What is contemporary? If someone asks me, I cannot help but ask back: in what terms? Do you want the dictionary definition? Philosophical definition? One knows such question of categorization cannot be answered succinctly (unless the person who answers is too annoyed or without knowledge), since these terms do not always concur with a fixed definition. Though the core to these terms remain in temporality, they mean more than just time; the terms encompass philosophy, style, historical background, ideologies, and much more. As such, critically defining these terms is a complex task.
Contemporary, in art and museum world, therefore encompasses both the sense of being literally present, or pertaining to presentism, and something more. I know it bothers people that this something more cannot clearly be defined. But again, viewing contemporary solely as being present has problems: Are modernism and postmodernism dead then? Is an artist who is stylistically anachronistic but born during the 21st century a contemporary artist? As such, simply denoting contemporary art in terms of presentism generates contradictions and complications. How, then, do we define contemporary? I define contemporary as the harmony between presentism and contextualization through multi-temporalities. Contemporary encompasses both new sensibility, undisturbed by context and past, and previously overlooked sensibility, discovered through re-reading of historical context. That is, contemporary is defined by both multi-temporal, historical context and present, avant-garde spirit toward future.
Attempt at Contemporary
One attempt to define contemporary is Claire Bishop’s attempt to politicize and contextualize the term. In Claire Bishop’s book “Radical Museology,” Bishop defines contemporary in two terms:
- Presentism – thinking of our current moment as the horizon and destination of our thoughts
- Dialectical method and a politicized project with a more radical understanding of temporality.
First definition is easy to grasp; this definition pertains to presence itself. However, the definition of dialectical contemporary is in some sense radically different. Bishop further defines this dialectical contemporary as she writes, “What I call a dialectical contemporary seeks to navigate multiple temporalities within a more political horizon. Rather than simply claim that many or all times are present in each historical object, we need to ask why certain temporalities appear in particular works of art at specific historical moments. Furthermore, this analysis is motivated by desires to understand our present condition and how to change it.” Multiple temporalities, politicization, history, and better future are the keys to her argument. She believes that contemporary involves multiple temporalities, in which these temporalities and specific historical moments reinforce the sensibility and the context of specific works; the politicization of works through the lens of multiple temporalities, which motivates us toward better future, is what she believes to be contemporary. To further understand what she means by this, we need to take a closer look at Bishop’s examples of her new notion of contemporary. She praises Van Abbemuseum for its attempt to build historical consciousness of museum itself, Reina Sofia for rethinking education and the medium-specific status of the collection, and MSUM for displaying multiple, overlapping time periods (temporalities) to discover previously overlooked historical context.
Reflecting on Bishop’s definition of dialectical contemporary, I understand the importance of contextualization in more profoundly appreciating the work of art. However, although I agree that contemporary seeks multiple-temporalities, Bishop’s notion of contemporary too strongly emphasizes historical and educational role of contemporary; Bishop downplays the importance of presentism.
Presentism and Avant-garde
Contemporary, residing in presentism, is also the springboard for a new, breakthrough sensibility in future. This sensibility involves both technical novelty and resistance against current political tendency (which in Bishop’s case is neo-liberalism). I understand that re-reading historical context of artworks can be great in understanding previously unseen sensibilities; for instance, Bishop praised Reina Sofia for displaying historically relevant newspapers, magazines, songs, and other mediums next to an artwork, creating an overall. more enlightening context for the work. I am sure this exhibition technique discloses previously unnoticed sensibility; as you unveil context and as it reinforces new meaning to work, the work may appear differently. However, though I agree with Bishop’s idea of politicization and historicization to a certain extent, her definition of contemporary seems to neglect or lacks to prioritize the search for a new, avant-garde sensibility. This particular new sensibility is the sensibility that is both challenging to current political concern (neo-liberalism) and is stylistically novel. Although I think Bishop’s vision can set up challenges to current neo-liberal market driven world of contemporary, I doubt if it can expand on avant-garde spirit. Bishop’s definition does not empower presentism as it prioritizes politicization, and this downplay of presentism in comparison to dialectical contemporary discomfits me. Being present and being without ties to history and politicization clears away the distractions for the emergence of avant-garde sensibilities. Thinking of contemporary within historical context is important and enlightening, but genuine avant-garde spirit, that is central to the progress of art in its search for stylistically ‘new,’ should deserve higher or at least equal priority in defining contemporary.
Contemporary Is…
Therefore, contemporary is about both presentism to achieve avant-garde, new sensibility in future, and dialectical contemporary that understands works through certain context established by multi-temporalities and politicization. This definition encompassses the efforts both to be stylistically new and to understand work more deeply through politicization and contextualization. Though my definition is similar to that of Claire Bishop, I want to define contemporary more in terms of presentism rather than of historicization and politicization. I understand that she has problems with neoliberal tendency of art institutions and thus, her definition of contemporary is in a way reactionary to neo-liberalism. However, this backlash definition cannot propel contemporary forward, toward future. Bishop certainly uses the notion of future in her contemporary dialectics, saying that understanding history prepares us for future. I agree with her that understanding work from multiple temporalities and multiple mediums is fruitful for our future attitude in exploring art. However, contemporary art should not be too subject to analysis and contextualization for its progress in sensibilities. If her definition of contemporary emphasizes reframing and re-reading, I emphasize more of presentism. Focusing on senses of present moment increases the possibility for new sensibilities that transcends historical and political context. Because Bishop’s definition is more reactionary to what she hates, which is neo-liberal forces that increasingly affect contemporary, her definition tends to overlook what is central to the progress of art: genuine, avant-garde pursuit of new sensibilities.
Contemporary is both about presentism and contextualization of work through multiple temporalities. First definition stays conducive to the emergence of new sensibilities, and the second definition enables one to see work’s previously unveiled sensibilities. I agree with Bishop’s approach to define contemporary, but I wish that she does not overlook the power of presentism. The power of rereading and reframing is great, it educates us. But art is more than education. It is about exploration of new sensibilities: new sensibilities in style, retained by an artwork itself and intended by its author (not requiring other contexts from multi-temporalities). Contemporary belongs to both sense and logical understanding, and these two work harmonically toward future sensibility that is both completely new (avant-garde) and re-contextualized (previously overlooked). Contemporary should not divert away from presentism just because present is filled with market-driven epidemic of capitalism; in fact, it is sometimes de-contextualization and focus on present moment that produces new sensibility, completely new and groundbreaking in its style and resistant to neo-liberal market context.
1,250 Comments
Learn to say “no” to things that don’t serve you or align with your values. Protect your energy and focus on what truly matters.
replay777
I gotta bookmark this internet site it seems very beneficial invaluable
คาสิโนมือถือ
Support local businesses and artisans by shopping at farmers markets, craft fairs, and independent stores. Invest in your community and support sustainable practices.
bolalion
Challenge yourself to try a new recipe, learn a new skill, or explore a new hobby every month. Keep your mind and body active and engaged.
bolawins
Make a conscious effort to reduce your digital footprint and spend more time offline. Disconnect from technology and reconnect with nature and your loved ones.
megajudi303
Travel the world and experience different cultures, cuisines, and ways of life. Broaden your horizons and expand your understanding of the human experience.
telewin88
Cultivate a sense of humor and find joy in the everyday moments of life. Laughter is a powerful medicine that can heal and uplift.
koi55
Use your creativity to express your unique perspective and inspire others. Share your art, music, writing, or other creative endeavors with the world.
dana-66
Challenge societal norms and question the status quo. Don’t be afraid to think outside the box and propose innovative solutions to complex problems.
elanggame
Use your voice and platform to advocate for social justice and equality. Speak out against injustice and discrimination, and stand up for the marginalized and oppressed.
rajaliga365
Make a conscious effort to reduce your environmental impact. Recycle, conserve water, and choose sustainable products and practices.
mbo4d
Give back to your community by volunteering your time, donating to charity, or simply being kind and helpful to others.
indowin168
Explore your spiritual side and connect with a higher power or universal energy. Find meaning and purpose in your life.
nagaslot888
Practice mindfulness and meditation to reduce stress, improve focus, and increase self-awareness. Cultivate inner peace and tranquility.
judislot7
Find a mentor or coach who can guide you on your journey and help you reach your full potential. Learn from their experience and wisdom.
ternatetoto
Cultivate healthy relationships with friends, family, and romantic partners. Surround yourself with people who support and uplift you.
pria4d
You have the courage to face any challenge.
slot777
Trust your intuition and follow your inner guidance. You have all the answers you need within you; you just need to listen and trust.
suhujp
Embrace change and uncertainty with an open mind and heart. Life is full of surprises, and new opportunities are always waiting around the corner.
tekanslots
What are your personal experiences with [topic of the post]? Share your stories and insights in the comments below!
inulpoker
Remember, you are worthy of love, happiness, and success. Believe in yourself and your dreams, and never give up on your journey.
mojobet89
Embrace your unique talents and passions. Share your gifts with the world and make a positive impact.
mutanslot
Forgive yourself for past mistakes and let go of any guilt or shame. Embrace your imperfections and move forward with grace and compassion.
murahslot
Learn to say “I love you” more often to the people who matter most. Express your gratitude and appreciation for their presence in your life.
muliaslot
“Wow, this was such a great read! I love how you explained everything so clearly and made the topic easy to understand.
BET TO WIN BIG CASH- REGISTER & CLAIM FREE SIGN UP BONUS
Take a break from your routine and try something new and spontaneous. Go on an adventure, explore a new city, or simply say “yes” to something unexpected.
madu88
Create a bucket list of things you want to do before you die. Start checking off items on your list and live life to the fullest.
sumo777
Write a letter to your future self, outlining your goals, dreams, and aspirations. Reflect on your progress and stay motivated on your journey.
tstoto
Take a class or workshop to learn a new skill, such as photography, painting, or coding. Invest in yourself and your personal growth.
persidenselot
Challenge yourself to read a book a month. Expand your knowledge, vocabulary, and imagination.
cuanjp
Learn a new dance or try a new workout routine. Get your body moving and have fun while staying active and healthy.
daisototo
Volunteer your time and skills to a cause you care about. Make a positive impact in your community and help those in need.
88ratu
Learn to meditate or practice deep breathing exercises to reduce stress and anxiety. Cultivate inner peace and tranquility.
dapattoto
Challenge yourself to complete a physical challenge, such as a marathon, triathlon, or obstacle course race. Push your limits and discover your inner strength.
hepybet188
Practice mindfulness in your daily activities. Pay attention to the present moment, engage your senses, and savor each experience.inatoge
Start a gratitude journal and write down three things you’re grateful for each day. Focus on the positive aspects of your life and cultivate a sense of abundance.
sabi4d
Learn to cook a new dish, bake a delicious dessert, or try a new cuisine. Expand your culinary skills and enjoy the process of creating something delicious.
layar138
Take a break from technology and reconnect with nature. Go for a hike, spend time in a park, or simply sit outside and breathe in the fresh air.
boz388
If you want to change the world, start with yourself. Greatness lies not in physical strength, but in the power of goodness that we do together paris88
Dont forget to check my website Paris88 top global best game
Thank you for your dedication to advancing the conversation in [field or industry]. Đánh bạc trực tuyến
I’m feeling more motivated already after reading this. Great work!
Setia138
Such a positive and encouraging post. It’s exactly what I needed.
Setia138
The when I just read a blog, I’m hoping that this doesnt disappoint me approximately this one. Get real, Yes, it was my method to read, but When i thought youd have something interesting to state. All I hear is a number of whining about something that you could fix should you werent too busy trying to find attention. ciobet88
This post is a great reminder to stay positive and focused. Well done!
Setia138
I love the energy in this post. It’s exactly what I needed to stay motivated!
Setia138
I love the positive message in this post. It’s a great source of motivation!
Setia138
Your article has really motivated me. Thanks for the positive vibes!
Setia138
I appreciate the uplifting content in this article. It’s very motivating!
Setia138
농구 중계의 해상도가 뛰어나서 좋아요. hulk24.com