On Witnessing and Reportage

 

Witnessing is a devious thing. On the one hand it serves to better the public understanding to an act, whether joyous or reprehensible, but on the other it may damage the witnesser. The fulcrum of this balance beam is of great concern in the MCA’s exhibition simply titled Witness. Photography is definitionally an encounter between artist and subject, but it also is an act of witnessing, and has been used as such for documentation. The MCA’s exhibit plays with this concept and pushes the boundaries of what it means to encounter and what it means to bear witness.

Similarly, Camille Henrot’s piece for MCA screen is a heavy undertaking. During her time as an art research fellow at the Smithsonian Institute, which the wall text is quick to point out is “The largest conglomerate of museums and research centers in the world… totaling some 137 million artworks, objects, and specimens,” Henrot attempts to piece together the history of the world. In so doing her piece morphs into a meditation on the quixotic nature of assembling knowledge while having virtually endless resources. The act of assemblage, however, is too an act of witnessing. It seeks to bear witness to all in order to report some. To summarize is an active form of bearing witness in that it attempts synthesis.

The choices of video and photographic media for these two exhibits are by no means incidental. These modes of signification are indexical and as such carry more weight of truth. The relation between the signifier and the signified in this case have made physical contact by means of light, and in so doing are directly related, like smoke to fire. As such they create a means of documentation that aims to be irrefutable. This is why Truman insisted on soldiers taking photographs as they liberated camps in Germany and Poland. To bear witness that is absolutely irrefutable.

jaar_1

Breaks in conventional form can bring attention to common assumptions about convention. That is one of the aims of Witness. This is notable in the case of Cindy Sherman, who documented herself for years in the series “Untitled Film Stills.” Sherman photographed only herself, in various costumes and guises, in a series that was linked by nothing but style. She was not simply bearing witness to an identity, she was creating one out of the act of documentation. Because she took those photos, those films sprung into the minds of thousands of her viewers. She bore witness to an entire oeuvre that never existed. If one attempted to imagine the catalog of film created by Sherman’s upwards of 85 “Untitled Film Stills” feeling some grosse fatigue could be understood.

The work of Sherman’s photos can also be understood as bearing witness to the cultural clichés and limited rolls for women in midcentury film and domestic life. Sherman places herself within archetypes of femininity and womanhood but her photos are claustrophobic and anxiety inducing. These emotions run against the grain of the patriarchal norms of both Hollywood and the Home.

The crown jewel of this exhibit is of course Alfredo Jaar’s “Sounds of Silence.” Jaars work is stunning and haunting and it captures the life and death of Kevin Carter with grace. What is meaningful about it is that it forces you, the viewer, to bear witness. In ways Carter could never imagine, Jaar uses his work along with his biography to show to his captive audience exactly the kind of forces that caused Carter to end his own life. As such, you are no longer bearing only witness on the Sudanese famine and the need for photojournalism, but the devastating effects of witnessing itself.

henrot-grossefatigue1

If “Witness” forces us to experience the dark side of human nature, “Grosse Fatigue” gives us the light. Hernot works with creation myths of many creeds and weaves them together through breakneck video windows on her laptop. Over the graphics that show the far reaches of human and natural beauty, creation, and culture, Henrot lays a track of gorgeous stream-of-consciousness poetry, with a pulsing rhythmic beat the mimics the heartbeat of the world. Through this we may bear witness to all the things that truly are worth living for. She creates for us the kind of Dream City that Zadie Smith writes about in her essay, “Speaking in Tongues,” and proves to us that it may be overwhelming and even debilitating at times, living in this world is a thing of beauty.

While many go through life simply consuming things as they are, artists and historians among us bear the burden of paying witness. This is a service to the rest of us that is invaluable. Historicizing and contextualizing are not only necessary for learning and the assemblage of knowledge, but they can be incredibly taxing and altogether harmful for those who under take the task. We owe them our thanks and our respect.

762 Comments

  • masarat commented on February 9, 2022 Reply

    Very nice post, amazing information.

    تركيب مكيفات سبليت بالرياض

    • Robert commented on December 20, 2023 Reply

      Thank you for sharing such an informative and useful content as I was looking for this only. I’m surely going to bookmarked this one. Looking forward for more such articles as I am doing my golang course right now so it is difficult to spare a time nowadays but such post motivates me to come back again.

      • Bussiness Sale commented on March 8, 2024 Reply

        This article is exactly what I needed! The clear and informative content makes it a valuable resource for Golang learners.

        Strengths of the Content:

        Exactly What You Needed: You acknowledge that the article fulfills a specific need you had for Golang information.
        Informative and Useful: You highlight the “informative and useful content” as a strength of the writing.
        Personal Connection:

        Bookmarked for Future Reference: You mention “bookmarking this one” demonstrating the value you find in the article.
        Golang Course and Time Constraints: You share your current situation “doing a Golang course right now” with “limited time”. This personalizes your comment.
        Motivation to Return: Despite the time constraints, you express “motivation to come back again” for future articles. This shows appreciation for the writer’s work.
        Overall, your comment is insightful and engaging. It highlights the usefulness of the content, your personal connection to the topic, and your appreciation for the writer’s work.

        khalidelarbi
        ————————————
        Online Marketing Analysis

        business for sale

  • James Smith commented on March 15, 2022 Reply

    Amazing article. Truly love it. Try visiting Steel Forgings China and learn new things.

  • Tom commented on April 16, 2022 Reply

    Relax! IF some of you guys really need help with essay or homework, you can as this guys and be sure that hey relay now ow https://www.nursingpersonalstatement.com/ to do it! So just text to them professional thesis writer and be ready for wins! Good luk and have fun!

  • Tom commented on April 16, 2022 Reply

    Relax! IF some of you guys really need help with , you can as this guys and be sure that hey relay now ow https://www.nursingpersonalstatement.com/ to do it! So just text to them and be ready for wins! Good luk and have fun!

  • Betmate commented on May 16, 2022 Reply

    에볼플레이 먹튀검증 안전노리터

  • ส้ม commented on May 22, 2022 Reply

    ambpoker โปรโมชั่นรวมโปร ambpoker แจกเครดิตฟรี ทุกวี่วัน รวมทั้ง ก็พิเศษสุดๆเอาไว้ต้อนรับสมาชิกทุกคน megaslotgame ไม่ว่าจะเป็น โปรโมชั่น pg สมัครเป็นสมาชิกใหม่รับ เครดิตฟรี50 หรือเป็นโบนัส

  • Talbot commented on June 28, 2022 Reply

    Really good one keep sharing with us valuable content. Thank you
    CGP

  • jackson commented on July 26, 2022 Reply

    keep sharing informative content i really like your content
    Technology

    • strengthensnort commented on November 23, 2022 Reply

      Dieter Runge, a local legend specialist, guided us for a portion of the 93-mile Hexen-Steig, sometimes known as the “witch climb.” The trail began at Thale, where we passed many tourist phrazle spots and a small adventure park before reaching the tiny Bode Valley and its corresponding riverside dirt road. The Hexentanzplatz and the Rosstrappe, two angular summits, were visible through the treetops.

  • Corey commented on August 3, 2022 Reply

    Interesting one keep sharing valuable content
    almirah

  • Max commented on August 11, 2022 Reply

    really good one keep sharing valuable and informative content
    chakra-jewelry

  • bitcoincasino commented on August 12, 2022 Reply

    I am very impressed with your writing bitcoincasino I couldn’t think of this, but it’s amazing! I wrote several posts similar to this one, but please come and see!

  • bitcoincasino commented on August 12, 2022 Reply

    Looking at this article, I miss the time when I didn’t wear a mask. bitcoincasino Hopefully this corona will end soon. My blog is a blog that mainly posts pictures of daily life before Corona and landscapes at that time. If you want to remember that time again, please visit us.

  • baccarat online commented on August 12, 2022 Reply

    I’m writing on this topic these days, baccarat online, but I have stopped writing because there is no reference material. Then I accidentally found your article. I can refer to a variety of materials, so I think the work I was preparing will work! Thank you for your efforts.

  • แนะนำเพื่อน igoal commented on August 31, 2022 Reply

    Your Website is very good, Your Website impressed us a lot, I like your website very much.
    แนะนำเพื่อน igoal

  • Nitin Raghav commented on September 22, 2022 Reply

    Hey, Great post! I really like the content you have shared. I am going to bookmark your website for future updates. Keep updating!

  • best data mapping tools commented on October 11, 2022 Reply

    best data mapping tools can map any tools and source any amount of data. What makes data mapping tools amazing is that these tools automate the data mapping process and help users map data seamlessly without much effort.
    Here’s our guide about the best data mapping tools that you need to keep in mind.
    best data mapping tools

  • disneyplus.com login/begin commented on October 11, 2022 Reply

    Now that I’ve studied some of the blog posts on your site, I really like the way you blog. I’ve added it to my favorite sites list and will be checking back soon. Please also visit my website and let us know what you think.
    disneyplus.com login/begin

  • Pindahan rumah commented on October 19, 2022 Reply

    Bersama Kami Pindahan Rumah tidak menjadi beban atau sebuah kekhawatiran

  • Help assignment commented on November 2, 2022 Reply

    Fantastic Post. Thank you for sharing your Post. We provide aid with, dissertation writing services, assignment help in Australia. If you’re looking for assistance with a dissertation writing services assignment in AU. We offer a reputable and high-quality service, and we have expert editors on staff work in AU.

  • Florance commented on November 4, 2022 Reply

    I am really impressed with the judgment you presented above. The great assignment help service by the Ideal Assignment Help platform allows students to stay at the top of their class and secure a better future for themselves in today’s competitive era. If you’re looking for assistance with your dissertation helpthen visit The Student Helpline UK.

  • Charlie Johnson commented on November 9, 2022 Reply

    Amex Login after you download and launch the app., the same way you would on a computer, enter your login and password. Once you’ve logged in, you may access your account and perform tasks like setting up an automated bill payment, depositing checks, and viewing the history of transactions whenever you need to.
    You can sign in to your account on the upper left of the Amex Login

  • Dissertation Help commented on November 15, 2022 Reply

    Thanks for this best Blog. We are a service provider in the field of Dissertation help in the United Kingdom. Our experts have 15+ years of experience and complete your Assignment on time with plag free content.

  • Nursing writing services commented on November 28, 2022 Reply

    Your blogs are great.Are you also searching for Nursing evidence-based practice writing services ? we are the best solution for you. We are best known for delivering the best nursing writing services to students without having to break the bank.

  • shadow health writing services commented on November 28, 2022 Reply

    Your blogs are great.Are you also searching for shadow health writing services ? we are the best solution for you. We are best known for delivering shadow health assignments.

  • jaeseu commented on December 7, 2022 Reply

    I found this post very interesting and informative.
    Thank you for sharing your special thoughts with us. I definitely share this with my peeps.
    Visit this and have fun !

    제이나인 온라인 카지노 사이트
    제이나인 안전 카지노 사이트
    제이나인 카지노 검증 사이트
    제이나인 카지노 게임 사이트
    제이나인 라이브 카지노
    https://www.j9korea.com

  • ConnectEBT commented on January 2, 2023 Reply

    Thanks for the information you shared. Loved the way you explained everything in this blog.
    ConnectEBT

  • dasnadas commented on January 6, 2023 Reply

    That was very lonly that was so unhappy \

    Subarunet Login

  • casinositeone.JDS commented on January 7, 2023 Reply

    Hey there. I found your site by the use of Google whilst looking for a similar subject, your site came up. It looks good. 카지노사이트원

  • casinositeone.JDS commented on January 7, 2023 Reply

    I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks to visit then. Feel free to visit my website; 카지노사이트원

  • safetotosite commented on January 7, 2023 Reply

    A very interesting topic that I have been looking at, I think this is one of the most important information for me. And I’m glad to read your post. Thanks for sharing! 먹튀검증

  • casinositenet commented on January 7, 2023 Reply

    Hi everyone, it’s my first go to see at this web page, and paragraph I am very satisfied with visiting here. Thank you for good content. And please visit my website as well. 카지노사이트넷

  • casinositekim commented on January 7, 2023 Reply

    Excellent site you’ve got here.. It’s hard to find high-quality writing like yours nowadays. 카지노사이트킴

  • 온라인카지노 commented on January 9, 2023 Reply

    Awesome and interesting article. Great things you’ve always shared with us. Thanks. Just continue composing this kind of post.

    바카라사이트
    온라인카지노

  • joker gaming commented on January 24, 2023 Reply

    I’m curious to find out what blog system you joker gaming happen to be utilizing? I’m having some minor security issues with my latest site and I would like to find something more safeguarded. Do you have any suggestions?

  • joker commented on January 24, 2023 Reply

    I was recommended this website by joker my cousin. I am not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my trouble. You are amazing! Thanks!

  • เครดิตฟรี 50 commented on January 24, 2023 Reply

    I am really enjoying the theme/design เครดิตฟรี 50 of your web site. Do you ever run into any web browser compatibility problems? A number of my blog audience have complained about my website not operating correctly in Explorer but looks great in Firefox. Do you have any recommendations to help fix this problem?

  • simiriti pandey commented on January 25, 2023 Reply

    Our business caters strictly to upscale clientele. Our escort ladies complete a careful screening process to ensure that you will experience the difference: a carefully chosen women whose appearance Delhi call girls cash payment.

  • pin code of my location commented on January 30, 2023 Reply
  • treans23 commented on February 8, 2023 Reply

    Awesome and interesting article. Great things you’ve always shared with us. Thanks. Just continue composing this kind of post.

    mathswatch

  • casinocommunity commented on February 10, 2023 Reply

    From some point on, I am preparing to build my site while browsing various sites. It is now somewhat completed. If you are interested, please come to play with casinocommunity !!

  • kevin commented on February 17, 2023 Reply

    Thank you for sharing informative content with us

    Cameratech is best Alarm installer in Cardiff

  • jung commented on February 18, 2023 Reply

    Thank you so much for sharing this great article! I really appreciate the amount of thought and effort you have put into it. The information you have provided is very helpful and insightful. It makes me think differently about the topic and provides me with a better understanding of it. Your article is a great source of information and I can’t wait to share it with others. Thank you so much for your hard work and dedication. 나리카페

  • adam commented on February 21, 2023 Reply

    This is really outstanding content you shared keep shared with us i always wait for your content

    Visit – Beerbistro is best beer restaurant in toronto

  • marcus commented on February 21, 2023 Reply

    your content is awesome keep share informative and valuable Thank you

    Visit – LongshoremanInsurance is best Longshore workers comp

  • louies commented on February 22, 2023 Reply

    I really like the content you have shared. I am going to bookmark your website for future updates

    Visit – Acua

  • brett commented on February 22, 2023 Reply

    yes, you’re correct. Please continue to share this excellent content with us.
    visit – recurring revenue

  • horik joudith commented on February 28, 2023 Reply

    The author’s unique perspective and in-depth knowledge were evident throughout the post, making it a worthwhile read. deniminvestor.com

  • baccaratsite commented on February 28, 2023 Reply

    I was looking for another article by chance and found your article baccaratsite I am writing on this topic, so I think it will help a lot. I leave my blog address below. Please visit once.

  • Home Buyer’s Best Friend commented on February 28, 2023 Reply

    I found this post very interesting and informative.

    benefits of a first time home buyer

  • Unicornpages commented on March 3, 2023 Reply

    The Unicorn Coloring Pages are very popular amongst kids. These pages incorporate positive thoughts or messages, which can make them a fun and inspiring way to spend some time coloring and reflecting on positive thoughts. These images depict different scenarios such as Birthdays, Picnics etc. Unicorn coloring pages are a fun and creative activity that can provide hours of entertainment for people of all ages.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *