-
The Interested Story-Teller
Alexander Hamilton walked down the ladder carrying a book in one arm and a sac in the other, curious and thrilled. He just finished the journey from an obscure Caribbean island to New York. He walked into the crowd, and vanished into the dark. The ensemble narrated,
“The ship is in the harbor now, see if you can spot him.
Another immigrant, comin’ up from the bottom.”
(“Alexander Hamilton”)
Hamilton and Burr each sat on a chair looking into distance, singing about their new born children. Coming back from the revolution they just won, they suddenly turned from fearless war heroes into helpless new fathers. Both being orphans, they so sang,
“My father wasn’t around. I swear that I’ll be around for you.
I’ll do whatever it takes. I’ll make a million mistakes.”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lakdWoM-5jU
(“Dear Theodosia”)
These are two scenes from the musical, Hamilton. Lin-Manuel Miranda, the mastermind behind the musical talked about how he related with Hamilton. Miranda’s family were immigrants from Puerto Rico living in New York. He grew up with the same American dream that Hamilton had: “In New York you can be a new man.” Also like Hamilton, he had a lonely childhood. Miranda’s father came to the United States for his PhD studies, and was busy raising the family. Miranda recalled how he “learned to keep [his] own company,” reading and writing. In 2014, as Miranda was writing the play, his son Sebastian was born.
It is then no surprise that Miranda signified these two episodes in Hamilton’s life in the play- and no surprise that Miranda decided to write about Hamilton in the first place. As I talked about the play with Professor Fitz, my other history professor, she said, “It is an amazing show, but the historian in me would sometimes jump out and say- this is not what I would stress in his life!”
That is to say, Miranda is telling a wonderful story, but it is by no means an objective story. In fact, there could be no “objective” stories be told: Even if Professor Fitz wrote her own version of Hamilton, it would inevitably betray her own point of view.
The point of view of the author leads to limits in observation. As Kant makes clear, every statement essentially has to be a judgment, with the potential to add “I think” to the front, for it necessary comes from a human perspective. Limited by our finiteness, we never see what happens when we are not looking, and we can never truly put ourselves in someone else’s shoes. That is, reality is always messier and more mysterious than any story.
Miranda himself made this clear in the song “The Room Where It Happens,” which talked about a deal Hamilton cut with Jefferson and Madison:
“No one else was in the
The room where it
happened.
No one really knows
how
The game is played.
The art of the trade,
How the sausage gets
made.
We just
Assume that it
Happens.”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NqG1rYXxo2I
(“The Room Where It Happens”)
Then Burr started narrating the situation, with every sentence starting with “Thomas claims,” for the only source was Jefferson’s account.
In addition to the subjectivity in observation, and more importantly, there is another layer of subjectivity in story-telling. Susan Sontag talks about photography as “selective transparency,” and prose and painting, “selective interpretation.” Even in photography which seemingly resembles the reality to the utmost degree, the artist necessarily selects. Sontag gives the example of Farm Security Administration photographic project, and how they “would take dozens of frontal pictures of one of their sharecroppers subjects until satisfied that they had gotten ‘just the right look’ on the film.” (Sontag, 6)
As a result, even if you get all the details right, the time, the action, you have the recording or the video tape, you cannot “simply” tell the story because every story, like every photograph, has a frame. The story-teller gets to posit the frame, from his or her own perspective even when unconsciously so. You pick and choose, zoom in and zoom out, and put things in order.
That is, as Bell Hooks sharply points out, the story-teller is always an interested one: the stance is always set already, however subtle. Miranda led us through Hamilton’s life, watching how hard he worked, and the human struggles he went through from loss of friends and family, to test on his fidelity. And such stance influences the audience: We are rooting for Hamilton because Miranda is, just like the audience was rooting for OJ Simpson because the press was (Hooks, On OJ Simpson).
-
Who Has the Mic: The Unevenly Distributed Story-Telling Power
George Washington, the man who was always taller than everyone else around him, spoke a monologue as everyone else froze:
“Now I’m the model of a modern major general,
the venerated Virginian whose men are all
Lining up, to put me up on a pedestal,
Writin’ letters to relatives
Embellishin’ my elegance and eloquence.”
(“Right Hand Man”)
Later, he told Hamilton:
“History has its eyes on you.”
(“History Has Its Eyes On You”)
For people like Washington and Hamilton, history indeed has its eyes on them: Today we still learn about them in textbooks, and even see their life’s anecdotes as important.
However, history does not have its eyes on most other people.
Before Washington entered the scene, the ensemble sang:
“Thirty-two thousand troops in New York harbor” – these were the silent thirty-two thousand. (“Right Hand Man”)
Before Thomas Jefferson came down the ladder, people in white gloves were busy pushing the ladder, and cleaning the floor and handle- these were the silent African slaves.
(“What Did I Miss”)
As Stuart Hall points out, the means of culture making is concentrated in the few, who makes the “power-bloc,” while the rest makes “the popular forces.” (Hall, 238) Bell Hooks draws the line with the term “white supremacist capitalist patriarchy,” which can shed light on both Hamilton and Washington’s time and our time (Hooks, “White Supremacist Capitalist Patriarchy”).
At Washington and Hamilton’s time, most women and African American were illiterate, and few people had the leisure to write, even fewer had access to publication. Even when literacy and access to publication are more prevalent today with basic education and internet, and thus people excluded from the dominant class are provided with instruments to tell their stories, the dominant class still, not unlike centuries ago, has the microphone for their stories to be heard, enshrined by the school and education system as well as literary and scholarly apparatus (Hall, 234).
-
The Redrawing of the Line: The Power of a Good Story
Although Hall stresses that the relationship between the power-bloc and the popular forces persists throughout history, he also acknowledges that on the one hand, it is not unilateral, and on the other hand, it is not static. The definitions that the power-bloc makes “do not function on us as we are blank screens,” as there are tension and resistance when the people carve out their space (Hall, 233). When they succeed, they redraw the line between the forces: “Today’s culture breaks can be recuperated as a support to tomorrow’s dominant system of values and meanings.” (Hall, 236)
Usually, the resistance and mobility are accomplished by a good story.
A man can be lifted by a good story, for the microphone does not only go to the powerful, but also goes to the extremely talented (and lucky, perhaps). Hamilton sang about his transformation from a penniless boy to the center of power:
“When I was seventeen a hurricane
Destroyed my town.
I wrote my way out,
Wrote everything down far as I could see.
I wrote my way out.
I looked up and the town had its eyes on me.
They passed a plate around.
Total strangers
Moved to kindness by my story.
Raised enough for me to book passage on a ship that was New York bound…
I wrote my way out of hell.
I wrote my way to revolution.”
(“Hurricane”)
A group of people can be recognized with a good story, for articulation, or the strive to be heard, is already resistance, and a good story humanizes and connects. In 2010, as a series of LGBT teenager suicides took place, thousands of LGBT people uploaded videos with the title “It Gets Better,” narrating their experience and encouraging the young. The population that supported same-sex marriage increased almost ten percent from 2010 to 2011 after the project (Fenrich, “It Gets Better”).
An art form can be transformed with a good story for the intertwining relationship between form and content. Miranda employed Hip-hop for the most of the musical Hamilton, applying an art form largely viewed as rebellious and popular to a mainstream “high art.” When he told President Obama that he was going to “rap about Hamilton,” Obama responded, “Good luck with that.” (Miranda, Hamilton’s America) However, as the form of hip-hop worked perfectly with the story of Hamilton, it is accepted by the world of musical.
Most of all, an ideology can come to dominance with a good story, for knowledge is linked to power (Said, 220). In Hamilton, Angelica Schuyler, Hamilton’s sister-in-law sang about how she read “‘Common Sense’ by Thomas Paine,” and wanted a “revelation” to have all men and women to be equals. Before “Common Sense,” changes were already taking place as the popular forces were demanding more power, and starting to grow skeptical about the system of difference and deference. However, it is only when a name and an account is given that a real change takes place: Only when empowered by the idea of “equality” can the unrest and discontent among the common acquire a standing point, and consequently thrive. And then a shoe-maker who was too nervous to meet John Hancock before revolution could ten years later stop a gentry from beating a child on the street, and tell the gentry “I am as good in credit in town as you.” (Fitz, “The American Revolution”)
As a result, although the power relations between the power-bloc and the popular might remain, the line can be redrawn, and the population included can expand. Our time seems to show some promising characteristics. On the one hand, with the democratizing means such as the internet, the power of story-telling while still unevenly distributed is spreading broader. On the other hand, with the idea of democracy, today we are having more debates to include the people into the narrative, just as Eliza, Hamilton’s wife sang in “That would be enough”: “Oh, let me be a part of the narrative, in the story they will write someday,” and just as people posed questions whether Hamilton and the movie Lincoln are making history all about the great men, and neglecting the part of the commons, from the soldiers fighting and dying for the revolution, to the slaves risking their lives to run to Union line for their freedom. That is to say, on the one hand the people have more power to make announcements that they can be heard, on the other hand have more support of public opinion that they should be heard.
-
The Role of the Audience and the Critic
Washington gave Hamilton his last lesson: “You have no control who lives who dies who tells your story.” (“History Has Its Eyes On You.”) I see the core question of the play in this sentence:
“Who tells the story?”
On this question, I agree with Pauline Kael on the affirmation of subjectivity: Everyone should tell their stories (Haberski Jr., 122). Both Hamilton and an unknown soldier should write their diaries.
As everyone tells their stories, we would be constantly receiving numerous subjectivities; As power still concentrates in the hands of the few, the attention would be disproportionally directed to them. Knowing all stories would be subjective, we should not dismiss the subjectivity but instead look at them critically: A comprehensive understanding of the world requires not only the information people deliver, but also the context of the information. Then the people should be consciously aware that all information comes from a finite and interested human, thus nothing should be taken as absolute truth but rather be put back into the context. In a sense, all audience ideally turn into critics.
As the people have the responsibility to equip themselves with literacy and critical thinking (Hooks, “Transformation”), the critic now shoulders the responsibility to inform and empower. On the one hand, they should “reveal the exact places- and displacement” of the numerous subjectivities, parsing out the power relations and accounting for where everyone comes from (Said, 221). On the other hand, they should specifically point out the power-bloc, and promote the voices of the marginalized since voice directly relates to power. While accounts that center around the powerful are “realistic truth” in the sense that the world, indeed, is centered around those who have tremendously more leverage than others, and it would be ignorant to deny the influence of power and give everyone an equal stance, it is valuable to land on some “affirmative truth” to prevent the vicious cycle of marginalization. That is, the critic should pay special attention to the marginalized, give them the microphone and help them be heard. In fact, Miranda set an example of “affirmative truth”: His cast was mostly non-white, including all the founding fathers, for he believed that the cast should represent what America is really like with all its diversity. He devoted much attention to the talent and dedication of women, from the wit of Angelica Schuyler to the selfless contribution Eliza Hamilton made for anti-slavery movement and social services. In other words, the critic navigates the audience on where the stories come from, and contributes in shaping how the stories should be.
An inquiry into Hamilton substantiates the idea that stories, told by all the interested story-tellers reflect power, and that the stories have power. Then in a time when we value diversity and equality, stories provide an approach to aid to such ends: To democratize stories, so that everyone has a voice, and everyone can be empowered by his or her voice.
Bibliography:
- Lin-Manuel Miranda, Hamilton the Revolution. (The source for all lyrics)
- Lin-Manuel Miranda, Hamilton’s America. Documentary.
- Susan Sontag, On Photography.
- Bell Hooks, Cultural Criticism and Transformation.
- Edward W. Said, The World, The Text, and the Critic.
- Hall Stuart, People’s History and Socialist Theory.
- Raymond J. Haberski Jr., It’s Only a Movie!: Films and Critics in American Culture.
- Lane Fenrich, “U.S Gay and Lesbian History.” Lecture.
- Caitlyn Fitz, “North America and the United States to 1865.” Lecture.
4,863 Comments
İstediğiniz her rengi ve modeli yapıyoruz Ödeme havale EFT şeklindedir Siparişe ödeme yapıldıktan sonra başlanır Sipariş süresi 15 ile 20 gün arasıdır Dünya nın heryerine kargo gönderimi mevcuttur. Sarı renk kesmiş olduğumuz ipi, krem renk kesmiş olduğumuz iplerin altına yerleştiriyoruz ve makrome kare düğümleri yaparak örüyoruz. Sepete Ekle. Gerekli alanlar ile işaretlenmişlerdir. Renk Seçenekli Makrome Örgü Anahtarlık Model 2 Söz Nişah Düğün Hediyelik Marka: Eymen Dizayn. Favorilere Ekle. Ürün 4cm uzunluğunda, alt kısmı ise 2.5cm dir. Makrome İpi Fiyatları ve Makrome Malzemeleri Hobipop. Kartlı Makrome Anahtarlık 12,00 ₺ 300 Gr kağıt üzerine kişiye özel baskı yapılmaktadır. Makrome Anahtarlık Kartları ve Makrome Anahtarlık Kartları Fiyatları. Makrome anahtarlık yapımı. En az 10 ad ve üzeri şipariş alınır. siteden kredi kartı yada eft ile almalısınız. 102 Numara Kırık Beyaz 3 mm Tek Büküm Taranabilir Makrome İpi. Çeşitli çalışmalarda kullanacağınız çok güzel bir model. Plastik Makrome Kasnak Üçe bölünebilir. Makrome Anahtarlık Bu videoda farklı kalınlıklarda pamuk iplerle yapabileceğiniz, 3 çeşit makrome anahtarlık modelini anlattım. Anahtarlık Art ve Craft. 9,75 TL. 1 no metal keten 2 no metal keten 3 no metal keten anahtarlik. 39,99 TL. Kişiye özel isim etiketi tasarlanarak istediğiniz isim tarih not yazılabilir. Hepsi el emeği. Detaylar fark yaratır. Makrome Balık Modeli Anahtarlık 30 Adet Makrome Balık Modeli Anahtarlık 30 Adet 177,00 TL Kodu: TRATL Üretici: Trend Atölye Durumu. kişiye özel olduğu için kapıda ödemeli gönderilmez. Üzerine makrome anahtarlık mevcuttur. Makrome Anahtarlık Yapımı İçin Halka Kasnak 4 adet Diğer Kapı Süsleri Modelleri ve Fiyatları için sonuç bulundu.
Hello, I’m new here and I’d want to share some information with you about the game. The finest drift boss game for females and young people has just been released, and while most people play it to kill time, I too used to play it.
Thanks for sharing this blog! If someone around you Looking for Operations Management Assignment Help, you can get the best Operations Management Assignment Help with top experts. The Student Helpline offers you best assignment in Uk with top 500+ experts. Our experts are working for you 24*7. We always deliver you best quality content at lowest price.
Yellowstone Jackets care for your fashion requirements. We uphold the premium quality Josh Lucas yellowstone that bring you a new style.
I’m checking out your site for the first time, and I must say that it’s great and very beneficial for kids. You’re doing an outstanding job, and I’ll be returning soon. Online Clothing Store Good luck in the future.
Your explanation is organized very easy to understand!!! I understood at once. Could you please post about bitcoincasino ?? Please!!
Sometimes life is not as fair as you think, but how you choose to deal with that unfairness is the way you choose. iscribble
I found this blog. For what you have suggested to us,
I have found some new data in your post, all things considered.
The cerebrum is incredibly satisfying and I am all thanks to the astonishing degree of your article.
제이나인 스포츠 토토 배당률
제이나인 스포츠 토토 승부 식
제이나인 승부 식 토토
제이나인 토토 도메인
제이나인 토토 먹튀
https://www.j9korea.com
Thanks for sharing this blog! If someone around you Looking for Social Media Marketing Dissertation Help, You can get the best Social Media Markeitng Dissertation Help by top experts. The Stuent Helpline offers you best quality assignment helpin Uk with top 500+ experts. Our expert are working for you 24*7. We always deliver you best quality content at lowest price.
I’m truly enjoying the design and layout of your blog.
It’s a very easy on the eyes which makes it much more pleasant for me to come here 제이나인 먹튀 검증 소
and visit more often.
I’m truly enjoying the design and layout of your blog.
It’s a very easy on the eyes which makes it much more pleasant for me to come here 제이나인 카지노 커뮤니티
and visit more often.
I am a seasoned leather jacket supplier to the entire world. For your specific needs, we have skilled artisans who can create Custom Leather Jackets. Buy Men’s Jacket
You have done a great job on this article. It’s very readable and highly intelligent. You have even managed to make it understandable and easy to read. You have some real writing talent. Thank you.
바카라사이트
An fascinating discussion is value comment. I think that it is best to write extra on this matter, it won’t be a taboo topic however generally people are not enough to talk on such topics.
카지노사이트
Great article with excellent idea! Thank you for such a valuable article. I really appreciate for this great information..
카지노사이트
Yes i am totally agreed with this article and i just want say that this article is very nice and very informative article. I will make sure to be reading your blog more.
카지노사이트
I recently found much useful information in your website especially this blog page. Among the lots of comments on your articles. Thanks for sharing.
온라인카지노
Very good points you wrote here.. Great stuff…I think you’ve made some truly interesting points. Keep up the good work.
온라인카지노
Your blog provided us with valuable information to work with. Each & every tip of your post is awesome. Thanks a lot for sharing. Keep blogging.
카지노
Thanks you very much for sharing these links. Will definitely check this out..
바카라
First of all, thank you for your post. slotsite Your posts are neatly organized with the information I want, so there are plenty of resources to reference. I bookmark this site and will find your posts frequently in the future. Thanks again ^^
I enjoyed reading a good article. It was very helpful and gave me some good information. 카지노사이트킴
I have been looking for articles on these topics for a long time.
I don’t know how grateful you are for posting on this topic.
Thank you for the numerous articles on this site,
I will subscribe to those links in my bookmarks and visit them often. Have a nice day
토토 사이트
카지노 사이트
먹튀 검증
먹튀 사이트
스포츠 토토
https://www.j9korea.com
Bergabunglah bersama kami untuk mendapatkan berbagai promo dan bonus menarik slot online paling gacor di https://ole777.game
Wow! Thank you! I permanently wanted to write on my blog something like that.
사설 카지노
j9korea.com
소셜 카지노
카지노 게임 종류
카지노 먹튀 검증
호텔 카지노
https://www.j9korea.com/
I’ve been searching for hours on this topic and finally found your post. majorsite, I have read your post and I am very impressed. We prefer your opinion and will visit this site frequently to refer to your opinion. When would you like to visit my site?
You actually make it look so easy with your performance but I find this matter to be actually something which I think I would never comprehend
토토사이트
I am very interested in environmental issues these days. I came all the way here after watching the posting. I could refer to good articles. Thank you very much and I hope to visit often.먹튀신고
Thank you for sharing this blog. This is very informative. Let your nursing assignment help get done with our expert who provides you top content with plag free, also you will get the best deal in price and A++ guarantee of content done on time also our will get experts available for you 24/7.
I’m watching his music video to see what it’s like.
Mahila Samman Bachat Patra
Pokr online menjadi lebih mudah diakses setelah situs https://67.207.83.133 baru diluncurkan di Indonesia. Situs pokr ini memiliki teknologi canggih yang membuat para pemain merasa nyaman bermain pokr online.
Selain itu, peningkatan pajak pemerintah atas perjudian membuat orang mencari tempat baru untuk berjudi; membuat situs https://161.35.5.62 baru membantu mereka mengurangi penghindaran pajak dan meningkatkan pendapatan. Mendirikan toko di pasar yang sudah mapan seperti Indonesia masuk akal untuk situs pokr baru mana pun; itu penuh dengan pemain dan menghasilkan aksi judi yang hebat!
The top Alexa websites list is a free and convenient way to discover the world’s most popular sites.
very good. I like it. It’s interesting. Thanks for sharing. Thank you. หนังใหม่ชนโรง
I thought of it for the first time in a long time, so I visited again. I checked that many posts have been updated. It’s still a blog that inspires me deeply. I am very grateful.메이저사이트
Overall, your blog post is informative, well-organized. Seeking assignment help can be a useful resource for students who may be struggling with a particular assignment or subject. We are the best help assignment Australia at an affordable price. Also we provide premium quality content.
I saw your article well. You seem to enjoy baccarat online for some reason. We can help you enjoy more fun. Welcome anytime 🙂
Best Truck, Truck Driving News and Tips – TruckBlog
The weather suddenly got cold these days. You should be careful not to catch a cold in this weather. This cold is so powerful that it suffers a lot. Let’s be prepared for a cold wave.https://envoytoken.io
It’s such a good site for me. I came to visit during a difficult time, and it was a deep comfort to me. I will be very grateful and visit again to get consolation.안전놀이터추천
I forgot about it for a long time. It popped up and I came back. It’s still a pleasant blog. I should bookmark it so that I don’t forget it again. without ever forgetting again토토사이트
I think this is a real great article post
바카라사이트
Nice read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing a little research on that.
카지노사이트
It’s nice to know that this topic is being also covered on this web site. Really appreciate you sharing this blog.
카지노사이트
It’s always exciting to read through content from other authors and use something from other sites.
카지노사이트
Thank you for creating one of the most excellent essays I’ve ever read https://www.totositesafe.com/
That’s a really impressive new idea! https://www.totositenet.com/
This is good news and it helps. I’m happy with that recently shared this helpful information with us https://www.casinositesafe.com/
Excellent read, I just passed this onto a friend who was doing a little research on that. https://www.slotsite.info/