Black & White: from Moonlight to Martin

Reviews are the oddest things. It boggles the mind that “Black Power,” a Hilton Als review of the film Moonlight, and “Agnes Martin, a Matter-of-Fact Mystic by New Yorker art critic Peter Schjeldahl are approximately the same length, in the same magazine. Moonlight is a sprawling two-hour movie, spanning a child’s journey through adolescence to adulthood, full of color, motion, and noise. The Agnes Martin retrospective exhibition at the Guggenheim Museum, on the other hand, is a subdued and esoteric group of paintings. Besides being examples of very different media, these two subjects serve as a stark juxtaposition of “popular” and “high” culture, as much of a contrast, funnily enough, as black  and white.

 

With the wildly disparate levels of stimulus inherent in these subjects, it’s impressive that these authors fit them both in the same 1500-word review format in the New Yorker. I think their keys to achieving this are adjusting the given context and in doing so developing very different relationships with the audience.

Als leads off with the deeply personal, confiding in us about his “anxious, closeted childhood” and  explaining the power this film holds for him as a queer black man. He grew up “in the era of Ronald Reagan, Margaret Thatcher, and AIDS,” never believing his story could be told on the silver screen until now. His repeated use of the first person enables intimacy and insight into his experience, which lends his discussion of the film extra weight. When he does include the viewer in his insights later on, he still includes himself using first-person plural: “Moonlight undoes our expectations as viewers…” He can focus more on his own reactions because he trusts his audience to be able to watch a film and get their own reading out of it. His job is to put his reading in conversation with yours. He achieves this by qualifying his readings: “Juan follows, entering through a blasted-out window, a symbol, perhaps, of the ruin left by the riots.” Something as simple as a “perhaps” invites the reader to really think about what he’s saying and agree or disagree.

For better or worse, Schjeldahl does not seem to trust his audience quite as much with the high-brow set of paintings by Martin at the Guggenheim. His use of second-person comes off as more prescriptive. After an admirable close-reading of a set of paintings that just look…… white, he follows with, “When you notice this [detail], the fields of paint seem to jiggle loose, and to hover. If you look long enough — the minute or so that Martin deemed sufficient for her works — your sensation-starved optic nerve may produce fugitive impressions of other colors.” Me? I notice this? His expectations would be easier to handle if they weren’t trying to force a religious experience (“secular pilgrimage”) on me. He attempts to teach my “heart” to be “ambushed by rushes of emotion,” but that’s not something you can force.

This lesser confidence in the viewer further manifests in the Martin review as an excess of biography. Citing a new biography of Agnes Martin by Nancy Princenthal, he outlines the artist’s entire life and career, making connections between her mental illness and the controlled, soothing geometric paintings she made. It was interesting to read as an art historian, because the field still debates the legitimacy of using biography to analyze work. This emphasis on biography was in stark contrast to the review by Als, who used more of his own biography than that of the filmmaker Barry Jenkins. The only bit of information deemed relevant to Als is that Jenkins “was raised in Liberty City,” the film’s setting, and therefore he “understands from the inside out.” Because again, the film will be able to speak for itself to its audience.

The more accessible nature of the film also enables Als to be more poetic and suggestive, skating over the rich scenes rather than plodding through an interpretation. One virtuosic description would lend itself wonderfully to spoken-word poetry.

“He’s a dope dealer, so there’s that, too. He may be a boss on the streets — his black do-rag is his crown — but he’s intelligent enough to know that he’s expendable, that real power doesn’t belong to men like him. Crack is spreading through the city like a fever.”

These kinds of poetic responses are enjoyable to read on their own, but again leave enough room for dialogue with the reader or film-viewer to think their own thoughts. Schjeldahl, in contrast, lets the reader be swept up in the narrative of Martin’s life, which is fascinating, but ultimately it doesn’t leave room for a Kantian “free play of imagination” above the facts.

Maybe I have been a little too hard on Peter Schjeldahl. In these pieces, I think of Als as a conversationalist and Schjeldahl as a coach, and I would definitely say there is room for both roles. I actually really appreciated the use of biography in the Martin review, because it does give the reader much more to grab hold of, beyond the white paintings described. Agnes Martin must have been a singular challenge to review. There is so little about her work alone for the popular New Yorker taste to invest in, so it makes sense to coach the reader through the experience of viewing in a way that feels rewarding, even spiritual, although for me it was a little heavy-handed. At the same time, there is something rewarding about being left to your own devices in Als’s piece after being given a prompt (or two including the film). While the authors have very different styles, the overlap occurs in their effective use of context: some media and artistic styles are just going to require more critical interpretation for a popular audience, despite the wise words of Susan Sontag.

The key as a reader is to be able to tell the difference between a genuine experience of pseudo-religious awe and one prescribed by the New Yorker.

Featured Image

5,755 Comments

  • UPSers commented on June 8, 2024 Reply

    Hey there! Someone in my Facebook group shared this website with us so I came to check it out. I’m definitely enjoying the information. I’m book-marking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Superb blog and wonderful design. kanjengtoto

  • Ahmed Raza commented on June 8, 2024 Reply

    Good website! I truly love how it is easy on my eyes it is. I am wondering how I might be notified whenever a new post has been made. I have subscribed to your RSS which may do the trick? Have a great day! CANDY CRUSH QUE PAGA

  • ff commented on June 8, 2024 Reply

    I really liked your content now if you want to know about your net worth you can visit my site. yalla shoot22

  • Liwovosa commented on June 8, 2024 Reply

    Great content material and great layout. Your website deserves all of the positive feedback it’s been getting. pafi

  • Escobar commented on June 9, 2024 Reply

    A very excellent blog post. I am thankful for your blog post. I have found a lot of approaches after visiting your post. gbt website

  • Frank commented on June 9, 2024 Reply

    When visiting blogs, i usually discover a very good content like yours a course in miracles

  • Paris88 commented on June 9, 2024 Reply

    sangat menarik dan mengesankan, amazing post Paris88

  • Frank commented on June 9, 2024 Reply

    Just wanna remark on few general things, The website style is ideal, the topic matter is rattling good pafikotapadangaro.org

  • Frank commented on June 9, 2024 Reply

    I really like your article. It’s evident that you have a lot knowledge on this topic. Your points are well made and relatable. Thanks for writing engaging and interesting material. สล็อตเว็บตรง

  • Frank commented on June 9, 2024 Reply

    I really like your article. It’s evident that you have a lot knowledge on this topic. Your points are well made and relatable. Thanks for writing engaging and interesting material. The affiliate business system

  • https://www.pgslot.best commented on June 9, 2024 Reply

    เล่น pgslot ใหม่ล่าสุด เว็บตรง ค่าย PG เกมสล็อต แตกหนัก เกี่ยวกับเรา ทดลอง เล่น สล็อต PG ไม่ เด้ง เว็บสล็อตแท้ บริการเครดิตที่น่าเชื่อถือที่สุดมีใบรับรองการันตีจากต่างประเทศ

  • robert cat commented on June 9, 2024 Reply

    A very excellent blog post. I am thankful for your blog post. I have found a lot of approaches after visiting your post. cromado de plasticos

  • Fareed Khatri commented on June 10, 2024 Reply

    I really loved reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to undertand. Unlike additional blogs I have read which are really not tht good. I also found your posts very interesting. In fact after reading, I had to go show it to my friend and he ejoyed it as well! THE EMERGENCY VISA TO VISIT INDIA

  • 토토사이트 commented on June 10, 2024 Reply

    여기 처음 왔어요. 나는이 게시판을 발견했고 그것이 정말 도움이되었고 많은 도움이되었다는 것을 발견했습니다. 나는 무언가를 돌려주고 당신이 나를 도왔던 다른 사람들을 돕고 싶습니다. 토토사이트

  • Frank commented on June 10, 2024 Reply

    I really like your article. It’s evident that you have a lot knowledge on this topic. Your points are well made and relatable. Thanks for writing engaging and interesting material. a course in miracles

  • 토토사이트추천 commented on June 10, 2024 Reply

    It is perfect time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I’ve read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you few interesting things or tips. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article. I want to read more things about it! 토토사이트추천

  • Mega888 Register commented on June 10, 2024 Reply

    Mega888 Register utilizing advanced encryption technology to safeguard personal and financial information

  • 토토사이트 commented on June 10, 2024 Reply

    Great survey, I’m sure you’re getting a great response 토토사이트

  • https://usun5g.com commented on June 10, 2024 Reply

    บาคาร่าเว็บตรงแท้ไม่ผ่านเอเย่นต์ เว็บตรงบาคาร่าและเกมสล็อต บาคาร่าเว็บตรงแท้ไม่ผ่านเอเย่นต์ เว็บที่ได้รับความนิยมมากที่สุดในโลก เว็บตรงที่ดีที่สุด เล่นเกมสล็อตเว็บตรง เว็บบาคาร่าใหม่ล่าสุด promotion ผู้เล่นจะต้องเลือกเกมสล็อต pg เว็บตรง แตกหนักยอดนิยมที่แพร่หลายอย่างมากในปัจุบัน

  • Frank commented on June 10, 2024 Reply

    I really like your article. It’s evident that you have a lot knowledge on this topic. Your points are well made and relatable. Thanks for writing engaging and interesting material. a course in miracles

  • Baby James commented on June 10, 2024 Reply

    This is a truly good site post. Not too many people would actually, the way you just did. I am really impressed that there is so much information about this subject that have been uncovered and you’ve done your best, with so much class. If wanted to know more about green smoke reviews, than by all means come in and check our stuff. situs slot

  • UPSers commented on June 10, 2024 Reply

    Hey there! Someone in my Facebook group shared this website with us so I came to check it out. I’m definitely enjoying the information. I’m book-marking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Superb blog and wonderful design. Press Release

  • qwdd commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    I really liked your content now if you want to know about your net worth you can visit my site. yalla shoot

  • efe commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    I really liked your content now if you want to know about your net worth you can visit my site. yalla shoot

  • 안전토토사이트 commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    Your topic is very great and useful for us… thank you 안전토토사이트

  • 슬롯사이트 commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    I enjoyed your blog. There is a lot of useful information on my blog too. Please come and have a look. I’ll leave my address.
    슬롯사이트

  • 슬롯커뮤니티 commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    I hope you have a good day today! I enjoyed your blog. I hope you come visit my blog too. leave your address.
    슬롯커뮤니티

  • KASHIF KHAN commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    You will find dissertation online sites via internet settle purchase not surprisingly well-known while in the web pages. memek

  • Frank commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    Just wanna remark on few general things, The website style is ideal, the topic matter is rattling good idw88

  • mrjames commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    I’m impressed by the thoroughness of this blog post. It’s evident that a lot of time and effort went into its creation. If you’re hungry for more fascinating content, Showbarkeeper Workingflair offers a plethora of resources waiting to be explored.

  • 스포츠분석 commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    Your topic is very great and useful for us… thank you 스포츠분석

  • Mega888 Game commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    Mega888 Game Whether you prefer classic fruit machines or themed video slots

  • 꽁머니사이트 commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    I want you to thank for your time of this wonderful read !!! I definately enjoy every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff of your blog a must read blog 꽁머니사이트

  • 슬롯사이트 commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    Really a great addition. I have read this marvelous post. Thanks for sharing information about it. I really like that 슬롯사이트

  • Frank commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    I really like your article. It’s evident that you have a lot knowledge on this topic. Your points are well made and relatable. Thanks for writing engaging and interesting material. a course in miracles

  • KASHIF KHAN commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    Hello, this is my first message made on this webpage and I wanted to say that I’m really impressed with this blog after reading this article about – Gulvafslibning | Kurt Gulvmand in which I share your same opinion. I’ll definitely mark to favorites this page! hargatoto

  • gledek88 login commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    I have read your article, it is very informative and helpful for me. I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles. Thanks for posting it gledek88 login

  • Poker88 Asia commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    http://194.233.78.100
    Poker88 Asia Situs Gacor mudah maxwin daftar dan rasakan sensational

  • ph777 commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    Fantastic Blog! Keep posting informative insights
    Embark on an extraordinary adventure by signing up for our online game, where exclusive bonuses and thrilling quests await! Register now and be part of a dynamic gaming community. fb777live

  • Keyan Baloch commented on June 11, 2024 Reply

    Thanks for sharing this knowledge here keep it up. download Yacine TV

  • Frank commented on June 12, 2024 Reply

    This information is magnificent. I understand and respect your clear-cut points. I am impressed with your writing style and how well you express your thoughts. qqraya

  • Baby James commented on June 12, 2024 Reply

    Nice to be visiting your blog once more, it has been months for me. Well this article that ive been waited for therefore long. i want this article to finish my assignment within the faculty, and it has same topic together with your article. Thanks, nice share. situs slot gacor

  • slot88 commented on June 12, 2024 Reply

    Luar biasa, postingan yang luar biasa. Saya menganggap ini sebagai informatika yang berlebihan. Saya sedang mencarinya. Saya mungkin ingin menyarankan Anda untuk terus berbagi informasi semacam itu. Jika memungkinkan, Sangat diwajibkan. slot88

  • Frank commented on June 12, 2024 Reply

    hey there, your site is cheap. We do thank you for work a course in miracles

  • UPSers commented on June 12, 2024 Reply

    This is the correct weblog for everyone who is would like to learn about this topic. You are aware of much its almost challenging to argue along with you (not that I personally would want…HaHa). You certainly put a different spin on a topic thats been revealed for several years. Fantastic stuff, just great! sdtoto

  • UPSers commented on June 12, 2024 Reply

    Regards for all your efforts that you have put in this. Very interesting information. sdtoto

  • Andy commented on June 12, 2024 Reply

    The article is a masterful piece of writing that showcases the author’s deep expertise on the subject. The clarity and insight provided are both enlightening and engaging. It’s evident that the author has a profound understanding of the topic, making it a highly recommended read. Their ability to present complex information in an accessible manner is truly commendable. See more Procedury FGaz

  • Partial Hospitalization Program Atlanta commented on June 13, 2024 Reply

    This is the correct weblog for everyone who is would like to learn about this topic. You are aware of much its almost challenging to argue along with you (not that I personally would want…HaHa). You certainly put a different spin on a topic thats been revealed for several years. Fantastic stuff, just great! government of pakistan

  • jepangbet commented on June 13, 2024 Reply

    Exploring the Boundaries of Sex: A Young Couple’s Passionate Journey game slot online

  • King33 commented on June 13, 2024 Reply

    King33 là một trong những nhà cái uy tín và được người chơi đánh giá cao trên thị trường cá cược hiện nay. Với đa dạng các tựa game và chương trình khuyến mãi hấp dẫn, King33 đã thu hút được sự quan tâm của đông đảo game thủ. Bài viết này sẽ giới thiệu chi tiết về nhà cái King33, cùng với đó là hướng dẫn đăng ký, nạp rút tiền và tải app ứng dụng của nhà cái.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *