I arrived in Venice alone on November 12, 2015. I had been abroad for about two months, and this was the moment I had been waiting for. My scrappy, industrious European adventure would make me feel without a doubt that I hadn’t squandered my time here. I was unfamiliar with traveling alone and terrified that I would drop a ball that ruined the whole trip, but so far I had figured out how to print my Ryanair boarding pass so I wouldn’t be charged 60 pounds at the airport and how get to London’s distant budget airport by 4 AM without major issue. I was even lucky enough to be routed into the normal airport (rather than the budget airport) in Venice due to fog! I was starting to feel like I was going to make it as I boarded the water bus. Student ticket in hand, I was going to one of the most famous art events in the world: the Venice Biennale.
The next day I walked along the water to the Giardini, one of the two largest Biennale venues. I crossed bridge after bridge, and my feet were just starting to fatigue from a long day’s travel when I saw the green gardens appear ahead out of the fog. I spent all day at the Giardini, taking in the main curated exhibition, “All the World’s Futures,” and several national pavilions. In the furthest corner, I found the Polish Pavilion and watched Halka/Haiti 18°48´05˝N 72°23´01˝W by C. T. Jasper and Joanna Malinowska (image below). This piece is a simply-edited panoramic video of the Polish opera Halka performed in a Haitian village, but I watched, mesmerized, for 25 minutes because I knew I would probably never see it again.
I stumbled back to my hotel in a daze, ready to settle into bed until the next day. Then my phone connected to the wifi and I started getting the notifications. News of the violent attacks in Paris permeated the safety of my locked hotel room door. I learned that my Northwestern roommate from freshman year had attended the soccer match that came under attack, but she had returned home safely. Still, attack after attack terrified the city as I sat in Venice, shocked and alone and sad.
The next day, it was just slightly harder than usual to open my door and face the world outside. But today was my only day to see the second part of the Biennale. I followed nearly the same path along the water in the fog to the Arsenale. It didn’t take me long to realize I wasn’t going to enjoy the show that day. I wasn’t feeling at all optimistic about “All the World’s Futures,” and I was greeted in the first gallery by two neon works by Bruce Nauman called Eat Death (1972) and Raw War (1970). I was not in the mood.
I powered through the main show and glanced through a couple of pavilions before collapsing into a chair at the café. It was time to go.
****
I didn’t think it about the Biennale that much in the following couple of months. When I returned to the U.S., I would list it as one of the things I did that meant I hadn’t squandered my time abroad. I felt very lucky to have been able to go, but I couldn’t deny my experience was colored by the terrible events in Paris. It came crashing back into mind, though, when I was introduced to the Google Cultural Institute by one of my courses early in 2016.
The Google Cultural Institute struck me as a thing of beauty. I was no stranger to searchable databases of artwork, but the interface was so polished and smooth. There were countless virtual exhibitions on subject ranging from the fall of the Berlin Wall to Rembrandt van Rijn, and it was all so interesting and easy to interact with. I was blown away by the fact that I could access images of so many works from so many different institutions in one place for free. I could happily get lost down the rabbit hole of virtual tours and collections, reveling in this new accessibility of the arts.
I found the Venice Biennale 2015 project on their news page. I was surprised and intrigued, so I clicked through the “All the World’s Futures” Giardini digital exhibition. It was very strange having been there before, and it brought up mixed feelings about the time I had spent in Venice not long ago. For the first time, I could see odd things about the Google Cultural Institute that I had not questioned before. The context of my viewing the weekend of the Paris attacks had changed my experience of the artwork, but temporal context was eliminated from the Google exhibitions. This emphasized the vague contemporaneity of the Biennale.
I was unable to decide whether I was grateful I could review the Arsenale show after the fact, or whether the stunted experience just made me feel worse for not taking full advantage of being there. On the one hand, I was able to identify a work I liked; I had taken a picture of it but forgotten to note the label information.
My iPhone image, November 13, 2015.
Google Cultural Institute, Giardini Digital Exhibition, Installation Photo
Further, I was able to view an in-depth, documentary virtual exhibition of Halka/Haiti in the Poland Pavilion, but there was no video clip of the work, so I had been right in thinking I would never see it again. The whole experience of reviewing the Biennale via Google was strangely unsettling, and it me to research more about this platform.
The enigmatic, contradictory Google Art Project launched February 1, 2011 to little fanfare and mixed reviews. There were 17 original partner institutions that made all or part of their holdings available online. While most critics lamented the bugs and whirling experience of indoor streetview (largely unchanged in 2016), some disparaged the concept itself because the photography, however hi-def, could never equal the experience of the real thing. Although I basically agree, this strikes me as incredibly elitist. Not everyone is going to have the means to make it to the Uffizi in person, so giving a virtual option radically expands the group of people able to indulge their interest in arts and culture. Many museums are also excited about the possibility of mitigating crowds.
Aside: there are some gray areas to this accessibility.
While they clearly want users to be able to create collections (which sort of remind me of Pinterest), they dangle their “Open Gallery” exhibition technology before budding digital curators (read: me) before dropping the bomb that it is “invite only.”. Okay. So, the wider audience is meant to be “culturally curious” but they should not be granted the same tools as culturally authoritative institutions. Heavens, no…
It didn’t take too long after the launch before people said, “Wait… How are you profiting from this Google?!?!?!” The short answer is, they aren’t. This subset of the company is strictly non-profit. However, when pressed, the Institute’s director Steve Crossan said, “There’s certainly an investment logic to this. Having good content on the Web, in open standards, is good for the Web, is good for the users. If you invest in what’s good for the Web and the users, that will bear fruit.” Okay, but also, Google is good at gathering and selling our metadata and great at keeping quiet about it. It’s a new and mind-bending possibility: billions of art and cultural objects aggregated, and billions of people interacting with them, showing Google (and maybe cultural institutions for the right price) what people are actually interested in (and possibly willing to pay for). Although this service is “free of charge,” there is an untold amount of money bound up in it nonetheless. It suddenly felt ironic that a major theme of the Biennale was “capital” and how it has changed in the 21st century. Evidently it’s a crazy new world.
A persistent problem for Google, however, has been copyright. There are next to no Picasso artworks in the database, and some artworks must be blurred out in the virtual tours. This has had ivory tower types questioning the usefulness of the Google Art Project to *serious scholarship*. They say that zooming in a lot is nice and all, but they can’t reproduce works for free so what’s the difference?
And at the end of the day, I’m kind of exasperated at everyone, including myself, ruining the fun. Of course there are so many complications, capitalistic and otherwise, making the dream of free access to every art object in reproduction impossible. Fine. Just take it as it is. Looking at pixels will never beat looking at paint. This we all know. But what about the ephemeral? For my thesis, I have spent the better part of a year thinking about an exhibition that occurred in 1962, trying to reconstruct its design and its meanings. I have been able to find no curator notes, no drafts, and very few installation photographs. All I can say is, a scholar attempting to study the 2015 Venice Biennale in the year 2080 is probably going to have a much easier time making heads or tails of it, thanks to Google.
Featured image: High definition detail of Sunday on La Grande Jatte, Google Cultural Institute.
2,602 Comments
Succeed! It could be one of the most useful blogs we have ever come across on the subject. Excellent info! I’m also an expert in this topic so I can understand your effort very well. Thanks for the huge help. 라이브스포츠중계
Different from other Training Ahli K3 Kebakaran uses of store space is the use of space to purely focus on selling experiential services.
The most typical type is Pelatihan K3 Kebakaran the space split by fixed walls into one unit
Thank you for sharing your knowledge and expertise with the world.
Kubet
Then there is the Sertifikasi K3 Ketinggian semi-fixed space, such as the department store areas dedicated to selling cosmetics or shoes.
I think this is a standout amongst the most critical data for me. What”s more, i”m happy perusing your article. Be that as it may, ought to comment on some broad things Customize Tactical Equipment
This is great guidance especially for those new to the blogosphere, providing simple and accurate information… Thanks for sharing this.”
bongvip.asia
These spaces cannot easily be Pelatihan Persiapan Pensiun adjusted in terms of size and layout without investment of significant time and money.
I am glad you take pride in what you write. This makes you stand way out from many other writers that push poorly written content. 라이브스포츠중계
Greetings and love always with BISAJITU EREK EREK TOGEL
A birthday party is a joyful celebration where friends and family gather to honor someone’s special day. It’s often filled with colorful decorations, delicious food, and lots of fun activities. From singing “Happy Birthday” to blowing out candles on a cake, the party is a time for everyone to come together and create happy memories. Games, music, and laughter typically fill the air, and gifts are exchanged as tokens of love and appreciation. Whether it’s a small gathering or a big event, a birthday party is all about celebrating life, happiness, and the joy of growing older surrounded by loved ones.
https://www.birthdaybottleservice.com/birthday-party
Good post , I am going to spend more time researching this topic slot sule
Hello. {Great|fantastic|splendid|impressive|magnificent|excellent|remarkable} job. I did not {expect|imagine|anticipate} this. This is a {great|fantastic|splendid|impressive|excellent|remarkable} story. Thanks!… You made certain fine points there. I did a search on the subject matter and found the majority of folks will have the same opinion with your blog…. login bondan69
24kbet offers a versatile platform with options for sports games and online games, including live sports and a wide range of game titles.
This is just the information I am finding everywhere. Thanks for your blog, I just subscribe your blog. This is a nice blog.. alexistogel daftar
This seems completely suitable. All of scaled-down elements had been produced via numerous report training. I like the applying a lot. pg slot
This could be furthermore a reasonably great article that people definitely valued examining. Certainly not each day that benefit from the probabilities to locate a item. pg slot
Glad to be one of the visitors on this awe inspiring web site : D. acim
This is really fascinating, You are a very professional blogger. I’ve joined your rss feed and sit up for searching for more of your great post. Also, I have shared your site in my social networks! acim eckhart tolle
I like this blog so much, saved to my bookmarks . a course in miracles
May peace always be with all.
https://bisapaus.com/
An example of this is Atypical Mole Syndrome. This syndrome brings about a tendency inside the physique to kind an abnormal amount of moles on our skin. This is some thing that we could have obtained from our parents or our grandparents and we’ve no manage over regardless of whether we obtain it or not. agen toto play
Attractive, post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wanted to say that I have liked browsing your blog posts. After all, I will surely subscribe to your feed, and I hope you will write again soon! song25.com
I high appreciate this post. It’s hard to find the good from the bad sometimes, but I think you’ve nailed it! would you mind updating your blog with more information? branding astral
It is my first visit to your blog, and I am very impressed with the articles that you serve. Give adequate knowledge for me. Thank you for sharing useful material. I will be back for the more great post. 쇼티비
Consumers internet marketing you ought to related pursuit ahead of creation. It is very easy to jot down top-notch write-up in that possition. show01.com
Hey there! Someone in my Facebook group shared this website with us so I came to check it out. I’m definitely enjoying the information. I’m book-marking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Superb blog and wonderful design. david hoffmeister
Can i post on your blog as well? I`m reading your posts since few monts and i think you`ve got amazing blog. Lot`s of interesting things and nice theme If you want to give me an access write me by e-mail. david hoffmeister
Perhaps you should update the php server on your webhost, WordPress is kinda slow. Remove logo from image
The problem with Pelatihan PLC Bandung golf and revenue management is that it usually charges a fixed price
These areas are much Kursus PLC more flexible in terms of changing the products being handled
Connecticut has made Jasa Pembuatan Website Bandung history by being the first town in Connecticut to experience a tornado with winds up to 115 MPH.