What belongs in a museum?

Is there such a thing as popular art? The term “popular” leaves a sour taste in the mouths of those trying to win respect from established institutions that seem to determine artistic merit. These institutions are towering monoliths that surround themselves with an agonizingly enticing air of prestige. I’m talking about museums, which are the be-all-end-all of the art world. In an ever-changing world, museums are racing to catch up, compelled by a need to compete with other cultural and entertainment destinations. While some lament this change, worried these institutions are pandering to the public, others believe museums are not changing fast enough to catch up with the new sensibility, which most recently includes a move to accept videogames as art. Most agree, however, that museums are a fundamental aspect of the art community and rely heavily on their expertise and validation.

There’s nothing controversial about declaring painting or sculpture as art. Film has made its way into this category as well, though not all films. For example, I feel confident in dismissing the 2015 Fantastic Four film (aka Fant4stic) as art for only its aimless plot that deteriorates into sub-par CGI and mindless fight scenes. On the other hand, year Amelie, with its super-saturated color palette and whimsical characterization, is a compelling example of falling in the category of art. The word ‘art’ is such a vague and complex a term, that in reality it is more of a sliding scale than a declaration. The distinction between art and everything else in the general, societal understanding falls under the category of discourse, which lacks concrete definition and relies on a slew of context that arrives at some fuzzy common agreement. (If you want to know more about discourse, I suggest locating and trying to decipher pages and pages of Michael Foucault’s rambling, inarticulate explanations strewn across various works of his). If Amelie is not artistic enough, perhaps an experimental film such as Last Year at Mariendbad would fit.

last-year-at-marienbad

(still from Last Year at Mariendbad)

My point is, not all film is art, but film that thoughtfully engages with emotion, style, or purposefully departs from convention could be worthy of the title. Describing the medium of film as art collectively seems heretical considering that you would be forcing A Single Man into the same category as Ghost Rider. It seems unfair to think any painting, whether it be a Monet or a three-year-old’s, could be universally called art, but mindless films are left high and dry. Practically, though, people want to draw a line somewhere, otherwise anything could be considered art, which would threaten countless egos and the prestige of museums.

Perhaps not all film is collectively considered art because it is one of the newer mediums to be introduced in a new sensibility. In George Cotkin’s book A Feast of Excess, he discusses the New Sensibility that emerged in the 1950s, which “was about excess, exaggeration, pushing limits, embracing the popular, and going too far in style and spirit” (7). This New Sensibility (with capital letters) is a term that may be referring to a specific movement, but the concept can be constantly applied to an ever-changing art world. The New Sensibility pushed the boundaries of art to the extreme, with pieces such as John Cage’s 4’33”, which used music to push the boundaries of minimalism. Though a current new sensibility may not involve such excess, it is questioning the structure of the heart of art infrastructure: the museum. The current new sensibility, still forming today, questions the function of the museum and what is allowed inside.

Videogames may be the newest medium aggressively forcing itself into the art world, which is how every new concept gets there. In Paolo Pedercini’s manifesto, The Great Art Upgrade, originally presented orally in 2013, Pedercini adds his two cents (or three judging by the length of his impassioned speech) to the not-so-old debate about the relationship of videogames to art. He describes the vigor with which the gaming community has recently been trying, and sometimes succeeding, to get society to admit that video games are art. The “cycle of shame and pride” that describes the fight to declare games is birthing “a new sensibility,” as games are more and more getting a foothold in institutions (Pedercini). Pedercini does not hide his exasperation with the game industry and fans, however, because they measure success by how museums have begun to recognize, showcase, or collect videogames. The perspective to most seems to be that the metric of the museum is the final frontier, and that there is some divine institution that determines what art is. The truth is much more complicated, but this oversimplification is more appealing than an ongoing struggle.

Pedercini sites the 2012 Smithsonian exhibition, “The Art of Videogames,” as one of the celebrated advancement of videogame status. But he also criticizes, saying that “[g]ame people were too busy celebrating this recognition to wonder whether or not this was a just populist publicity stunt to refresh the museum’s image and the industry’s. The show was in fact “generously” supported by Entertainment Software Association.” This exhibition was not only paid for by a major publisher and supporter of popular games, but Pedercini accuses the Museum of using videogames as a marketing tool rather than genuine interest in their artistic merit. While the industry was trying to become more elite and respected, the Smithsonian was attempting to appeal to a younger, more radical crowd, which is the recent trend.

smithsonian-exhibition

(from the Smithsonian exhibition “The Art of Videogames”)

In Matti Bunzl’s book In Search of Lost Avant Guarde, he dives deep into the inner working of Chicago’s MCA to reveal hidden tensions between the curators, the marketing team, and the educational programmers. More and more the marketing and fundraising division of the museum get the final say because it comes down to money and visitation to stay afloat (Benzl). To compete with the entertainment—movie theaters, shopping, and restaurants—for people’s time, museums are forced to sacrifice novelty for safer, more well-funded options—such as the Smithsonian’s “The Art of Videogames” exhibition. This exhibition is in keeping with museum’s attempts to become destination and events rather than simply presenters and protectors of art. Northwestern’s Block museum offers discussions and performative artwork open to the public; experiences that offer a chance to engage in conversation with an artist in ways that walking around a gallery cannot. You could attribute this change to the lamented loss of patience that plagues humanity today, but nostalgia for an elusive simpler time has and always will be present. The fact of the matter is that museums have always evolved with the times, and though some criticize this change, others (like video games as art advocates), don’t think museums are changing fast enough.

In the 1940s, complaints about modern art museums arose, accusing them of showing work that wasn’t contemporary enough (Claire Bishop, 12). [T]he Institute of Contemporary Arts in London was founded in 1947, opting to show temporary exhibitions rather than building up a permanent collection, as did many similarly titled venues.” This new perspective on a museum—striving to show only contemporary art—was a direct reaction to a movement, and was made to draw in the audience that demanded it. Museums could ignore societal shifts and remain absolute in old beliefs, but one period’s old ideas were another’s radical shifts. Resisting change in museums, as with anything else, will only result in obsolitism, which would be death to an institution that strives for viewership. Art is displayed to be viewed, so there will always be a conversation between museums and the changing perspectives of their potential audience. The push to install videogames into museum galleries is no different than the push for a purer contemporaneity uninhibited by the past.

However, even if museums are just barely beginning to acknowledge videogames, they are still not designed to display them. Pursuing a gallery involves walking around and perhaps very occasionally sitting on a bench if one is supplied. Videogames often require a longer commitment that few would be willing to engage with if they had to stand in one place for extended periods of time. Pedercini elaborates in his manifesto, “We may need to bring some couches, snacks and drinks in the museum. Because you just can’t play Cart Life in 5 minutes while standing.” Perhaps this is why “only 5 among the 80 chosen titles were actually playable in the exhibition” (Pedercini).

Currently, the struggle for artistic validation is best exemplified by the push for video game recognition, and museums have always been the most concrete elevation of a medium. Once you’re in a museum, you’ve “made it,” but this glorification of museums is misguided and perpetuated by a wealthy elite. Anything that does not exist within the structure of a cultural system enabled by the wealthy is too common, too popular to be highly regarded. These discards of the upper class fall to the entertainment industry to distribute. Perhaps on one side of the scale you have entertainment and on the other lies art (and the museum). Art and entertainment both fall under culture, but only art is cultured. Though these boundaries are abstract creations of society, they lie in that dangerous realm of a discourse, which takes years of resistance to unravel. Controversial art is often the most interesting, so though this pushback can be frustrating to some, it in itself is validating. Pedercini concludes his impassioned manifesto, “we cannot have an art history of games without an art criticism of games,” which gives me hope that this current struggle is just the beginning of a new sensibility that’s here to stay.

 

 

Image sources:

Last year at Marienbad: https://mountainx.com/movies/reviews/last-year-at-marienbad/ 

Smithsonian exhibition “the Art of Videogames”: http://www.molleindustria.org/blog/the-great-art-upgrade/ 

(featured image) Cory Arcangel’s game modification-Clouds: http://www.coryarcangel.com/things-i-made/2002-001-super-mario-clouds

 

5,925 Comments

  • Michael Kramer commented on December 12, 2016 Reply

    Nice exploration of the lag between what art museums are equipped to display and the art itself. Perhaps the digital shift is key here as well as new notions of the game as a form of art (and art as a kind of game?). I suspect there is a rich buried history of this notion to be further explored in the history of art.

    • Diana commented on October 10, 2022 Reply

      I’m so glad I eventually found this website. Thanks for the post and your effort—it was very useful and instructive. Keep sharing blogs like this: Click Here bike race for More Information

    • Mira Sherronm commented on December 26, 2023 Reply

      Items that hold historical or cultural importance, reflecting a particular era, civilization, or event, are often considered for museum minecraftle collections. These could include artifacts, documents, artworks, or cultural objects significant to a region or community.

    • Bussiness Sale commented on March 8, 2024 Reply

      This is a thought-provoking analysis of the evolving relationship between art and museums! You raise a critical point about the limitations of current museum displays.

      Strengths of the Analysis:
      Lag Between Art and Display: You acknowledge the writer’s focus on the “lag between what art museums are equipped to display and the art itself.” This is a significant point.
      Digital Art and Games as Art: You highlight the “digital shift” and the concept of “games as a form of art (and art as a kind of game?)” as key considerations. This demonstrates your own thoughtful engagement with the topic.
      Unexplored History: The “rich buried history” comment about the “notion of art as a game” encourages further exploration. This is a valuable call to action for future research.
      Overall, your comment is insightful and engaging. It highlights the importance of the writer’s point, adds your own thoughtful ideas, and encourages further exploration of the topic.

      khalidelarbi
      ————————————
      Online Marketing Analysis

      business for sale

  • Michael Kramer commented on December 12, 2016 Reply

    So I wonder, what would the kind of museum work someone such as Bishop suggests look like with video games incorporated: can they sustain an “archive of the commons”?

  • Max commented on December 22, 2021 Reply

    Sure, why not? Things evolve over time, like this… But also, look, people thought fax machines were great, then we had email and printers. No more fax machines. Then people thought the internet was irrelevant, and now all companies have a website. It makes sense for video games to be in museums, just like fax machines and other old technology like pagers.

  • Jessica Davies commented on January 7, 2022 Reply

    I really happy found this website eventually. Really informative and inoperative, Thanks for the post and effort! Please keep sharing more such blog.
    for More Information Click Here:- HP Printer in Error State

  • Betmate commented on May 2, 2022 Reply

    이용이유가생기는곳 먹튀검증 안전노리터 go

  • Esha Fatima commented on May 23, 2022 Reply

    I have gone to museums many times, Most of the museums were about old historical statues and stuff. I have never gone to any art museum, but I would like to go there someday. well, I provide article writing services in pakistan, and in one of my articles, I wrote that everything that you do passionately is now considered an art.

  • mega game commented on May 24, 2022 Reply

    เป็นเยี่ยมเว็บไซต์ใหม่ ที่น่าเล่น MegaGame สล็อต แตก หนัก เนื่องจากว่าเป็น ค่ายเกมสล็อต MEGASLOTGAME ที่ดีเยี่ยมที่สุด เป็นการ รวมสล็อตทุกค่ายในเว็บไซต์เดียว สามารถเข้าเล่นเกมสล็อต มากมายกกว่าร้อยเกม MEGAGAME เว็บตรง

  • Olivia Amber commented on May 31, 2022 Reply

    Museums can be categorized into major groups by the type of collections they display, including fine arts, applied arts, craft, archaeology, anthropology and ethnology, biography, history, cultural history, science, technology, and children’s museums. And I’m also visiting the museum with our team of Dissertation Help London and getting amazing knowledge.

  • Sarahlisa commented on June 29, 2022 Reply

    Very wonderful, the recipe is very root, and the dish is very delicious. I’ll make it for my family this weekend at 5 letter words for free

  • today uk news commented on July 29, 2022 Reply
  • Steve Herrington commented on August 3, 2022 Reply

    Do you have unsolved management paper and academic tasks? Struggling with stringent deadlines to conclude your assessments? Looking professional help however unable to find out qualified tutor for your management assessments? Approach the comprehensive Management Homework Help guidance to get the most effective research content.

  • Jasa Pindah commented on August 4, 2022 Reply

    Thanks to my father who informed me on the topic of this blog, this blog is truly amazing. Pindahan

  • Jasa Pindahan Rumah commented on August 5, 2022 Reply

    naturally like your website however you have to test the spelling on quite a few of your posts. Many of them are rife with spelling problems and I find it very troublesome to inform the reality however
    I will definitely come again again. Jasa Pindahan Rumah

  • Jasa Pindah commented on August 5, 2022 Reply

    magnificent points altogether, you simply received a new reader. What would you recommend in regards to your post that you just made some days in the past?
    Any positive? Jasa Pindahan Rumah

  • simar commented on August 5, 2022 Reply

    A reliable essay help London understands that students are always in a hurry and can’t complete their work on their own. Their dissertation writing experts follow a strict set of rules and guidelines and will do their utmost to help you earn your desired grades. Dissertation writing services in the UK must have thorough knowledge of the style, structure and content of academic dissertations in UK universities.

  • Jakarta commented on August 6, 2022 Reply

    It’s actually a great and helpful piece of info. I’m glad that you just shared this useful info with us. Please stay us informed like this.
    Jasa Pindahan Rumah Bogor Thanks for sharing.

  • dailynewsera commented on August 18, 2022 Reply
  • Jasmine Brown commented on August 26, 2022 Reply

    There’s never enough articles out. Which is why I feel pleased to come across such an amazing article like this one. I luv this article. DROP MORE PLEEEEEASE>>> LifeCare prescriptions at your doorstep!!!

  • 에볼루션 알가격 commented on August 30, 2022 Reply

    you all technicalss AUGUST1983Y solutions and staff we need for 에볼루션알가격

  • Karl Francis commented on September 5, 2022 Reply

    Very interesting examination of the gap between the art and what may be shown five nights at freddy’s in museums. Possibly the change to digital media and evolving ideas about video games as art are crucial factors.

  • safetoto commented on September 8, 2022 Reply

    I came to this site with the introduction of a friend around me and I was very impressed when I found your writing. I’ll come back often after bookmarking! safetoto

  • Jack commented on September 29, 2022 Reply

    Hello there! I simply want to offer you a huge thumbs up
    for the great information you have got right here on this post.
    I’ll be returning to your site for more soon.Are you one of those students who is striving to precisely finish up your assessments and homework jobs?click here to take a sigh of relief and enjoy your academic life to the fullest as it never comes back again.

  • casinocommunity commented on October 8, 2022 Reply

    I have been looking for articles on these topics for a long time. casinocommunity I don’t know how grateful you are for posting on this topic. Thank you for the numerous articles on this site, I will subscribe to those links in my bookmarks and visit them often. Have a nice day

  • Maklon Kosmetik commented on October 10, 2022 Reply

    An interesting discussion is value comment. I think that it’s best to write extra on this topic, it might not be a taboo subject but usually people are not enough to speak on such topics. To the next. Maklon Kosmetik Cheers

  • Maklon commented on October 10, 2022 Reply

    An interesting discussion is value comment. I think that it’s best to write extra on this topic, it might not be a taboo subject but usually people are not enough to speak on such topics. To the next. Maklon Kosmetik Cheers

  • Jasa Pindah commented on October 16, 2022 Reply

    I’ve been surfing on-line more than three hours nowadays, but I by no means found any fascinating article like yours. It’s beautiful value sufficient for me. Personally, if all webmasters and bloggers made excellent content material as you probably did, the internet will be a lot more helpful than ever before. “Oh, that way madness lies let me shun that.” by William Shakespeare. Pengelola Limbah B3

  • Rental Elf Jakarta commented on October 18, 2022 Reply

    A person essentially lend a hand to make critically posts I’d state. That is the very first time I frequented your web page and up to now? I amazed with the research you made to make this particular post amazing. Wonderful task! Rental Elf Jakarta

  • Jasa Pindahan commented on October 19, 2022 Reply

    Kami Jasa Pindahan profesional dan terpercaya

  • Pindah Kantor commented on October 19, 2022 Reply

    Pindah Kantor tak perlu bingung, kami mampu membuat anda nyaman saat pusing karena pindahan

  • baccaratsite commented on October 21, 2022 Reply

    Your writing is perfect and complete. baccaratsite However, I think it will be more wonderful if your post includes additional topics that I am thinking of. I have a lot of posts on my site similar to your topic. Would you like to visit once?

  • Media Monitoring commented on October 22, 2022 Reply

    Tell your story about the industry that you’ve been working up to, we begin the strategy after we scraping all the data in media and all related to your industry. Media monitoring will gave the insights and a better solution for you to step up against the competitor and regulator.

  • Jasa Pindah Murah commented on October 22, 2022 Reply

    Solusi bagi anda yang memiliki keluhan dan kekhawatiran saat ingin melakukan pindahan, jasa pindah murah kami mampu meminimalisir segala bentuk risiko yang ada

  • bitcoincasino commented on October 26, 2022 Reply

    I came to this site with the introduction of a friend around me and I was very impressed when I found your writing. I’ll come back often after bookmarking! bitcoincasino

  • bitcoincasino commented on October 30, 2022 Reply

    I am very impressed with your writing bitcoincasino I couldn’t think of this, but it’s amazing! I wrote several posts similar to this one, but please come and see!

  • safetoto commented on October 30, 2022 Reply

    Hello ! I am the one who writes posts on these topics safetoto I would like to write an article based on your article. When can I ask for a review?
    sdsd

  • Nicole commented on October 30, 2022 Reply

    Good post and right to the point. I am not sure if this is actually the best place to ask but do you guys have any thoughts on where to get some professional writers? Thx Jasa Angkutan Barang Pindahan Rumah🙂

  • totosite commented on November 8, 2022 Reply

    As I am looking at your writing, totosite I regret being unable to do outdoor activities due to Corona 19, and I miss my old daily life. If you also miss the daily life of those days, would you please visit my site once? My site is a site where I post about photos and daily life when I was free.

  • Robert Carlose commented on November 10, 2022 Reply

    “tradeKey” is a B2B marketplace where companies sell products or services to other businesses. tradekey is the website that connects you with rubber pants for adults suppliers for your sole online store.

  • Rental Mobil Jakarta commented on November 19, 2022 Reply

    I was wondering if you ever considered changing the page layout of your blog? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better. Paket Wisata Jogja 3 Hari 2 Malam Youve got an awful lot of text for only having 1 or 2 images. Maybe you could space it out better?

  • hellonio commented on November 22, 2022 Reply

    Well you are right with the blog. WHy dont you check out digitize a logo services?

  • James Lavine commented on November 22, 2022 Reply

    I really like your blog. The most interesting things are neatly collected. Every now and then I go to look and wonder. Men’s leather jackets

  • totosin23 commented on December 5, 2022 Reply

    It’s really nice to see you at Waikano today Nice to meet you. Neagle is so much fun. I’m going to read it again메이저토토사이트]

  • Sewa Bus Jogja commented on December 9, 2022 Reply

    I’m not sure why but this blog is loading incredibly slow for me. Is anyone else having this issue or is it a problem on my end? Sewa Bus Jogja I’ll check back later and see if the problem still exists.

  • Sewa Bus Jogja commented on December 9, 2022 Reply

    You’re so awesome! I do not suppose I’ve truly read through something like this before. So good to find somebody with some original thoughts on this subject. Really.. Paket Wisata Jogja thank you for starting this up. This website is something that’s needed on the internet, someone with a little originality!

  • Rental Mobil Jakarta commented on December 9, 2022 Reply

    Thank you a lot for sharing this with all of us you actually recognize what you’re talking about! Bookmarked. Sewa Mobil Jakarta Please additionally visit my web site =). We could have a link alternate contract among us!

  • Sewa Badut Gresik commented on December 9, 2022 Reply

    Hello there, I do believe your web site could be having web browser compatibility problems. When I take a look at your site in Safari, it looks fine but when opening in I.E.,
    Sewa Badut Gresik it has some overlapping issues. I merely wanted to give you a quick heads up! Besides that, wonderful website!

  • jaeseu commented on December 10, 2022 Reply

    I found this blog. For what you have suggested to us,
    I have found some new data in your post, all things considered.
    The cerebrum is incredibly satisfying and I am all thanks to the astonishing degree of your article.

    제이나인 스포츠 토토 배당률
    제이나인 스포츠 토토 승부 식
    제이나인 승부 식 토토
    제이나인 토토 도메인
    제이나인 토토 먹튀
    https://www.j9korea.com

  • Jagran Party in Delhi commented on December 14, 2022 Reply

    Conduct Mata Bhagwati Jagran Party in Delhi from the Best Famous Well Renowned Bhagwati Jagran Party in Delhi, Noida, Ghaziabad, Faridabad, Gurgaon, Gururgam & Other -States of India. Arrange Mata Bhagwati Jagran Party at your Home this Navratri 2022. Call Rakesh Khanna & Party on +91 9810235505 or visit https://www.jagrankiparty.com today.

  • CUAL ES LA MEJOR commented on December 15, 2022 Reply
  • Depilación commented on December 15, 2022 Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *