I arrived in Venice alone on November 12, 2015. I had been abroad for about two months, and this was the moment I had been waiting for. My scrappy, industrious European adventure would make me feel without a doubt that I hadn’t squandered my time here. I was unfamiliar with traveling alone and terrified that I would drop a ball that ruined the whole trip, but so far I had figured out how to print my Ryanair boarding pass so I wouldn’t be charged 60 pounds at the airport and how get to London’s distant budget airport by 4 AM without major issue. I was even lucky enough to be routed into the normal airport (rather than the budget airport) in Venice due to fog! I was starting to feel like I was going to make it as I boarded the water bus. Student ticket in hand, I was going to one of the most famous art events in the world: the Venice Biennale.
The next day I walked along the water to the Giardini, one of the two largest Biennale venues. I crossed bridge after bridge, and my feet were just starting to fatigue from a long day’s travel when I saw the green gardens appear ahead out of the fog. I spent all day at the Giardini, taking in the main curated exhibition, “All the World’s Futures,” and several national pavilions. In the furthest corner, I found the Polish Pavilion and watched Halka/Haiti 18°48´05˝N 72°23´01˝W by C. T. Jasper and Joanna Malinowska (image below). This piece is a simply-edited panoramic video of the Polish opera Halka performed in a Haitian village, but I watched, mesmerized, for 25 minutes because I knew I would probably never see it again.
I stumbled back to my hotel in a daze, ready to settle into bed until the next day. Then my phone connected to the wifi and I started getting the notifications. News of the violent attacks in Paris permeated the safety of my locked hotel room door. I learned that my Northwestern roommate from freshman year had attended the soccer match that came under attack, but she had returned home safely. Still, attack after attack terrified the city as I sat in Venice, shocked and alone and sad.
The next day, it was just slightly harder than usual to open my door and face the world outside. But today was my only day to see the second part of the Biennale. I followed nearly the same path along the water in the fog to the Arsenale. It didn’t take me long to realize I wasn’t going to enjoy the show that day. I wasn’t feeling at all optimistic about “All the World’s Futures,” and I was greeted in the first gallery by two neon works by Bruce Nauman called Eat Death (1972) and Raw War (1970). I was not in the mood.
I powered through the main show and glanced through a couple of pavilions before collapsing into a chair at the café. It was time to go.
****
I didn’t think it about the Biennale that much in the following couple of months. When I returned to the U.S., I would list it as one of the things I did that meant I hadn’t squandered my time abroad. I felt very lucky to have been able to go, but I couldn’t deny my experience was colored by the terrible events in Paris. It came crashing back into mind, though, when I was introduced to the Google Cultural Institute by one of my courses early in 2016.
The Google Cultural Institute struck me as a thing of beauty. I was no stranger to searchable databases of artwork, but the interface was so polished and smooth. There were countless virtual exhibitions on subject ranging from the fall of the Berlin Wall to Rembrandt van Rijn, and it was all so interesting and easy to interact with. I was blown away by the fact that I could access images of so many works from so many different institutions in one place for free. I could happily get lost down the rabbit hole of virtual tours and collections, reveling in this new accessibility of the arts.
I found the Venice Biennale 2015 project on their news page. I was surprised and intrigued, so I clicked through the “All the World’s Futures” Giardini digital exhibition. It was very strange having been there before, and it brought up mixed feelings about the time I had spent in Venice not long ago. For the first time, I could see odd things about the Google Cultural Institute that I had not questioned before. The context of my viewing the weekend of the Paris attacks had changed my experience of the artwork, but temporal context was eliminated from the Google exhibitions. This emphasized the vague contemporaneity of the Biennale.
I was unable to decide whether I was grateful I could review the Arsenale show after the fact, or whether the stunted experience just made me feel worse for not taking full advantage of being there. On the one hand, I was able to identify a work I liked; I had taken a picture of it but forgotten to note the label information.
My iPhone image, November 13, 2015.
Google Cultural Institute, Giardini Digital Exhibition, Installation Photo
Further, I was able to view an in-depth, documentary virtual exhibition of Halka/Haiti in the Poland Pavilion, but there was no video clip of the work, so I had been right in thinking I would never see it again. The whole experience of reviewing the Biennale via Google was strangely unsettling, and it me to research more about this platform.
The enigmatic, contradictory Google Art Project launched February 1, 2011 to little fanfare and mixed reviews. There were 17 original partner institutions that made all or part of their holdings available online. While most critics lamented the bugs and whirling experience of indoor streetview (largely unchanged in 2016), some disparaged the concept itself because the photography, however hi-def, could never equal the experience of the real thing. Although I basically agree, this strikes me as incredibly elitist. Not everyone is going to have the means to make it to the Uffizi in person, so giving a virtual option radically expands the group of people able to indulge their interest in arts and culture. Many museums are also excited about the possibility of mitigating crowds.
Aside: there are some gray areas to this accessibility.
While they clearly want users to be able to create collections (which sort of remind me of Pinterest), they dangle their “Open Gallery” exhibition technology before budding digital curators (read: me) before dropping the bomb that it is “invite only.”. Okay. So, the wider audience is meant to be “culturally curious” but they should not be granted the same tools as culturally authoritative institutions. Heavens, no…
It didn’t take too long after the launch before people said, “Wait… How are you profiting from this Google?!?!?!” The short answer is, they aren’t. This subset of the company is strictly non-profit. However, when pressed, the Institute’s director Steve Crossan said, “There’s certainly an investment logic to this. Having good content on the Web, in open standards, is good for the Web, is good for the users. If you invest in what’s good for the Web and the users, that will bear fruit.” Okay, but also, Google is good at gathering and selling our metadata and great at keeping quiet about it. It’s a new and mind-bending possibility: billions of art and cultural objects aggregated, and billions of people interacting with them, showing Google (and maybe cultural institutions for the right price) what people are actually interested in (and possibly willing to pay for). Although this service is “free of charge,” there is an untold amount of money bound up in it nonetheless. It suddenly felt ironic that a major theme of the Biennale was “capital” and how it has changed in the 21st century. Evidently it’s a crazy new world.
A persistent problem for Google, however, has been copyright. There are next to no Picasso artworks in the database, and some artworks must be blurred out in the virtual tours. This has had ivory tower types questioning the usefulness of the Google Art Project to *serious scholarship*. They say that zooming in a lot is nice and all, but they can’t reproduce works for free so what’s the difference?
And at the end of the day, I’m kind of exasperated at everyone, including myself, ruining the fun. Of course there are so many complications, capitalistic and otherwise, making the dream of free access to every art object in reproduction impossible. Fine. Just take it as it is. Looking at pixels will never beat looking at paint. This we all know. But what about the ephemeral? For my thesis, I have spent the better part of a year thinking about an exhibition that occurred in 1962, trying to reconstruct its design and its meanings. I have been able to find no curator notes, no drafts, and very few installation photographs. All I can say is, a scholar attempting to study the 2015 Venice Biennale in the year 2080 is probably going to have a much easier time making heads or tails of it, thanks to Google.
Featured image: High definition detail of Sunday on La Grande Jatte, Google Cultural Institute.
1,963 Comments
VEGAS969 is the most complete and trusted online gaming site in Indonesia.
Jogja adalah kota yang penuh dengan pesona dan daya tarik wisata yang beragam. Dengan paket wisata Jogja, Anda dapat menjelajahi berbagai tempat menarik dalam waktu singkat. Mulai dari warisan budaya, pusat perbelanjaan, hingga keindahan alam, semuanya bisa Anda nikmati dalam sehari. Jangan ragu untuk mengambil paket wisata Jogja agar perjalanan Anda lebih teratur dan nyaman. Selamat menikmati trip Jogja yang penuh kenangan!
Birkaç tıklama ile binlerce email gönderin, kolay ve hızlı eposta çözümü ile şimdi tanışın. Şimdi eposta pazarlamasına başlayın, en hızlı ve etkili şekilde kampanyalarınızı duyurun. toplu mail
PANGLIMA77 is an online slot site that provides the highest and most accurate RTP.
TIMUR99 is the best and most favorite online gaming site in Indonesia.
PONDOK969 is an online slot that always provides the best service 24 hours a day.
FURLA77 is a trusted online game site where any winnings are paid in full.
GARUDA55 is an online game site that provides very complete and interesting games.
JAPAN168 is an online slot and lottery site that is very popular among young people to fill their free time.
Kumpulan video Youtube Shorts
Kunjungi website kami dijamin jackpot hanya di Slot Bet 100 Perak
Kunjungi website kami dijamin jackpot hanya di Slot Bet 100
This is a high-quality informational blog. Great job as the author of this blog ติดต่อสอบหวยบี
Wahanatogel adalah situs Ion777 resmi terpercaya saat ini menyediakan banyak sekali member aktif setia menang berapapun kami bayar.
Thank you for sharing your thoughtful insights. Keep sharing informational blog
taya365
Bravo! Informative and engaging—thank you for sharing your knowledge
philboss
I simply wanted to thank you a lot more for your amazing website you have developed here. It can be full of useful tips for those who are actually interested in this specific subject, primarily this very post. Your all so sweet in addition to thoughtful of others and reading the blog posts is a great delight in my opinion. And thats a generous present! Dan and I usually have enjoyment making use of your recommendations in what we need to do in the near future. Our checklist is a distance long and tips will certainly be put to excellent use. naga303
I appreciate the entirety you have got added to my knowledge base.Admiring the effort and time you placed into your blog and special facts you offer.thanks. situs slot gacor hari ini
extraordinary records sharing .. i’m very glad to read this newsletter .. thanks for giving us undergo info.excellent excellent. I respect this submit. slot gacor hari ini gampang menang
I haven’t any phrase to realize this publish…..truly i am inspired from this put up….the person that create this publish it was a terrific human..thank you for shared this with us. situs gacor hari ini
extraordinary records sharing .. i’m very glad to read this newsletter .. thanks for giving us undergo info.excellent excellent. I respect this submit. situs gacor slot
I appreciate the entirety you have got added to my knowledge base.Admiring the effort and time you placed into your blog and special facts you offer.thanks. slot88 login
extraordinary records sharing .. i’m very glad to read this newsletter .. thanks for giving us undergo info.excellent excellent. I respect this submit. slot gacor gampang menang
Very informative and good structure of subject matter, now that’s user genial (:. قیمت انواع سمعک شنوایی
The only place you’ll find success before work is in the dictionary indobet365 Platform Kejuaraan Euro 2024
Really Curious site this is.. I really Enjoy a lot reading your Blog.. I will Bookmark your site for more reference. Daftar ID Pro PKV Games
This information is magnificent. I understand and respect your clear-cut points. I am impressed with your writing style and how well you express your thoughts. Fmovie
Thank you for sharing such useful information. I’m a Writer by profession and I found that today’s students are very curious about their assignments. I recommend them to take assignment Help services from experts. There are some online platforms that offer SAS Assignment Help to students in Australia. One of the key roles within their team is that of the best academic writer. An assignment writer is a professional who specializes in crafting high-quality and well-researched academic papers on various subjects and topics.
Just came across Olivia Smith’s post on Quora highlighting the ‘5 Best Assignment Writing Services Companies in the USA for 2024,’ and I must say, it’s a gem! Olivia’s detailed insights and thorough analysis of each service provider make it easier for students like me to make informed decisions. The post is well-structured and offers valuable recommendations. Definitely bookmarking this for future reference. Thanks, Olivia, for this informative and helpful resource!
You have a real talent for writing unique content. I like how you think and the way you express your views in this article. I am impressed by your writing style a lot. Thanks for making my experience more beautiful. slothoki
Wahanatogel adalah situs Bo Togel Hadiah 2D 200Rb resmi terpercaya saat ini menyediakan banyak sekali member aktif setia menang berapapun kami bayar.
House Lawyers… […]just below, are some totally unrelated sites to ours, however, they are definitely worth checking out[…]… 토토사이트
This blog is very informational and helpful to the viewers. Thank you for sharing!
taya365
This is an educational blog. Thank you for posting this article. philboss
Excellent! I thank you your contribution to this matter. It has been insightful. my blog: how to turn a girl on situs judi QQ Pkv Games
As an avid gamer in Bangladesh, I’ve stumbled upon something truly spectacular. It’s elevated my online gaming experience to new heights, with stakes that are unmatched and gameplay so smooth, it’s like entering a new dimension. I know, it sounds too good to be true. But don’t just take my word for it, check it out at https://mcw-apps.com/customer-service/. The user interface is intuitive, you’ll be a master in no time. And the cherry on top? It’s become my go-to gaming hub. So prepare yourself, this is a real game-changer!
I haven’t any phrase to realize this publish…..truly i am inspired from this put up….the person that create this publish it was a terrific human..thank you for shared this with us. Nigeria & Best Education Consultant in Abuja
i will set up my new concept from this submit. It gives extensive information. thanks for this precious records for all,.. taxi
반면 카지노사이트는 웹사이트에 기반하고 있는 덕에 오프라인 카지노 대비 운영 비용이 극단적으로 적습니다. 섹시카지노
Wahanatogel adalah situs Togel Sydney resmi terpercaya saat ini menyediakan banyak sekali member aktif setia menang berapapun kami bayar.
Your writing creates connection to your readers. Thank you for sharing this post. philboss
Great article! Thank you for tyour significant insights.
philboss
sewa mobil jogja lepas kunci Kencana Cars – Rental Alphard Transformer vellfire, Fortuner VRZ GR Sport, Innova Reborn Zenix Venturer, Hiace Premio Luxury Commuter Avanza FWD dan Isuzu ELF Long NLR.
Hello my loved one! I wish to say that this article is amazing, great written and include almost all important infos. I’d like to peer more posts like this. daftar mataqq pkv games
Reading your article helped me a lot. thank you I invite you to my blog. It will be of great help to you. Please visit us
슬롯사이트
Wahanatogel adalah situs Togel 5000 resmi terpercaya saat ini menyediakan banyak sekali member aktif setia menang berapapun kami bayar.
I just added this to my favorites I truly love reading your posts.Review my web page แนะนำเพื่อน 789bet
I really enjoyed this article; it is well written! Thank you for sharing .
philboss
House Lawyers… […]just below, are some totally unrelated sites to ours, however, they are definitely worth checking out[…]… acim podcast
Good post. Thank you for the knowledge you shared on this blog . philboss
I really appreciate the time and effort you put into your blog posts.
It’s clear that you’re passionate about it.
Car parking shades in Saudi Arabia
I really appreciate the time and effort you put into your blog posts.
It’s clear that you’re passionate about it.
Car parking shades in Saudi Arabia
today is my holiday And I happened to come across your article. It’s really good. I’ll come and read it again next time. ทางเข้า dream gaming