Critics for weekly magazines generally have a limited space to write on; whether they want it or not, they are limited in the number of words. Given this limit, criticism that explicates too much on description of work often fails to expand on meaningful interpretation of work. Therefore, works that are familiar to its audience, which requires relatively little description, leave more room for critics to convey meaningful judgment to its audience. Thus, the level of audience’s familiarity with the criticized work contributes to both style and quality of criticism. Two different critiques, one by Anthony Lane on the Korean film “The Handmaiden”, and another by Hilton Als on Amy Schumer’s performance, explicitly show how the nature of criticism is shaped by audience’s familiarity with the criticized work. “The Handmaiden,” as a distant foreign film, requires its criticism to spend much time describing its plot and its foreign background that it fails to reach a clear, meaningful interpretation. On the other hand, Amy Schumer’s familiarity with the general audience helps Als to talk more about implication and meaning of her work rather than about description.
“The Handmaiden” is a Korean film directed by one of the most acclaimed Korean directors, Park Chan-Wook. The film is centered around a handmaiden’s affair with her master, Lady Hideko, who is under the protection of her mysterious and dangerous guardian, Kouzouki. As she grows older, Lady Hideko increasingly senses the danger of living under her wicked and perverted guardian. Sookee, a handmaiden newly hired to serve Lady Hideko, feels pity and love for her. Together with Lady Hideko, Sookee eventually escapes Kouzouki’s influences through the series of dangerous and bold plans. When the film was first released, it was noted for its explicitly sexual scenes between Sookee and Lady Hideko. With director Park’s remark that their relationship is not of two homosexuals, but of two human beings who are attracted to each other, his film tries to show a relationship that transcends lovers’ sexual orientation.
Anthony Lane’s review aptly summarizes the basic plot of “The Handmaiden.” He describes what happens and lays out the tension between different characters. Furthermore, Lane spends his time discussing the director Park Chan-Wook’s previous works, such as Old Boy, providing where “The Handmaiden” stands in terms of Park’s work spectrum. However, spending too much time on plot and director, Lane’s critique lacks in its interpretation of the film. Though he tries to throw in bits and pieces of his own interpretation as he moves through the plot, they do not seriously question or interpret the crucial themes of the film. In the last paragraph, he tries more in-depth analysis of the film as he says the secret of the film is “its love of secrets.” However, such analysis is too short to achieve anything and falls short of touching the central theme of this film: the relationship between Sookee (the handmaiden) and Lady Hideko.
Because his critique is about an unfamiliar (at least to the popular American audience) Korean film set in the complex historical background of the Japanese occupation of Korea during the early 20th century, Lane endeavors to summarize and let his readers understand what the movie is about; he even mentions the history necessary to understand what is going on in the film. In the process of doing this in a weekly magazine section, Lane fails to delve deeper into the central theme of the movie, or to provide a meaningful judgment. He provides necessary knowledge in understanding a foreign film, but in doing so, he fails to spend time interpreting its implication and conveying the film’s sensibility.
Hilton Als’s critique on Amy Schumer’s performances is more straightforward and relevant to providing a meaningful judgment to its audiences. Hilton Als interprets how the elements of sexual degradation, the language of schoolboy misogyny, and perversity are apparent in Schumer’s performances. Als then expresses how Schumer’s performance still can incorporate her identity as a woman, without degrading her own sexuality and relying on misogyny; he encourages her to talk more about her stories of her father, her time as a waitress, and so on, rather than to joke about misogynic and sexual stereotypes. His criticism is directed more towards providing a meaningful implication of her performances, and the direction that she should strive toward.
Compared to Lane’s critique on film, Als has certain advantages in writing about a familiar performance rather than about a foreign film. He starts his critique, “Amy Schumer is on tour just now, and if you’ve loved her on TV, as I have, I suggest you see her perform live.” As such, the premise of his criticism is that general American audiences are familiar with Amy Schumer. Because the audience is familiar with Schumer, Als omits writing about the extensive description of her performance, and starts right away with interpreting her performance’s implication.
Overall, “The Handmaiden” critique does not penetrate the film; it is only superficial. Though Lane’s review achieves to provide the general knowledge about the plot and its director, it falls short of providing a meaningful judgment; Lane provides knowledge, but he does not provide any unique sensibility in approaching this film. He has the task to both familiarize and provide sensibility to the New Yorker audiences, and it is a difficult one especially when the film is Korean. On the other hand, because the general audience of the New Yorker is much more familiar with the American stand-up comedian Amy Schumer, Hilton Als focuses more on talking about his own taste toward Schumer’s performances. To Als, knowledge that is needed to provide a meaningful judgment is already embedded, to a certain extent, in the general audience.
As such, audience’s familiarity with the criticized work influences the nature of criticism. If critics can write on and on in a weekly magazine, they are much more likely to achieve both description and interpretation; however, because the number of words are limited, they need to balance between the amount of description and the amount of interpretation. When audiences are familiar with the work, there is less need for description, which helps the critic to write more about interpretation. Critics by themselves cannot determine the distance between critics and audiences. Rather, the distance between the criticized work and its audience contributes to how a critic stays with his or her audience. For the critic to stand with the audiences, the audiences need to be familiar with the work; you cannot talk to someone in a familiar tone if that person has no or scarce idea about the work in general.
1,385 Comments
I just wanted to take a moment to express my appreciation for the fantastic content shared by the admin. It’s clear how much thought and effort goes into every piece. I’ve read so many uplifting comments from others about their experiences with AI SEO Services, and it inspired me to share my own. Their expertise truly shines in helping businesses achieve smarter digital marketing. If you’re looking to enhance your online presence, I highly recommend checking out their E-commerce SEO services!
Your article has sparked a conversation that I believe is important and necessary.
game nổ hũ
The partner rewards from 6club are a game changer. It is exciting to see how my invitations can lead to real earnings.
I am grateful for the clarity and insight your article has provided. cách kiếm tiền online
slot rp8888 telah memantapkan dirinya sebagai pusat situs judi online terbesar dan terpercaya di Indonesia.
Ratu123 selalu memberikan promosi menarik untuk member baru dan lama.
new release OC claim Free bonus up to 777 just sign up and download the app..withdrawable!!! NO DEPOSIT REQUIRED!!! just reach P777 amount or higher!!!
click and register now!
Telegram下载 offers a platform that, much like a critic’s interpretation of film, allows for deeper analysis and meaningful discussions. In the case of a complex movie like The Handmaiden, which requires both description and interpretation, Telegram groups provide a space where fans and critics alike can debate its layers, offering insights that traditional media outlets with limited word count might miss.
Telegram中文版下载 serves as an ideal platform for ongoing conversations around films like The Handmaiden. Just as the article mentions the challenges critics face with limited space, Telegram allows users to break free from those constraints, fostering detailed discussions on everything from plot description to character motivation, without worrying about running out of room for meaningful interpretations.
Raja123 telah meningkatkan standar untuk permainan daring dengan berbagai permainan slot gacor yang beragam.
Dengan speaker langit-langit bose indonesia Professional, mencapai suara berkualitas tinggi tidak pernah semudah atau lebih bergaya.
The nights at basant club are legendary. Great competition and a friendly crowd!
slot gacor
rp8888
The bonuses from the colour prediction game on Win101 are impressive. I recommend giving it a shot to everyone.
pusat4d memiliki komunitas pemain yang bersemangat. Senang berbagi kiat dan strategi dengan orang lain yang menikmati perjudian slot daring.
Situs terbaik thailand RP8888
An impressive share, I simply with all this onto a colleague who had previously been performing a small analysis within this. And hubby actually bought me breakfast since I found it for him.. smile. So let me reword that: Thnx for the treat! But yeah Thnkx for spending the time to debate this, I’m strongly about it and adore reading more on this topic. If it is possible, as you become expertise, does one mind updating your blog site with increased details? It is actually highly helpful for me. Huge thumb up because of this short article! deluna4d login
I admire your ability to distill complex ideas into clear and concise prose. trang cá cược bóng đá
fb999 is the ultimate destination for gamblers! The variety of games is impressive.
Slot RP8888 stands out as one of the most exceptional online slot platforms, offering players a top-tier gaming experience with exciting features and incredible opportunities to win.
Sapanca Bungalov evlerinde cazip fiyatlarla tatil fırsatlarını kaçırmayın! En uygun indirimlerle hemen rezervasyon yapın.
The satisfaction I get from using a Fume vape is unmatched. It provides a smooth and enjoyable hit every time.
Thank you for the interesting tips you’ve shared here. https://789bet.domains/
Thanks a lot my dear. gk88
Thank you for your unwavering commitment to excellence.
đánh bài online
nft games are revolutionizing the gaming industry, allowing players to own in-game assets with real-world value. Players can trade, sell, or collect these NFTs, creating a whole new economy within the gaming ecosystem.
Saya suka bonus yang ditawarkan oleh https://raja99.lat/. Sangat membantu!
Setiap slot memiliki fitur unggulan yang dapat memberikan keuntungan besar saat bermain.
Good content and nice writing, thank you for sharing this content.
rp8888
Nice content and good writing blog
slot thailand
Nothing compares to Weber using Genesis sort of grills. That is certainly the type gas grills which have been that will always make sure that they deliver a high performance part of down interval bandar slot onlin
spaceman
slot bet 100
Good article, nice content, keep it up!
rp8888
Good to see this amazing article nice writing!
scatter hitam
Visual di Zeus Slot bikin betah main berjam-jam!
SpinBet99 menawarkan berbagai macam slot dengan gameplay yang seru dan penuh kejutan.
Nice content writing
scatter hitam
To save my sanity
rp8888
This article is very amazing!
rp8888
Nice writing for this amazing article
rp8888
dom toto menawarkan pengalaman seluler yang lancar. Saya dapat dengan mudah memainkan permainan lotere favorit saya dari mana saja kapan saja.
Thank you for sharing this amazing article
rp8888
Spinbet99
Your article is a testament to your expertise and dedication to your craft.หวย มาเล ย์ วัน นี้ 4d
Pengalaman saya dengan BettogelAsia sangat luar biasa, terutama dengan pembayaran cepatnya.
Your writing resonated with me on a personal level, and I am thankful for the connection it fostered. yeebet
Baru aja coba slot, lumayan dapet jackpot kecil, jadi semangat terus!
Extraordinary things you’ve generally imparted to us. Simply continue written work this sort of posts.The time which was squandered in going for educational cost now it can be utilized for studies.Thanks bandar slot online
Thank you
rp8888