“For all criticism is based on that equation: KNOWLEDGE + TASTE = MEANINGFUL JUDGMENT. The key word here is meaningful. People who have strong reactions to a work—and most of us do—but don’t possess the wider erudition that can give an opinion heft, are not critics. (This is why a great deal of online reviewing by readers isn’t criticism proper.) Nor are those who have tremendous erudition but lack the taste or temperament that could give their judgment authority in the eyes of other people, people who are not experts. (This is why so many academic scholars are no good at reviewing for mainstream audiences.) …The role of the critic, I repeat, is to mediate intelligently and stylishly between a work and its audience; to educate and edify in an engaging and, preferably, entertaining way. (Critics, more than any other kind of writer, should have a sense of humor.)” – Daniel Mendelsohn
“What the critic has to give is the fruits of looking laggardly, an attention that appears in increasingly lesser quantities today, a long and sustained commitment to coaxing meaning from mute objects. Though we “pay” attention, our attention need not be regulated by the industrial logic of clock time. What the critic has to offer is her own subjectivity, her own careful, glacial experience of a work of art, especially ones that do not immediately break open to the spectator’s gaze…But for now, what I’m calling for is criticism as temporary communion rather than appraisal. A criticism that’s slow, descriptive, subjective, a criticism that values process and experience over judgement and whose language is as intricate as its looking. Our eyes still have to adjust. We have to slow down. We have to lose ourselves.” – Anya Ventura
Most people have experiences with cultural criticism through critiques on writings, films, music, dances and many other different forms of art. The questions are: Who are the critics and what are they criticizing for? What are they supposed to do for us? There are certainly a number of different opinions on what cultural criticism is and what a cultural critic does.
The quotes above from Daniel Mendelsohn and Anya Ventura represent two of the different opinions on cultural criticism and critics. They both agree in their view of the critic as a positive force for both an artwork and its audiences. On the contrary, while Mendelsohn sees the critic as someone who edifies and educates its audience and provides judgment, Ventura sees the critic as someone who helps other spectators to focus slow attention toward an artwork. Together, both views shed light on whether the critic’s priority is to provide a judgment on a work, or to evoke a slow, descriptive attention toward work.
Mendelsohn sees the critic’s role in educating and edifying audience by providing a meaningful judgment through one’s critique. As the quote shows, he believes that a critic is someone who possess both knowledge and taste, or sensibility, that either of the scholars or the general spectators have. Therefore, in Mendelsohn’s view, a critic is positioned completely differently from both an artwork and its audience; he is the mediator who stays in between them to provide judgment. In this relationship, the critic’s priority is to judge an artwork.
On the other hand, Anya Ventura sees the critic as someone who assists spectators in slowly and attentively experiencing a work, before rushing to its judgment. Furthermore, she believes criticism to be a “temporary communion” rather than “appraisal.” Although Ventura’s view states critics as people who “offer” their own subjectivity or experience of a work of art to other spectators, and are therefore somewhat superior to the general spectators in experiencing art, they are never teachers or judges of art. Criticism, to Ventura, is the redirection of attention toward work of art, and the experience of work itself, rather than a judgment on a work of art.
Throughout both articles, judgment, or appraisal, emerges as one of the key issues in defining criticism. Mendelsohn puts the highest priority in judgment while Ventura stresses the importance of process and experience over judgment. The idea of judgment further opens up the discussion of the power relationship between the critic and a work’s audience. The idea of judgment is crucial since if one is believed to be in the position of judging something, that person obtains the power to rule something; however, that judgment can also be flawed. As Bruno Latour writes in “Why Has Critique Run Out of Steam?”, some critics write critiques that are at the level of groundless conspiracy theory. Therefore, as in Mendelsohn’s case, if the critic’s main goal is to judge a work of art and to teach its audience, there should be a more discussion on who is qualified to teach and judge, since teaching and judging are more dangerous than simply offering one’s subjectivity to help others better experience a work of art.
To sum up, Mendelsohn believes that the critic’s job is to provide a meaningful judgment capable through the critics’ expertise and taste in a work of art. Anya Ventura sees the cultural critic and the cultural criticism as something that puts process and experience of a work of art before the judgment of it. It is important, overall, to note that judging something and teaching someone should always be approached carefully, as wrong judgment and teachings would always be highly detrimental to the art of criticism.
- Anya Ventura, “Slow Criticism: Art in the Age of Post-Judgement,” Temporary Art Review, 15 February 2016, http://temporaryartreview.com/slow-criticism-art-in-the-age-of-post-judgement/
- Daniel Mendelsohn, “A Critic’s Manifesto,” New Yorker, 28 August 2012, http://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/a-critics-manifesto
- Bruno Latour, “Why Has Critique Run Out of Steam? From Matters of Fact to Matters of Concern,” Critical Inquiry30 (2004), 225–48.
1,514 Comments
Hi jaekim (I apologize for not knowing your real name),
I appreciated your post’s balance between Mendelsohn’s prioritization of judgement and Ventura’s emphasis on description, or the process. You intro paragraph nicely summarized the two, varying perspectives: “Together, both views shed light on whether the critic’s priority is to provide a judgment on a work, or to evoke a slow, descriptive attention toward work.” Comparing these two perspectives, I like how you emphasize the stakes of power in relation to judgement and the general audience. “The idea of judgment further opens up the discussion of the power relationship between the critic and a work’s audience.” Continuing this exploration, I’m curious: do you think there is a difference between power and authority, and if so, how does this difference mingle with the stakes of criticism?
Your final paragraph dips its toes in “wrong judgement.” What do you mean by this? Would you lean more towards Mendelsohn’s argument–wrong judgement is judgement that lacks knowledge? Or Ventura’s–judgement that lacks thorough description? Both? Neither? Somewhere in between?
Embark on an adrenaline-fueled journey with the only up game. This captivating mobile adventure takes you on a vertical thrill ride like no other. Overcome obstacles, collect rewards, and aim for the highest score as you ascend through various levels. Are you up for the challenge? Download “Only Up Game” now and conquer the skies!
your analysis beautifully navigates the contrasting viewpoints of Mendelsohn and Ventura on the critic’s role. It’s particularly insightful how you highlight the power dynamics surrounding judgment and the impact on the audience.
Expanding on your point about power and authority, I wonder if critics hold authority due to their expertise and experience, while wielding power through their judgments. Perhaps responsible criticism requires acknowledging the inherent power dynamic and ensuring judgments are grounded in both knowledge (Mendelsohn) and thorough analysis (Ventura).
Your mention of “wrong judgment” piques my curiosity. Could you elaborate on what constitutes a “wrong judgment” in your perspective? Does it encompass factual errors, biased interpretations, or a lack of nuance in the critical process?
Overall, this thoughtful exploration of contrasting critical perspectives opens up a multifaceted discussion on the purpose, ethics, and potential impact of criticism. Thank you for prompting such engaging reflection!
khalidelarbi
————————————
Online Marketing Analysis
business for sale
can you please do something about the spam? scrap car removal vancouver
Transform any glass surface into a canvas of creativity with a captivating Glass sticker – a chic way to elevate your space effortlessly!
I think your commentary on Ventura is insightful and thorough. I think that it is essential to have an appreciation of the experience and the construction in context. But, I think my main problem with this is access. It seems a bit elitist to assume that everyone is interested in the experience and construction, when that seems to be just one aspect of the art piece itself. However, this becomes more relevant and important because you outline the sensationalism that is apparent in criticism when you mention “conspiracy theory.” I think you did a good job presenting two contrasting arguments, and drawing distinctions between the two. In doing so, I think I learned more about the what two sides of in the battle for what criticism should be are.
Jeremy Lin and Jeremy Lin dream of teaming up, even the lockers are right next to each other
Jeremy Lin, who sparked “Linsanity” again in Taiwan’s Professional Basketball League (PLG) last season, will make his debut as a player for the New Taipei Kings tomorrow afternoon. After arriving in Taiwan today, he posted on social media again in the evening, describing the feeling of playing on the same team with his younger brother Lin Shuwei. Unbelievable, “This must be God’s blessing.” Lin Shuwei first helped his brother choose the location of the King’s Lounge. Two brothers live together.https://3a5688.com/
OC娛樂城
Jae,
This is a nice essay which begins to focus on the question of judgment as key to how our readings position cultural criticism. You nicely contrast Mendelsohn’s emphasis on the critic as a kind of expert authority compared to Ventura’s focus on process, in particular her urge for “slow criticism” in which attention gets stretched out more. Implicit here is that from time given to attention authority of a viewer/critic’s judgment emerges—anyone can do it. Whereas for Mendelsohn the authority emerges from a kind of expertise or training already in place prior to the experience of an artwork, and earned by only a select few. Of course there is time buried in that formulation as well: the time spent by the select few gaining their expertise; and you might probe the implicit uses of time that Mendelsohn overlooks in his piece.
As I’ve written to a few other students, I wonder if you might rethink your organization a bit. What if instead of organizing your essay by readings, you organize it by themes. Judgment is the overarching focus and then you might delve into subthemes (authority, time) and bring in your quotations around/within each sub theme. See if that brings out your own voice more boldly here and highlights your own judgment of the readings and the issues they raise more compellingly. But, that said, great start here!
Prof. Kramer
에볼플레이 먹튀검증 안전노리터1
https://mid-man.com/
ใช้ iphone 13 เล่นเมก้าเกม iphone 13เหมาะมากที่จะใช้เล่นเกมกับเว็บ megaslot เพราะเว็บของเราเป็นเว็บที่เสถียรเเละเเละเล่นง่าย ฝาก ถอน โอนไว ได้ผลตอบเเทนคืนเเน่นอน
Your article is very good, I have reread it many times cookie clicker
Really good valuable keep sharing with us. Thank you
best dentist
This seems so valuable post about critics and I love the content your share here. Really good and help keep sharing with us.
Right keep sharing with us valuable and informative content. Thank you
sheeter chair
Critical thinking is essential for erudition by critical thinking we can edify between bad prospective and the right prospective our professional essay writers deeply take care of critical thoughts.
The form tunnel rush is very nice, I was blown away when I saw them, I will give a good review on the appearance of the article
I am very happy to read this article. thanks for giving us nice info.
บริษัท igoal
This is a great post. lol beans is currently a stormy game among gamers. With the vivid 3D design, it promises to bring you moments of relaxation. Best of all, it’s free. As a result, you are free to play as many games as you like without having to pay any money.
I’ll give the article’s appearance a positive assessment. google
critical thinking is the Basic Skill which is Necessary for human development and this skill is listed in the GitHub blog you can navigate the right things at the right place with critical thinking.
Do My Essay
This is an excellent piece of writing. This is without a doubt one of the most impressive entries I’ve ever seen. Your work is remarkable, and it inspires me to do better. I admire you.
usps tracking
Chocovic hampers can be a hassle-free option for you. You will get something for everyone and every occasion. This Hot Air Balloon gift basket is in fashion and trendy. It is also environmentally friendly which gives this hamper a plus point. This hamper is a beautiful bag in the shape of a hot air balloon containing some of the best products of Chocovic. It gives a very homely feeling to the gift.
We have hot Sizzling Call Girls in Dwarka who make your night fun. We have Models, College Girls, Housewives and Russians
I thoroughly enjoyed reading it in my lunch time. Will surely come and visit this blog more often. Thanks for sharing assignment writing service
To write a compelling article or story, authors need keen senses and eyes, and they need to consider the subject in great detail flagle. Your article has left a very favorable impression on me.
Significance of Dissertation Help in University life
Surely you only know New York as a place of America, right? But now there is one more great game genre that you should experience: nytimes crossword
I’m truly enjoying the design and layout of your blog.
It’s a very easy on the eyes which makes it much more pleasant for me to come here http://j9korea.com and visit more often.
I have been looking for articles on these topics for a long time.
I don’t know how grateful you are for posting on this topic.
Thank you for the numerous articles on this site, I will subscribe to those links in my bookmarks and visit them often.
Have a nice day
제이나인 토토 사이트 도메인
제이나인 토토 사이트 순위
제이나인 토토 유저
제이나인 토토 일정
제이나인 온라인 카지노 순위
https://www.j9korea.com
This blog was really great, never seen a great blog like this before. i think im gonna share this to my friends. Blue Leather Jackets
no we are not they to teach and judge. RealcompOnline Sign In
Criticism has moral overtones. Judgement on the other hand is just “making a call”. RealcompOnline App
You have done a great job on this article. It’s very readable and highly intelligent. You have even managed to make it understandable and easy to read. You have some real writing talent. Thank you.
바카라사이트
An fascinating discussion is value comment. I think that it is best to write extra on this matter, it won’t be a taboo topic however generally people are not enough to talk on such topics.
카지노사이트
Great article with excellent idea!Thank you for such a valuable article. I really appreciate for this great information..
카지노사이트
Yes i am totally agreed with this article and i just want say that this article is very nice and very informative article.I will make sure to be reading your blog more.
카지노사이트
This is an excellent piece of writing. This is without a doubt one of the most impressive entries.
사설토토 ~
Greate article. Keep writing such kind of info on your page 먹튀검증
Im really impressed by it 카지노사이트넷
Your writing is perfect and complete. 카지노사이트킴
“Not many of you should become teachers, my fellow believers, because you know that we who teach will be judged more strictly.” KanTime Medicare
This verse is sandwiched between James’ instruction about the kind of faith that produces good works and his warnings about our words, so we should view it within that context.
Your writing is perfect and complete. majorsite However, I think it will be more wonderful if your post includes additional topics that I am thinking of. I have a lot of posts on my site similar to your topic. Would you like to visit once?
The post could be very informative many people need to examine this form of the post I’m also part of them and after studying always supply true evaluations however this is not my profession I’m a style clothier and also designed the and after the job, my first preference is studying this kind of put up. You can check my work by visiting this website
It promises to provide you with some moments of relaxation with its vivid 3D design. Most importantly, it’s free. Therefore, you are unrestricted in how many games you can play without having to pay any money. geometry dash
I’m curious to find out what blog system you joker gaming happen to be utilizing? I’m having some minor security issues with my latest site and I would like to find something more safeguarded. Do you have any suggestions?
I was recommended this website by joker my cousin. I am not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my trouble. You are amazing! Thanks!
I am really enjoying the theme/design เครดิตฟรี 50 of your web site. Do you ever run into any web browser compatibility problems? A number of my blog audience have complained about my website not operating correctly in Explorer but looks great in Firefox. Do you have any recommendations to help fix this problem?
I enjoyed the interesting post. It’s suddenly getting a lot colder. I hope you take care of your health and spend this winter well. If you are not busy, please visit my bloghttps://hostfiles.org
Criticism leads to betterment of an individual or team. A one should be brave enough to bear the criticisms. There are many websites that post content that how a one can bear the criticism. To have your own website you need to purchase a domain name.
Numerous thanks for a fascinating website internet site. What else may possibly I get that sort of data composed in this kind of a fantastic method? I have an enterprise that I am just now running on, Which i are already on the lookout for These types of info. pg betflik
I completely agree with you. That’s an excellent concept flagle
I thought of it for the first time in a long time, so I visited again. I checked that many posts have been updated. It’s still a blog that inspires me deeply. I am very grateful.메이저사이트
Thank you for this useful information, after reading this I have collected so much information about many things and about this page as well. Actually, I am a fashion blogger. You can check my work by visiting thiswebsite
Extremely pleasant article, I appreciated perusing your post, exceptionally decent share, I need to twit this to my adherents. Much appreciated!. Monthly Dripfeed
Complete Alexa top 1 million website list available for free according to alexa rank 2023 to discover the world’s most popular sites.
https://www.qqpqq.com/