries.
Both Derrida and Foucault describe culture as influenced by some dominant force. Derrida’s idea of the “culture” in discussion is the Western culture which forms a “cultural domination” centering “metaphysics and its hierarchies,” manifested in “texts” ranging from Plato to Heidegger. Foucault sees the production of culture governed by “discourses,” which he describes as “impersonal, systematic, and highly regulated by enuciative formations.” (Said, 186)
Their criticism of culture, then, serves to challenge the authorities and influences exerted on it, whether it is the “metaphysics,” or the “discourses”. For Derrida, it is to uncover the “silent complicity between the superstructural pressures of metaphysics and an author’s ambiguous innocence about a detail at base level.” He stands up to challenge logocentric fallacies, such as “the nostalgia for presence,” (Said, 190) pointing out that language can never bring about presence, but is always representation. For Foucault, it is to make the text “assume its affiliation with institutions, offices, agencies, classes, academics, corporations, groups, guilds, ideologically defined parties and professions” by “redefining and reidentifying the particular interests that al texts serve.” (Said, 212) That is, he points out that the author is not isolated as he or she produces a text, but placed in a specific historical, social, and political context, all of which influences him or her. Thus it is not sufficient to understand the text in isolation, but should take into account the context, examine the influences, and decipher the meanings hidden due to these influences.
Both Derrida’s and Foucault’s stances encourage cultural critics to detach themselves from the dominate culture, challenge the orthodox way of thinking, and produce knowledge, which is contentious. In this sense, when producing a description of the original text, the critic, stripping away or at least acknowledging the forces acted upon the text, gets closer to the meaning of the original text than the original text itself, as if he or she deciphers it.
AND THEN: The Power of Words
The articles provide a broad range of understandings of culture, including subjects from literature (Said) to social conditions (Latour). While addressing different subjects, they all point out the radical power in criticism: Instead of cultivating “taste” on high arts, or arguing to favor some preferences over others, they describe criticism as a way to inform, as an intellectual inquiry in search of the true meanings of texts, and even as a weapon to bring about revolutions.
That said, the articles all convey the idea that words and understandings have power, and criticism has the capacity to alter, form, and communicate understandings. Just as orthodox beliefs constrain the way people think, criticism challenging these beliefs liberates them, or at least make them conscious about the restraint. From the words of critics, then, readers are taught, connected, and even intellectually challenged.
Key words
1. Authority: Authority bear different senses in the discussions. On the one hand, critics need to possess some sort of “authority,” that is, trust based on credential, in order to present their ideas to the viewers. On the other hand, critics, as Derrida and Foucault would argue, challenges the authorities, that is the established ideas.
2. Power: Critics, at least in idea, have the power of words. They make judgments or claims, which exerts influence on people given critics have the authority, and the people in turn carry out activities. In short, the production of authoritative ideas has the power to influence actions.
3. Knowledge: On the one hand, critics need knowledge in order to make judgments and provide responses. On the other hand, critics produce knowledge in their judgments and responses.
609 Comments
Hanya Dengan Menggunakan 1 user ID saja Anda sudah bisa Memainkan Semua Permainan Yang Anda Di Game Slot Online Yang Kami Sediakan. Maka dari itu Anda tidak perlu khawatir akan mengalami kerugian selama bermain di situs Madu88.
Situs Judi Online Bigo88 Telah diakui Sebagai Judi Online Terpercaya Diindonesia yang mampu memberikan Anda profit besar hanya dalam beberapa kali putaran permainan saja, jadi Anda tidak perlu takut untuk mengalami kekalahan selama bermain di situs Bigo88.
Gaspoll88 is aSlot Gacor Hari Ini game site that provides wins in every game and the best service among other online slot provider sites.
I’m truly enjoying the design and layout of your site. 카지노사이트
It’s a very easy on the eyes which makes it much more enjoyable for me to come here and visit more often. 바카라사이트
Did you hire out a designer to create your theme? Exceptional work! 바카라사이트
Thank you so much for this excellent blog article. 먹튀검증
I believe it is a lucky site
비아그라구입처
Thank you dear friends, Keep forward and support us. We need more valuable information. keep it up.메이저놀이터
At CryptoRobotics, we understand that security is paramount when it comes to handling your hard-earned assets. We employ robust security measures and industry-standard encryption protocols to safeguard your funds and personal information. Our platform undergoes regular audits and assessments to ensure the highest level of security.
It gives in depth information. Thanks for this valuable information for all,.. This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free.
안전놀이터
토토사이트, also known as Toto sites, are online platforms that provide a space for sports betting enthusiasts to place wagers on various sporting events.
thanks for sharing this beautiful blog키톤벳
Thank you for consistently delivering high-quality posts! Your dedication to your readers is evident, and it’s truly appreciated. Buy gmail business email price from gmail business email price
Situs kudabet merupakan Agen Slot Terpercaya Di Indonesia dan paling populer nomor 1 di Indonesia, selain itu tingkat kemenangan yang besar juga sudah menjamin kemenangan Anda selama bermain, malah Anda akan memperoleh peruntungan yang besar hanya dengan bermain pada disitus kudabet.
Online slots today can be played directly using credit deposits which provide lots of benefits for members
https://slot-pulsa-gacor.azurefd.net/
Easy-to-win online slots are available here, which are sure to provide lots of advantages for members https://slotonlines.azurefd.net/
As of my last update in September 2021, there was no specific information available on a topic called “aw8.” It is possible that “aw8” refers to something that has emerged or become relevant after my last update, or it could be a specialized term or acronym not widely recognized in the general context.
This blog is an amazing one, the contents here are always very educative and useful, the reason I make it my regular blog of visit so as to widen my knowledge every day, thanks for always sharing useful and interesting information, you can checkout this I’ve always wondered about this! Loved your advice!! Thanks so much for sharing your expertise 🙂
Regards :
Get top-quality kids furniture at Playfurn’s online furniture store in Karachi. Check the best Kid’s beds, chairs, and tables. Affordable prices. Visit Now!
Agen Slot Bambu99 dikenal sebagai web judi Agen Betting yang telah berlanglang buana sejak tahun 2018 di Indonesia. Kepuasan semua bettor adalah visi dan arah kami didukung dari segi servis dan keamanan.
Selamat Bergabung Di Slot Online Indonesia Di Situs Gaspoll88 Agen Slot Online Terpercaya No 1 Di Indonesia, Siapa Yang Tidak Kenal dengan nama situs yang 1 ini Gaspoll88 Adalah Agen Bandar Game Slot Gacor Thailand 2023 yang memiliki banyak hadiah yang bisa anda dapatkan. Dapatkan bocoran Game Slot Gacor di situs Kami untuk menunjang kemenangan Anda saat bermain, Dengan Menggunakan Sistem Prediksi yang kami sedia kan untuk member kami di gaspoll88.
Judi slot online yang paling terkenal menggunakan server Kamboja saat ini adalah Bigo88, dengan trik mereka mendapatkan kemenangan maxxwin hanya dalam sekejap, Jadi tunggu apalagi segera Bergabung di situs kami yang satu ini banyak bonus dan hadiah yang sedang menanti anda.
Di Jaring88 agen slot gacor selalu menyediakan permainan Fair to play, oleh karena itu anda tidak akan merasa tertipu oleh kami. Jaring88 slot juga tentunya sudah berlisensi Internasional jadi tentunya anda bisa bermain dengan enjoy dan senang pastinya. Kemenangan yang anda dapatkan dari taruhan – taruhan Yang lakukan akan kami bayar 100% murni.
The importance of Dubai has grown recently as a tourist and investment destination, drawing the attention of citizens of the world.
https://msknk.com/en/apartment-for-sale-in-dubai/
The importance of Dubai has grown recently as a tourist and investment destination, drawing the attention of citizens of the world.
This concept is a good way to enhance knowledge and will be recommended this information to my friends. Thanks for explaining it perfectly continue to share your knowledge through articles like these, and keep posting more blogs.
Regards:Digital Marketing Agency With Incredible Results
https://msknk.com/villas-for-sale-in-sharjah/Sharjah is the capital of the United Arab Emirates and is located on the Persian Gulf. It has many fun activities for the whole family. One can explore one of the wonderful gardens,
Looking for the best PTECoaching in Brisbane? Our guide provides comprehensive tips and resources to choose the right one. Click here!
Playing online slots has become iconic in the world of judi, so you can slot dana now use online judi anywhere in the world, making it easy to win big.
feel the sensation of playing online only here you can play the most perfect online games and only here you can play all online games with just one id, of course the site slot online terpercaya gives you the best.
Of course, if you want to get big wins, you have to join and play games on our / slot kamboja gacor site which will definitely give you big wins easily.
This blog is really very informative and helpful for us. i would like to recommend it to breast pump
. Most importantly, Having Information makes it easy to choose the best online khasino, so don’t wait for American jackpot players to take a look. Because scams are frequently posted on the Internet, it is very important that we know our surroundings raja slot online.
Your words evoke an expanse of emotions. Your unique insights add color to the discussion. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and contributing to this vibrant exchange.
Regards:AC maintenance
Thank you very much for this article. It explains everything I need to know! This article is so peaceful and easy to understand.
Excellent aspects as well as fine points imparted in this condensed content. Awaiting more posts such as this one.
Glitz life care
Acne-Face Wash
Hello, everyone! I am John Doe, an enthusiastic entrepreneur. Today, I am thrilled to introduce you about Mughal Labs – a premier medical diagnostic lab facility dedicated to elevating the standards of diagnostic excellence.
Eyes are a gift we all possess. Due to eye conditions or continual use of high-tech equipment, we need to wear eyeglasses. We also need to wear sunglasses to shield our eyes from UV rays and harsh sunshine. Design is now also essential. EASYSIGHT is the only response to all of your vision-related needs because we also take care of your eyes and looks.
Buruan gabung dipermainan Gampang menang dan serun bonusnya pun melimpah.
Daftar Slot Gacor segera dan dapatkan ID PRO VIP dijamin MAXWIN.
RTP tinggi rata rata di atas 95% dijamin mudah menang tanpa harus buypin.
Situs Perdana138 adalah game slot terbaik yang berlisensi Resmi dari Pagcor sehingga sudah pasti situs ini sangat aman untuk dikunjungi.
Bonus yang diberikan situs Perdana138 ini memiliki TO rendah dengan sistem Betingan.
Your post provides valuable information. It’s evident that you’ve put a lot of effort into this and I’d love to hear your thoughts on it. Keep up the great work!
Best Regards: Johnathon Dave Online Medical Books Store
I wonder why the other experts of this sector don’t notice this. You must continue your writing. I’m sure, you’ve a huge readers’ base already! want to learn more? click the link here
바카라사이트
I would appreciate you that you pick up an important topic to write a thoroughly informative post on. I hope that you never stop and keep posting such valuable content
카지노사이트
Thanks for sharing This is really inspiring and I love to read more about this 카지노사이트
I will recommend your website to everyone. You have a very good gloss. Write more high-quality articles. I support you. 카지노사이트
Dear Yiran Wang,
I wanted to extend my sincerest appreciation for your thought-provoking essay, “The Critics: With the Power of Words.” Your exploration of the relationship between culture, criticism, and power was not only enlightening but also skillfully presented.
Your essay offered a comprehensive analysis of the complex interplay between culture and criticism, drawing from various scholars and thinkers to provide a holistic view of the subject. I was particularly impressed by your discussion of Raymond Williams’ insights into the evolving definitions of culture and the importance of acknowledging their complexity. Your emphasis on the need to consider the context and specificity in criticism resonated deeply with me, highlighting the importance of providing concrete responses rather than abstract judgments.
Furthermore, your essay delved into the multifaceted roles of critics, portraying them as teachers, proxies, coordinators, and philosophers. The inclusion of Derrida and Foucault’s philosophical perspectives on culture and criticism added depth to your argument, emphasizing the transformative power of critical thinking and analysis.
I found your exploration of the power of words in criticism to be particularly compelling. Your essay effectively conveyed how criticism has the capacity to challenge orthodox beliefs, liberate minds, and bring about revolutions. It underscored the idea that words and understandings hold significant power in shaping perspectives and influencing actions.
Your essay was a rich and insightful exploration of cultural criticism, and I commend you for your meticulous research and eloquent presentation. It has provided me with valuable insights into the world of criticism and its profound impact on culture and society.
Thank you once again for sharing your knowledge and perspectives on this important topic.
Warm regards,
Thanks Message From Udham Singh Nagar
918kissautorizontally will then cas you can vg (build) your own component. In Google Webshared
We s