On October 10, 2016, New Yorker talks about “putting Marx back” in his nineteenth century surroundings.” (Louis Menand, “Karl Marx, Yesterday and Today”)
On October 17, 2016, New Yorker talks about “modernizing” Shakespeare into the twenty-first century. (Adam Gopnik, “Why Rewrite Shakespeare?”)
Menand critiques two recent books arguing to put Marx back in his context, and Gopinik critiques current adaptions of several Shakespearean plays. While the two essays seem to be addressing movements towards different directions, both discuss the same question:
What is our relationship with works of the past and their authors, and how should we treat them?
1. Where to Place Marx and Shakespeare
Putting Marx back to the nineteenth century:
Menand first lays out the main arguments Marx claims in “The Communist Manifesto,” from the wealth stemming from modern industry, to the worker revolution he predicts the unequal distribution of such wealth would trigger. He then brings up two recent books that “are committed to returning [Marx] to his own century,” written by Jonathan Sperber and Gareth Stedman Jones respectively.
Menand argues that such Historizing as “correcting for the tendency to presentize the past” is worthy. As Jonathan Sperber insists, “Marx is more a figure of the past than a prophet of the present.” Many of his arguments are directed against “thinkers now obscure” and “interpretations of events largely forgotten.” That is, much of Marx’s fights are over parochial stakes rooted in his time, and knowing this allows us to correct our tendency of wrongly assigning the fights meanings grander than they have.
Nonetheless, Menand stresses Marx’s relevance even today: “‘The Communist Manifesto’ is like a bomb about to go off in your hand.’” In his words, “You can put Marx back into the nineteenth century, but you cannot keep him there.” Most importantly, Marx changes how people think in at least the following ways. First, he suggests that we use philosophy not only to interpret the world, but also to change it. Second, he concurs that we as humans naturally create ideologies to make sense of the world, but reminds us that they are human inventions, but not “the way things are,” nor are they inevitable. Third, he provides a model of class struggle that applies even to today’s social relations, although not strictly in his bourgeoisie- proletariat divide.
Modernizing Shakespeare to the twenty-first century:
Gopnik goes through the recent adaptions of Shakespeare: “Merchant of Venice” is adapted into “Shylock is My Name,” where the Venice merchant becomes an art collector Simon Strulovitch, and the core conflict on the pound of flesh becomes his insistence on circumcising his soon-to-be son-in-law. “The Taming of the Shrew” is adapted into “Vinegar Girl,” where Kate, a socially awkward woman “becomes more herself by being made to engage with someone as odd as she is.” “Hamlet” is reproduced in twenty-first century context, too, with Hamlet telling the story as a fetus from Gertrude’s womb. In short, they keep the “twists” of the original plays, from anti-Semitism to the subjugation of women to art and isolation, but weave them into different tales.
Gopnik sees merit in such adaptions. He believes that the “twists” are closer to the essence of Shakespearean plays than the “story content,” just as the music is closer to the essence of “Cosi Fan Tutte” than the plot. That is, Gopnik acknowledges that the themes debated in Shakespeare’s plays are still debated today.
However, Gopnik also points out the un-Shakespearean nature of such adaptions. That is, we think in a different way from Shakespeare, and the adaptions “impose a value system that [Shakespeare] did not share.” “Shakespeare believed in fate, order, and forgiveness;” he argues, “we believe in history, justice, and compassion.” While Anne Tyler, the novelist who adapted “The Taming of the Shrew” gives details of Kate’s inner world to make her actions plausible, just as other modern novelists would explain why evil people are evil by looking into their “trauma and history,” Shakespeare would attribute the wickedness to their “nature and destiny.”
2. Similar Yet Different: Authors from the Past and Us
Menand and Gopnik both discuss the differences and similarities the authors of past works have with us, although in reversed order. By noting such differences and similarities, they acknowledge the complexity and tension created by the co-existing pair.
On the one hand, we are fundamentally different from the past authors, and our times different from theirs, because nothing can be “unhappened,” and no word can be “unsaid.” Time flows in one direction, and events and literatures necessarily take place between the authors and us. As a result, we would act differently: In our body today there are struggles of our ancestors, and such memories shape the way we act. Having witnessed American Independence and French Revolution, while one can still value “order,” like Shakespeare did, he or she can hardly hold it on the unquestionable pedestal. At the same time, we would also think differently: Words carry thoughts, and more importantly, ways of thinking, and thus we are influenced by literatures that did not influence the authors in the past- including their own works. When looking at current politics, it is inevitable to have Marx sitting in the back of our minds: While the bourgeoisie- proletariat division seems to be alleviated by access to votes, new division such as the immigrants versus natives and the resourced versus the underprivileged can easily fit into the same pattern.
On the other hand, we are similar to them, and our time similar to theirs. We still have the instinct to form ideologies to explain the inexplicable world as Marx has observed, and we still struggle to analyze the relationship between identity and ethnicity, a question raised in “The Merchant of Venice.” In our time, “class wars” still take place, and women are not yet free from the oppressions that chained Kate.
3. What Should We Do: Put Marx back to His Time, But Not Keep Him There
Given the juxtaposition of the differences and similarities, how should we treat authors from the past and their works? I believe the quote from Menand summarizes an advisable attitude: We should put Marx back to his time, but do not keep him there. That is, we should actively learn from their work, knowing that one’s time influences one’s ideas. For example, we should closely study the Ancient Greek classics, but bear in mind that to accuse Greeks of moral corruption on the basis of slavery is at best oversimplification.
Putting authors back to their contexts not only removes illusions and misunderstandings about their works, as Sperber and Stedman Jones argue, but also strips away the basis of our self-righteousness: Since we too are in our particular context just as they are in theirs, we are in no position to impose our assumptions and standards on them, but should first critique such assumptions and standards, parsing our own context.
The critique of our own context helps us to understand ourselves better- we can now find what in us might be intrinsic human nature by seeking what has not changed, and analyze what are shaped by history of past events and literature, and how they are so shaped. That is, by recognizing contexts of past works, we inquire into our nature.
With the inquiry into human nature, we would also be able to see the world we essentially construct with our words more clearly- just like philosophers who disillusion us by putting ideologies back to their place as social constructs, by acknowledging ourselves as the source of concepts, we challenge the status quo as not necessarily inevitable, and not necessarily justified.
The similarities between ourselves and our ancestors are crucial to such learning: The fact that while we give different answers from our ancestors, we are after the same questions suggests that we can compare and contrast ourselves with them, and that we would be justified to attribute our differences to history because we are not comparing two essentially difference species.
1,289 Comments
Spicing Up Your Intimacy: Hot Sex Tips and Tricks bokep indonesia
Your blogs are really good and informative keep sharing such good content. 789 ทางเข้า
I simply must tell you that you have written an excellent and unique article that I really enjoyed reading. I’m fascinated by how well you laid out your material and presented your views. Thank you. acim
omg! can’t imagine how fast time pass, after August, ber months time already and Setempber is the first Christmas season in my place, I really love it! a course in miracles
I simply must tell you that you have written an excellent and unique article that I really enjoyed reading. I’m fascinated by how well you laid out your material and presented your views. Thank you. indoxx1
Can’t imagine how fast time pass, after August, ber months time already and Setempber is the first Christmas season in my place, I really love it! juraganfilm
I have been exploring for a little bit for any high quality articles or blog posts in this sort of house . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this website. Reading this info So i am satisfied to show that I’ve a very just right uncanny feeling I found out exactly what I needed. I such a lot for sure will make sure to don’t disregard this site and provides it a look on a constant. kanjengtoto
I am glad to be a visitant of this double dyed web site, appreciate it for this rare info! kanjengtoto
บีวิน The best popular casin0 game
SITUS SLOT ONLINE PASTI MAXWIN. PLAY NOW!!!!! CLICK ->> ALPHASLOT88
SITUS SLOT ONLINE PASTI MAXWIN. PLAY NOW!!!!! CLICK –> PLAY FOR MAXWIN WITH ALPHASLOT88
I simply must tell you that you have written an excellent and unique article that I really enjoyed reading. I’m fascinated by how well you laid out your material and presented your views. Thank you. pafikotapadangaro.org
Immigration solicitors
Immigration Lawyers UK’s solicitors possess the necessary expertise and knowledge in any legal matters that may be included in your case.
SITUS SLOT ONLINE TERPERCAYA DAN PASTI MAXWIN. PLAY IT NOW!!!!! CLICK ->> ALPHASLOT88
New web site is looking good. Thanks for the great effort. alexistogel
그것은 완전히 흥미로운 블로그 게시입니다. 저는 종종 Diwali Bumper Lottery에 대한 내 프로젝트의 도움을 위해 귀하의 게시물을 방문하고 귀하의 슈퍼 쓰기 기능은 진정으로 나를 깜짝 놀라게했습니다. 미라클 도메인 주소
I believe, life’s more for example a battlefield, both equally armies skin oneself, the light gives you Pifu all the bravery is just not just enough, there has to be tip, there are actually certain schemes together with projects prior to they’re able to do anything whatsoever, we will need to think carefully about, not necessarily blind to this problem, systems work efficiently possibly not set off unneeded waste together with letdown. kanjengtoto
I hate my boss. So during the spare times, I am quite down and dumbed from the repetitive tasks. Your posts give my brain some needed excercise. Thanks! kanjengtoto
Excellent blog post. Thanks for this valuable information
Start your epic journey by registering for our online game now, and enjoy special rewards and exciting challenges right from the start! Don’t wait—join thousands of players in the adventure of a lifetime. taya365
I’m not sure exactly why but this website is loading extremely slow for me. Is anyone else having this issue or is it a issue on my end? I’ll check back later and see if the problem still exists.
I have learned some new elements from your web site about pcs. Another thing I have always imagined is that laptop computers have become a product that each family must have for several reasons. They supply you with convenient ways in which to organize homes, pay bills, go shopping, study, hear music and even watch television shows. An innovative strategy to complete many of these tasks is a laptop computer. These personal computers are portable ones, small, effective and lightweight. Website Traffic
I simply must tell you that you have written an excellent and unique article that I really enjoyed reading. I’m fascinated by how well you laid out your material and presented your views. Thank you. indowin88
omg! can’t imagine how fast time pass, after August, ber months time already and Setempber is the first Christmas season in my place, I really love it! idw88
My spouse and i got so joyous Edward could carry out his investigation through the entire ideas he came across while using the weblog. It is now and again perplexing to just always be giving for free techniques which usually others might have been selling. We really remember we’ve got you to appreciate for this. The main explanations you’ve made, the easy website navigation, the relationships your site aid to create – it’s got mostly wonderful, and it is aiding our son in addition to the family feel that this issue is exciting, which is certainly very fundamental. Thank you for all the pieces! kitchen stores vancouver bc
Fantastic Blog! Keep posting informative insights
Embark on an extraordinary adventure by signing up for our online game, where exclusive bonuses and thrilling quests await! Register now and be part of a dynamic gaming community. fb777live
It is very interesting topic you’ve written here . The truth I’m not related to this, but I think is a good opportunity to learn more about, And as well talk about a different topic to which I used to talk with others คาเฟ่อุบลราชธานี
howdy, I’ve been havin a tough time attempting to rank well for the words “victorias secret coupon codes”… Pls approve my comment!! sdtoto
Dear admin, thanks for providing this blog post. I found it great. Take care, sdtoto
SITUS SLOT ONLINE TERPERCAYA, LANCAR, DAN PASTI MAXWIN. SEGERA CLAIM BERBAGAI MACAM PROMO TERBAIK!!! BUMI365
Thanks for sharing the article, and more importantly, your personal experience! Mindfully using our emotions as data about our inner state and knowing when it’s better to de-escalate by taking a time out are great tools. Appreciate you reading and sharing your story, since I can certainly relate and I think others can too.
Free Download Vector Design For International Clients(United States of America)
The Stigma of Casual Sex: Challenging Society’s Views on Young Adults’ Sexual Behavior slot gacor daftar x500
Great post! Thank you for sharing informative post with us.
ลิงค์รับทรัพย์ 123bet
Thanks for every other excellent post. The place else may just anyone get that kind of info in such an ideal manner of writing? I’ve a presentation subsequent week, and I am at the look for such information. alexistogel
Thanks for every other excellent post. The place else may just anyone get that kind of info in such an ideal manner of writing? I’ve a presentation subsequent week, and I am at the look for such information. a course in miracles
SITUS SLOT ONLINE TERPERCAYA, LANCAR, DAN PASTI MAXWIN. SEGERA CLAIM BERBAGAI MACAM PROMO TERBAIK!!! CLICK ->> BUMI365
If conceivable, as you clear knowledge, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is damned helpful in return me. acim app
I’m not certain the place you are getting your information, however great topic. I must spend a while learning more or working out more. Thank you for magnificent info I was searching for this info for my mission. sdtoto
Hmm is anyone else encountering problems with the images on this blog loading? I’m trying to determine if its a problem on my end or if it’s the blog.
Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
SWMSS Org
Henkiez.com
SINI BREE…… SITUS SLOT ONLINE TERGACOR DAN PASTI MAXWIN BREEEE!!!. JANGAN LUPA BREEE….CLAIM BERBAGAI MACAM PROMO TERBAIKNYA!!! BUMI365
I do not know if it’s just me or if everyone else encountering problems with your blog.
It looks like some of the written text in your posts are running off the screen. Can someone else please provide feedback and let me know if this is happening to them as well? This may be a problem with my browser because I’ve had this happen previously. Kudos
Compassionineconomics
Marinapalmyachtclubmiami Com
Thanks for sharing excellent informations. 토토사이트 순위
I was reading some of your articles on this website and I conceive this web site is very instructive!
카지노사이트 모음
I thought it was heading to become some dull previous publish, however it truly compensated for my time. I’ll publish a hyperlink to this web page on my blog. I am positive my visitors will uncover that extremely helpful. alexistogel
SLOT GACOR NOMOR 1 DI INDONESIA PALING TERPERCAYA!!! Tiki4D
Hey, you used to write wonderful, but the last few posts have been kinda boring… I miss your tremendous writings. Past few posts are just a little out of track! come on! alexistogel
Thanks for making the honest attempt to speak about this. I believe very robust approximately it and want to read more. If it’s OK, as you gain more in depth wisdom, would you thoughts adding extra articles similar to this one with additional information? It might be extremely useful and useful for me and my friends. alexistogel
I’ve recently started a web site, the information you offer on this site has helped me greatly. Thanks for all of your time & work. acim podcast
grat article but maybe please update this post with more detail, i really think this would help a lot of people. acim podcast
certainly like your web site but you have to check the spelling on quite a few of your posts. Many of them are rife with spelling problems and I find it very troublesome to tell the truth nevertheless I’ll certainly come back again. movie watchers guide to enlightenment
I don’t normally comment but I gotta tell appreciate it for the post on this great one : D. movie watchers guide to enlightenment