On October 10, 2016, New Yorker talks about “putting Marx back” in his nineteenth century surroundings.” (Louis Menand, “Karl Marx, Yesterday and Today”)
On October 17, 2016, New Yorker talks about “modernizing” Shakespeare into the twenty-first century. (Adam Gopnik, “Why Rewrite Shakespeare?”)
Menand critiques two recent books arguing to put Marx back in his context, and Gopinik critiques current adaptions of several Shakespearean plays. While the two essays seem to be addressing movements towards different directions, both discuss the same question:
What is our relationship with works of the past and their authors, and how should we treat them?
1. Where to Place Marx and Shakespeare
Putting Marx back to the nineteenth century:
Menand first lays out the main arguments Marx claims in “The Communist Manifesto,” from the wealth stemming from modern industry, to the worker revolution he predicts the unequal distribution of such wealth would trigger. He then brings up two recent books that “are committed to returning [Marx] to his own century,” written by Jonathan Sperber and Gareth Stedman Jones respectively.
Menand argues that such Historizing as “correcting for the tendency to presentize the past” is worthy. As Jonathan Sperber insists, “Marx is more a figure of the past than a prophet of the present.” Many of his arguments are directed against “thinkers now obscure” and “interpretations of events largely forgotten.” That is, much of Marx’s fights are over parochial stakes rooted in his time, and knowing this allows us to correct our tendency of wrongly assigning the fights meanings grander than they have.
Nonetheless, Menand stresses Marx’s relevance even today: “‘The Communist Manifesto’ is like a bomb about to go off in your hand.’” In his words, “You can put Marx back into the nineteenth century, but you cannot keep him there.” Most importantly, Marx changes how people think in at least the following ways. First, he suggests that we use philosophy not only to interpret the world, but also to change it. Second, he concurs that we as humans naturally create ideologies to make sense of the world, but reminds us that they are human inventions, but not “the way things are,” nor are they inevitable. Third, he provides a model of class struggle that applies even to today’s social relations, although not strictly in his bourgeoisie- proletariat divide.
Modernizing Shakespeare to the twenty-first century:
Gopnik goes through the recent adaptions of Shakespeare: “Merchant of Venice” is adapted into “Shylock is My Name,” where the Venice merchant becomes an art collector Simon Strulovitch, and the core conflict on the pound of flesh becomes his insistence on circumcising his soon-to-be son-in-law. “The Taming of the Shrew” is adapted into “Vinegar Girl,” where Kate, a socially awkward woman “becomes more herself by being made to engage with someone as odd as she is.” “Hamlet” is reproduced in twenty-first century context, too, with Hamlet telling the story as a fetus from Gertrude’s womb. In short, they keep the “twists” of the original plays, from anti-Semitism to the subjugation of women to art and isolation, but weave them into different tales.
Gopnik sees merit in such adaptions. He believes that the “twists” are closer to the essence of Shakespearean plays than the “story content,” just as the music is closer to the essence of “Cosi Fan Tutte” than the plot. That is, Gopnik acknowledges that the themes debated in Shakespeare’s plays are still debated today.
However, Gopnik also points out the un-Shakespearean nature of such adaptions. That is, we think in a different way from Shakespeare, and the adaptions “impose a value system that [Shakespeare] did not share.” “Shakespeare believed in fate, order, and forgiveness;” he argues, “we believe in history, justice, and compassion.” While Anne Tyler, the novelist who adapted “The Taming of the Shrew” gives details of Kate’s inner world to make her actions plausible, just as other modern novelists would explain why evil people are evil by looking into their “trauma and history,” Shakespeare would attribute the wickedness to their “nature and destiny.”
2. Similar Yet Different: Authors from the Past and Us
Menand and Gopnik both discuss the differences and similarities the authors of past works have with us, although in reversed order. By noting such differences and similarities, they acknowledge the complexity and tension created by the co-existing pair.
On the one hand, we are fundamentally different from the past authors, and our times different from theirs, because nothing can be “unhappened,” and no word can be “unsaid.” Time flows in one direction, and events and literatures necessarily take place between the authors and us. As a result, we would act differently: In our body today there are struggles of our ancestors, and such memories shape the way we act. Having witnessed American Independence and French Revolution, while one can still value “order,” like Shakespeare did, he or she can hardly hold it on the unquestionable pedestal. At the same time, we would also think differently: Words carry thoughts, and more importantly, ways of thinking, and thus we are influenced by literatures that did not influence the authors in the past- including their own works. When looking at current politics, it is inevitable to have Marx sitting in the back of our minds: While the bourgeoisie- proletariat division seems to be alleviated by access to votes, new division such as the immigrants versus natives and the resourced versus the underprivileged can easily fit into the same pattern.
On the other hand, we are similar to them, and our time similar to theirs. We still have the instinct to form ideologies to explain the inexplicable world as Marx has observed, and we still struggle to analyze the relationship between identity and ethnicity, a question raised in “The Merchant of Venice.” In our time, “class wars” still take place, and women are not yet free from the oppressions that chained Kate.
3. What Should We Do: Put Marx back to His Time, But Not Keep Him There
Given the juxtaposition of the differences and similarities, how should we treat authors from the past and their works? I believe the quote from Menand summarizes an advisable attitude: We should put Marx back to his time, but do not keep him there. That is, we should actively learn from their work, knowing that one’s time influences one’s ideas. For example, we should closely study the Ancient Greek classics, but bear in mind that to accuse Greeks of moral corruption on the basis of slavery is at best oversimplification.
Putting authors back to their contexts not only removes illusions and misunderstandings about their works, as Sperber and Stedman Jones argue, but also strips away the basis of our self-righteousness: Since we too are in our particular context just as they are in theirs, we are in no position to impose our assumptions and standards on them, but should first critique such assumptions and standards, parsing our own context.
The critique of our own context helps us to understand ourselves better- we can now find what in us might be intrinsic human nature by seeking what has not changed, and analyze what are shaped by history of past events and literature, and how they are so shaped. That is, by recognizing contexts of past works, we inquire into our nature.
With the inquiry into human nature, we would also be able to see the world we essentially construct with our words more clearly- just like philosophers who disillusion us by putting ideologies back to their place as social constructs, by acknowledging ourselves as the source of concepts, we challenge the status quo as not necessarily inevitable, and not necessarily justified.
The similarities between ourselves and our ancestors are crucial to such learning: The fact that while we give different answers from our ancestors, we are after the same questions suggests that we can compare and contrast ourselves with them, and that we would be justified to attribute our differences to history because we are not comparing two essentially difference species.
1,899 Comments
Your creativity in the classroom is outstanding. You find new and exciting ways to make learning enjoyable
Merak555
Hello, I was looking on the internet and I ran into your website. Keep up the excellent work. a course in miracles facebook
I went over this website and I conceive you have a lot of fantastic information, saved to my bookmarks (:. a course in miracles facebook
I went over this website and I conceive you have a lot of fantastic information, saved to my bookmarks (:. a course in miracles audio
I’ve been visiting your blog for a while now and I always find a gem in your new posts. Thanks for sharing. a course in miracles
Hallo super toller Blog den ihr da habt. Bin gerade über die MSN Suche darüber gestolpert. Gefällt mir echt super gut. macht weiter so. MFG Susi เว็บสล็อตตรง ไม่ล็อคยูส
Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive read anything similar to this just before. So nice to find somebody with original ideas on this subject. realy we appreciate you starting this up. this fabulous website is one thing that is required online, a person with some originality. beneficial job for bringing interesting things for the internet! เว็บสล็อตตรง ไม่ล็อคยูส
The practical advice and clear explanations make this a very valuable article. Well done!
Merak555 Slot Online Populer 2024
You have a gift for words I will give you that. If only I had the same gift ศูนย์รวมโปรสล็อตใหม่
Excellent! I thank you your contribution to this matter. It has been insightful. my blog: how to turn a girl on ศูนย์รวมโปรสล็อตใหม่
Your commitment to student success is evident in everything you do. Thank you for your hard work!
Merak555
Wonderful post.I like the post.It is very informative and helpful for writing.
เดิมพันกีฬาออนไลน์
Villa Movers Dubai are professional moving services dedicated to providing a seamless and stress-free relocation experience for villa owners in Dubai. These specialized movers offer comprehensive solutions, including packing, loading, transportation, unloading, and unpacking, tailored to the unique needs of villa-sized moves. With expertise in handling delicate and valuable items, furniture, and appliances, Villa Movers in Dubai ensure safe and efficient relocation, whether you’re moving within the city or to a new emirate. Their team of experienced professionals uses high-quality packing materials and modern equipment to safeguard your belongings throughout the moving process. villa movers Dubai
Thank you for sharing your wisdom and insights with your readers. đánh bài online
Hey there! Great post! Please do tell us when we shall see a follow up! SLOT AYAMTOTO
This article is a great balance of depth and clarity. It’s a pleasure to read.
Merak555
I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often. SEO Company College Station
Your presence is always a positive force
Mahkota555
The way you presented this topic is both thorough and thought-provoking. Excellent work!
Merak555
Keep up the good work , I read few posts on this web site and I conceive that your blog is very interesting and has sets of fantastic information. zeus4d
Thank you so much for sharing this great blog.Very inspiring and helpful too.Hope you continue to share more of your ideas.I will definitely love to read. situs slot
Thanks for a wonderful share. Your article has proved your hard work and experience you have got in this field. Brilliant .i love it reading. slot online
Yes, I am entirely agreed with this article, and I just want say that this article is very helpful and enlightening. I also have some precious piece of concerned info !!!!!!Thanks. zeus4d slot
This type of message always inspiring and I prefer to read quality content, so happy to find good place to many here in the post, the writing is just great, thanks for the post. TOPGUN77
I just found this blog and have high hopes for it to continue. Keep up the great work, its hard to find good ones. I have added to my favorites. Thank You. JUMANJI88
انتخاب بهترین سایت شرط بندی برای علاقه مندان این صنعت مهم می باشد. زیرا عضویت در یک سایت شرط بندی فیک می تواند مشکلات بزرگی را برای مخاطبان ایجاد کند. معتبر ترین سایت شرط بندی امنیت و اعتبار کاربران را تامین می کند.
سایت شرط بندی فوتبال
HappyToon 웹툰추천 : Introduction to the most popular free webtoons 웹툰추천
HappyToon 해피툰 : Introduction to the most popular free webtoons 해피툰
HappyToon 웹툰사이트 : Introduction to the most popular free webtoons 웹툰사이트
HappyToon 무료웹툰사이트 : Introduction to the most popular free webtoons 무료웹툰사이트
HappyToon 무료웹툰 : Introduction to the most popular free webtoons 무료웹툰
HappyToon 웹툰추천 : which has the largest number of webtoons currently being serialized. 웹툰추천
HappyToon 해피툰 : which has the largest number of webtoons currently being serialized. 해피툰
HappyToon 웹툰사이트 : which has the largest number of webtoons currently being serialized. 웹툰사이트
HappyToon 무료웹툰사이트 : which has the largest number of webtoons currently being serialized. 무료웹툰사이트
HappyToon 무료웹툰 : which has the largest number of webtoons currently being serialized. 무료웹툰
HappyToon 웹툰추천 : the fastest place to check free webtoon addresses. 웹툰추천
HappyToon 해피툰 : the fastest place to check free webtoon addresses. 해피툰
HappyToon 웹툰사이트 : the fastest place to check free webtoon addresses. 웹툰사이트
HappyToon 무료웹툰사이트 : the fastest place to check free webtoon addresses. 무료웹툰사이트
HappyToon 무료웹툰 : the fastest place to check free webtoon addresses. 무료웹툰
انتخاب بهترین سایت شرط بندی برای علاقه مندان این صنعت مهم می باشد. زیرا عضویت در یک سایت شرط بندی فیک می تواند مشکلات بزرگی را برای مخاطبان ایجاد کند. معتبر ترین سایت شرط بندی امنیت و اعتبار کاربران را تامین می کند.
سایت شرط بندی معتبر
Im no expert, but I believe you just made an excellent point. You certainly fully understand what youre speaking about, and I can truly get behind that. zeus4d link alternatif