What belongs in a museum?

Is there such a thing as popular art? The term “popular” leaves a sour taste in the mouths of those trying to win respect from established institutions that seem to determine artistic merit. These institutions are towering monoliths that surround themselves with an agonizingly enticing air of prestige. I’m talking about museums, which are the be-all-end-all of the art world. In an ever-changing world, museums are racing to catch up, compelled by a need to compete with other cultural and entertainment destinations. While some lament this change, worried these institutions are pandering to the public, others believe museums are not changing fast enough to catch up with the new sensibility, which most recently includes a move to accept videogames as art. Most agree, however, that museums are a fundamental aspect of the art community and rely heavily on their expertise and validation.

There’s nothing controversial about declaring painting or sculpture as art. Film has made its way into this category as well, though not all films. For example, I feel confident in dismissing the 2015 Fantastic Four film (aka Fant4stic) as art for only its aimless plot that deteriorates into sub-par CGI and mindless fight scenes. On the other hand, year Amelie, with its super-saturated color palette and whimsical characterization, is a compelling example of falling in the category of art. The word ‘art’ is such a vague and complex a term, that in reality it is more of a sliding scale than a declaration. The distinction between art and everything else in the general, societal understanding falls under the category of discourse, which lacks concrete definition and relies on a slew of context that arrives at some fuzzy common agreement. (If you want to know more about discourse, I suggest locating and trying to decipher pages and pages of Michael Foucault’s rambling, inarticulate explanations strewn across various works of his). If Amelie is not artistic enough, perhaps an experimental film such as Last Year at Mariendbad would fit.

last-year-at-marienbad

(still from Last Year at Mariendbad)

My point is, not all film is art, but film that thoughtfully engages with emotion, style, or purposefully departs from convention could be worthy of the title. Describing the medium of film as art collectively seems heretical considering that you would be forcing A Single Man into the same category as Ghost Rider. It seems unfair to think any painting, whether it be a Monet or a three-year-old’s, could be universally called art, but mindless films are left high and dry. Practically, though, people want to draw a line somewhere, otherwise anything could be considered art, which would threaten countless egos and the prestige of museums.

Perhaps not all film is collectively considered art because it is one of the newer mediums to be introduced in a new sensibility. In George Cotkin’s book A Feast of Excess, he discusses the New Sensibility that emerged in the 1950s, which “was about excess, exaggeration, pushing limits, embracing the popular, and going too far in style and spirit” (7). This New Sensibility (with capital letters) is a term that may be referring to a specific movement, but the concept can be constantly applied to an ever-changing art world. The New Sensibility pushed the boundaries of art to the extreme, with pieces such as John Cage’s 4’33”, which used music to push the boundaries of minimalism. Though a current new sensibility may not involve such excess, it is questioning the structure of the heart of art infrastructure: the museum. The current new sensibility, still forming today, questions the function of the museum and what is allowed inside.

Videogames may be the newest medium aggressively forcing itself into the art world, which is how every new concept gets there. In Paolo Pedercini’s manifesto, The Great Art Upgrade, originally presented orally in 2013, Pedercini adds his two cents (or three judging by the length of his impassioned speech) to the not-so-old debate about the relationship of videogames to art. He describes the vigor with which the gaming community has recently been trying, and sometimes succeeding, to get society to admit that video games are art. The “cycle of shame and pride” that describes the fight to declare games is birthing “a new sensibility,” as games are more and more getting a foothold in institutions (Pedercini). Pedercini does not hide his exasperation with the game industry and fans, however, because they measure success by how museums have begun to recognize, showcase, or collect videogames. The perspective to most seems to be that the metric of the museum is the final frontier, and that there is some divine institution that determines what art is. The truth is much more complicated, but this oversimplification is more appealing than an ongoing struggle.

Pedercini sites the 2012 Smithsonian exhibition, “The Art of Videogames,” as one of the celebrated advancement of videogame status. But he also criticizes, saying that “[g]ame people were too busy celebrating this recognition to wonder whether or not this was a just populist publicity stunt to refresh the museum’s image and the industry’s. The show was in fact “generously” supported by Entertainment Software Association.” This exhibition was not only paid for by a major publisher and supporter of popular games, but Pedercini accuses the Museum of using videogames as a marketing tool rather than genuine interest in their artistic merit. While the industry was trying to become more elite and respected, the Smithsonian was attempting to appeal to a younger, more radical crowd, which is the recent trend.

smithsonian-exhibition

(from the Smithsonian exhibition “The Art of Videogames”)

In Matti Bunzl’s book In Search of Lost Avant Guarde, he dives deep into the inner working of Chicago’s MCA to reveal hidden tensions between the curators, the marketing team, and the educational programmers. More and more the marketing and fundraising division of the museum get the final say because it comes down to money and visitation to stay afloat (Benzl). To compete with the entertainment—movie theaters, shopping, and restaurants—for people’s time, museums are forced to sacrifice novelty for safer, more well-funded options—such as the Smithsonian’s “The Art of Videogames” exhibition. This exhibition is in keeping with museum’s attempts to become destination and events rather than simply presenters and protectors of art. Northwestern’s Block museum offers discussions and performative artwork open to the public; experiences that offer a chance to engage in conversation with an artist in ways that walking around a gallery cannot. You could attribute this change to the lamented loss of patience that plagues humanity today, but nostalgia for an elusive simpler time has and always will be present. The fact of the matter is that museums have always evolved with the times, and though some criticize this change, others (like video games as art advocates), don’t think museums are changing fast enough.

In the 1940s, complaints about modern art museums arose, accusing them of showing work that wasn’t contemporary enough (Claire Bishop, 12). [T]he Institute of Contemporary Arts in London was founded in 1947, opting to show temporary exhibitions rather than building up a permanent collection, as did many similarly titled venues.” This new perspective on a museum—striving to show only contemporary art—was a direct reaction to a movement, and was made to draw in the audience that demanded it. Museums could ignore societal shifts and remain absolute in old beliefs, but one period’s old ideas were another’s radical shifts. Resisting change in museums, as with anything else, will only result in obsolitism, which would be death to an institution that strives for viewership. Art is displayed to be viewed, so there will always be a conversation between museums and the changing perspectives of their potential audience. The push to install videogames into museum galleries is no different than the push for a purer contemporaneity uninhibited by the past.

However, even if museums are just barely beginning to acknowledge videogames, they are still not designed to display them. Pursuing a gallery involves walking around and perhaps very occasionally sitting on a bench if one is supplied. Videogames often require a longer commitment that few would be willing to engage with if they had to stand in one place for extended periods of time. Pedercini elaborates in his manifesto, “We may need to bring some couches, snacks and drinks in the museum. Because you just can’t play Cart Life in 5 minutes while standing.” Perhaps this is why “only 5 among the 80 chosen titles were actually playable in the exhibition” (Pedercini).

Currently, the struggle for artistic validation is best exemplified by the push for video game recognition, and museums have always been the most concrete elevation of a medium. Once you’re in a museum, you’ve “made it,” but this glorification of museums is misguided and perpetuated by a wealthy elite. Anything that does not exist within the structure of a cultural system enabled by the wealthy is too common, too popular to be highly regarded. These discards of the upper class fall to the entertainment industry to distribute. Perhaps on one side of the scale you have entertainment and on the other lies art (and the museum). Art and entertainment both fall under culture, but only art is cultured. Though these boundaries are abstract creations of society, they lie in that dangerous realm of a discourse, which takes years of resistance to unravel. Controversial art is often the most interesting, so though this pushback can be frustrating to some, it in itself is validating. Pedercini concludes his impassioned manifesto, “we cannot have an art history of games without an art criticism of games,” which gives me hope that this current struggle is just the beginning of a new sensibility that’s here to stay.

 

 

Image sources:

Last year at Marienbad: https://mountainx.com/movies/reviews/last-year-at-marienbad/ 

Smithsonian exhibition “the Art of Videogames”: http://www.molleindustria.org/blog/the-great-art-upgrade/ 

(featured image) Cory Arcangel’s game modification-Clouds: http://www.coryarcangel.com/things-i-made/2002-001-super-mario-clouds

 

6,652 Comments

  • aaliyan commented on June 13, 2024 Reply

    I can’t believe focusing long enough to research; much less write this kind of article. You’ve outdone yourself with this material without a doubt. It is one of the greatest contents. memek

  • https://revenderpaineliptv.com.br/ commented on June 13, 2024 Reply

    Nice post! This is a very nice blog that I will definitively come back to more times this year! Thanks for informative post. https://kingcreditweb.com/

  • aaliyan commented on June 13, 2024 Reply

    This valuable appear to be most certainly good. Those very tiny facts are designed implementing a wide variety for experience know-how. That i love the reasoning behind a lot. titit

  • University Scholarships commented on June 13, 2024 Reply

    Yo, this site is like a virtual escape room – maybe add a ‘Brain Teaser Thursday’ section for mind-bending puzzles and challenges to keep us sharp!
    University Scholarships

  • sobat777 commented on June 13, 2024 Reply

    jika anda sedang mencari sebuah situs yang membayar berapapun kemenangan anda sobat777 adalah situs slot gacor paling sensasional dan terpercaya.disini anda bisa deposit sebesar 5000 saja untuk bermain semua jenis permainan yang di sediakan di situs sobat777

  • rachana commented on June 13, 2024 Reply

    situs slot gacor 2024 terbaru silahkan kunjungi situs sobat777</a

  • UPSers commented on June 13, 2024 Reply

    “”Its always good to learn tips like you share for blog posting. As I just started posting comments for blog and facing problem of lots of rejections. I think your suggestion would be helpful for me. I will let you know if its work for me too.” sdtoto

  • dakar zig commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    Your effort in sharing this is much appreciated.

    Ambrein

  • show rush commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    Your detailed information is greatly appreciated.

    ethyl laurate

  • Huzii ex commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    I am able to provides you with the objective In this article understasand the best way to practice it the right way. Understand in addition to generate anything beneficial. SRL Cricket Live Score 2024

  • Huzii ex commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    Allowed towards gathering associated with gaming in this article understand just about everything in relation to everyone. SRL Matches Live Score

  • Zonnepanelen installateurs commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    I like viewing web sites which comprehend the price of delivering the excellent useful resource free of charge. I truly adored reading your posting. Thank you! Zonnepanelen installateurs

  • Airconditioning installateur commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    This is an awesome motivating article.I am practically satisfied with your great work.You put truly extremely supportive data. Keep it up. Continue blogging. Hoping to perusing your next post Airconditioning installateur

  • Isolatie spouwmuur commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    Hello! I just wish to give an enormous thumbs up for the nice info you’ve got right here on this post. I will probably be coming back to your weblog for more soon! Isolatie spouwmuur

  • Zwembadbouw commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    Glad to chat your blog, I seem to be forward to more reliable articles and I think we all wish to thank so many good articles, blog to share with us. Zwembadbouw

  • Zonnepanelen plat dak commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    Wonderful blog post. This is absolute magic from you! I have never seen a more wonderful post than this one. You’ve really made my day today with this. I hope you keep this up! Zonnepanelen plat dak

  • Buitenzwembaden commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    Really impressed! Everything is very open and very clear clarification of issues. It contains truly facts. Your website is very valuable. Thanks for sharing. Buitenzwembaden

  • Prijs zonnepanelen commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    Three are usually cheap Ralph Lauren available for sale each and every time you wish to buy. Prijs zonnepanelen

  • Aanleg zwembaden commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    i am for the first time here. I found this board and I in finding It truly helpful & it helped me out a lot. I hope to present something back and help others such as you helped me. Aanleg zwembaden

  • Zonnepaneel installatie commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    It has fully emerged to crown Singapore’s southern shores and undoubtedly placed her on the global map of residential landmarks. I still scored the more points than I ever have in a season for GS. I think you would be hard pressed to find somebody with the same consistency I have had over the years so I am happy with that. Zonnepaneel installatie

  • Zonnepanelen plaatsen commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    Three are usually cheap Ralph Lauren available for sale each and every time you wish to buy. Zonnepanelen plaatsen

  • Prijzen zonnepanelen commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    Mmm.. good to be here in your article or post, whatever, I think I should also work hard for my own website like I see some good and updated working in your site. Prijzen zonnepanelen

  • Zonnepanelen prijs commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    Wow, happy to see this awesome post. I hope this think help any newbie for their awesome work. By the way thanks for share this awesomeness from Zonnepanelen prijs

  • Huawei batterij commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    It is perfect time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I’ve read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you some interesting things or suggestions. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article. I want to read more things about it! Huawei batterij

  • สอบถามหวยหุ้นเกาหลี commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    Your dedication to delivering high-quality content is evident in every word you write.สอบถามหวยหุ้นเกาหลี

  • Zonnepanelen laten plaatsen commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    Going to graduate school was a positive decision for me. I enjoyed the coursework, the presentations, the fellow students, and the professors. And since my company reimbursed 100% of the tuition, the only cost that I had to pay on my own was for books and supplies. Otherwise, I received a free master’s degree. All that I had to invest was my time. Zonnepanelen laten plaatsen

  • Jenis Kendaraan Sport Paling Mahal commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    Thank you for the information about sports vehicles which is quite interesting, but if you want to know more interesting and of course very profitable information which will definitely not disappoint, please visit our website.sportkeren01.blogspot.com/

  • 토토사이트 commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    Hi Trent this is so informative, and thanks for the effort of putting all this together and shared to us! 토토사이트

  • Mos77 commented on June 14, 2024 Reply
  • Olo4D commented on June 14, 2024 Reply
  • Sukaslot commented on June 14, 2024 Reply
  • Sukaslot commented on June 14, 2024 Reply
  • Mpo55 commented on June 14, 2024 Reply
  • Bni4D commented on June 14, 2024 Reply
  • Pandaslot commented on June 14, 2024 Reply
  • Pandaslot commented on June 14, 2024 Reply
  • Prada88 commented on June 14, 2024 Reply
  • sarim commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up High Traffic Backlinks.

  • dji sams soe commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    tempat main slot terbaik di sobat777 yang merupakan server asli server nexus dan banyak bonusnya.

  • sarim commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    If you don”t mind proceed with this extraordinary work and I anticipate a greater amount of your magnificent blog entries.  High Traffic Backlinks.

  • jus tomat commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    indexing semoga indeks ini berjalan lancar gaes,terima kasih ya ^^

  • sarim commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    If you don”t mind proceed with this extraordinary work and I anticipate a greater amount of your magnificent blog entries.  Boost Traffic

  • Arzoo Kanak commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    Hello, I am Arzoo Kanak from Chandigarh, I understand that every person has unique desires and fantasies. That’s why I’m offering a wide range of services to ensure that your experience with me in bed is memorable. Your satisfaction is our first priority, plus we have a diverse collection of beautiful girls to spend a romantic night with you. https://www.arzookanak.in

  • hamtaro commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    indexing ketiga semoga indexing kali ini berjalan dengan lancar ya ges ya

  • jerman commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    jerman semoga sekali ini german menang dengan membawa tropi piala citra indonesia

  • honees commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    sobat777 slot online terbaik server nexus yang memiliki game tergacor seindonesia dan pastinya terpercaya, berkunjunglah karena disini banyak event menarik dan bonus setiap hari senin.

  • aaadd commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    sobat777 situs slot online terpercaya dan terbesar seindonesia bisa deposit 5000 setiap hari.

  • poi commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    sobat777 merupakan situs slot gacor gampang maxwin yang bisa deposit 5000 saja setiap hari

  • risman commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    sobat777 adalah situs slot online yang berdiri sejak tahun 2024 yang memiliki game slot paling lengkap diantara situs situs lainnya.

  • reo rey commented on June 14, 2024 Reply

    sobat777 adalah situs slot online yang berdiri sejak tahun 2024 yang memiliki game slot paling lengkap diantara situs situs lainnya.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *