Reviews are the oddest things. It boggles the mind that “Black Power,” a Hilton Als review of the film Moonlight, and “Agnes Martin, a Matter-of-Fact Mystic” by New Yorker art critic Peter Schjeldahl are approximately the same length, in the same magazine. Moonlight is a sprawling two-hour movie, spanning a child’s journey through adolescence to adulthood, full of color, motion, and noise. The Agnes Martin retrospective exhibition at the Guggenheim Museum, on the other hand, is a subdued and esoteric group of paintings. Besides being examples of very different media, these two subjects serve as a stark juxtaposition of “popular” and “high” culture, as much of a contrast, funnily enough, as black and white.
With the wildly disparate levels of stimulus inherent in these subjects, it’s impressive that these authors fit them both in the same 1500-word review format in the New Yorker. I think their keys to achieving this are adjusting the given context and in doing so developing very different relationships with the audience.
Als leads off with the deeply personal, confiding in us about his “anxious, closeted childhood” and explaining the power this film holds for him as a queer black man. He grew up “in the era of Ronald Reagan, Margaret Thatcher, and AIDS,” never believing his story could be told on the silver screen until now. His repeated use of the first person enables intimacy and insight into his experience, which lends his discussion of the film extra weight. When he does include the viewer in his insights later on, he still includes himself using first-person plural: “Moonlight undoes our expectations as viewers…” He can focus more on his own reactions because he trusts his audience to be able to watch a film and get their own reading out of it. His job is to put his reading in conversation with yours. He achieves this by qualifying his readings: “Juan follows, entering through a blasted-out window, a symbol, perhaps, of the ruin left by the riots.” Something as simple as a “perhaps” invites the reader to really think about what he’s saying and agree or disagree.
For better or worse, Schjeldahl does not seem to trust his audience quite as much with the high-brow set of paintings by Martin at the Guggenheim. His use of second-person comes off as more prescriptive. After an admirable close-reading of a set of paintings that just look…… white, he follows with, “When you notice this [detail], the fields of paint seem to jiggle loose, and to hover. If you look long enough — the minute or so that Martin deemed sufficient for her works — your sensation-starved optic nerve may produce fugitive impressions of other colors.” Me? I notice this? His expectations would be easier to handle if they weren’t trying to force a religious experience (“secular pilgrimage”) on me. He attempts to teach my “heart” to be “ambushed by rushes of emotion,” but that’s not something you can force.
This lesser confidence in the viewer further manifests in the Martin review as an excess of biography. Citing a new biography of Agnes Martin by Nancy Princenthal, he outlines the artist’s entire life and career, making connections between her mental illness and the controlled, soothing geometric paintings she made. It was interesting to read as an art historian, because the field still debates the legitimacy of using biography to analyze work. This emphasis on biography was in stark contrast to the review by Als, who used more of his own biography than that of the filmmaker Barry Jenkins. The only bit of information deemed relevant to Als is that Jenkins “was raised in Liberty City,” the film’s setting, and therefore he “understands from the inside out.” Because again, the film will be able to speak for itself to its audience.
The more accessible nature of the film also enables Als to be more poetic and suggestive, skating over the rich scenes rather than plodding through an interpretation. One virtuosic description would lend itself wonderfully to spoken-word poetry.
“He’s a dope dealer, so there’s that, too. He may be a boss on the streets — his black do-rag is his crown — but he’s intelligent enough to know that he’s expendable, that real power doesn’t belong to men like him. Crack is spreading through the city like a fever.”
These kinds of poetic responses are enjoyable to read on their own, but again leave enough room for dialogue with the reader or film-viewer to think their own thoughts. Schjeldahl, in contrast, lets the reader be swept up in the narrative of Martin’s life, which is fascinating, but ultimately it doesn’t leave room for a Kantian “free play of imagination” above the facts.
Maybe I have been a little too hard on Peter Schjeldahl. In these pieces, I think of Als as a conversationalist and Schjeldahl as a coach, and I would definitely say there is room for both roles. I actually really appreciated the use of biography in the Martin review, because it does give the reader much more to grab hold of, beyond the white paintings described. Agnes Martin must have been a singular challenge to review. There is so little about her work alone for the popular New Yorker taste to invest in, so it makes sense to coach the reader through the experience of viewing in a way that feels rewarding, even spiritual, although for me it was a little heavy-handed. At the same time, there is something rewarding about being left to your own devices in Als’s piece after being given a prompt (or two including the film). While the authors have very different styles, the overlap occurs in their effective use of context: some media and artistic styles are just going to require more critical interpretation for a popular audience, despite the wise words of Susan Sontag.
The key as a reader is to be able to tell the difference between a genuine experience of pseudo-religious awe and one prescribed by the New Yorker.
6,954 Comments
This is a fantastic website , thanks for sharing.
ติดต่อหวย huay bee,
Great job, I was doing a google search and your site came up for homes for sale in Altamonte Springs, FL but anyway, I have enjoyed reading it, keep it up! en iyi bahis siteleri
Excellent .. Amazing .. I’ll bookmark your blog and take the feeds also…I’m happy to find so many useful info here in the post, we need work out more techniques in this regard, thanks for sharing. 性功能障礙
This is really fascinating, You are a very professional blogger. I’ve joined your rss feed and sit up for searching for more of your great post. Also, I have shared your site in my social networks! best spiritual movie
TOGEL88 | DAFTAR TOGEL88 | LOGIN TOGEL88 | TOGEL88 ASIA Daftar segera di situs Togel88 untuk mulai bermain permainan online terlengkap. Situs gacor gampang maxwin. Berapapun kemenangan Anda pasti akan terbayar lunas. Jaminan 100% Privasi dan keamanan Anda terjaga dengan baik bersama situs terbaik dan terpercaya Togel88.
KOINTOTO | DAFTAR KOINTOTO| LOGIN KOINTOTO| KOINTOTO Daftar segera di situs Kointoto untuk mulai bermain permainan online terlengkap. Situs gacor gampang maxwin. Berapapun kemenangan Anda pasti akan terbayar lunas. Jaminan 100% Privasi dan keamanan Anda terjaga dengan baik bersama situs terbaik dan terpercaya Kointoto.
You really make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this topic to be really something which I think I would never understand. It seems too complicated and very broad for me. I am looking forward for your next post, I will try to get the hang of it! Coloured contact lenses
The internet has been considered as one of the best ways to find a reputed and known SEO company. Apart from high quality services, its response towards customers is prompt and satisfactory. Search a company and get associated with it for your SEO services. professional led light therapy machine
Hey there! Someone in my Facebook group shared this website with us so I came to check it out. I’m definitely enjoying the information. I’m book-marking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Superb blog and wonderful design. micromodule optical fiber cable
Great survey, I’m sure you’re getting a great response. sv388.llc
Please continue this great work and I look forward to more of your awesome blog posts. ae888.help
Wonderful article. Fascinating to read. I love to read such an excellent article. Thanks! It has made my task more and extra easy. Keep rocking. 1 kanal house for sale in Citi Housing Sialkot
This information is magnificent. I understand and respect your clear-cut points. I am impressed with your writing style and how well you express your thoughts. bougies parfumées
السفر يعلمنا دروساً قيمة في التكيف والمرونة. عندما نواجه ثقافات وبيئات جديدة، نضطر إلى التأقلم مع الظروف الجديدة والخروج من منطقة الراحة الخاصة بنا. هذا التحدي يطور لدينا القدرة على التفكير بطرق جديدة وإيجاد حلول إبداعية للمشكلات. نتعلم كيف نكون أكثر انفتاحاً للتغيير ونرحب بالمفاجآت بدلاً من مقاومتها.رحلة الى سبانجا
One of the greatest gifts of travel is the opportunity for self-discovery. By removing ourselves from our daily routines and familiar surroundings, we are able to reflect on our lives from a new vantage point. The challenges of navigating foreign places instill a sense of independence, resourcefulness, and confidence within us.تكلفة رحلة سبانجا
في نهاية المطاف، السفر يذكرنا بأن العالم أكبر وأجمل مما نتصور. فهو يفتح آفاقاً جديدة لا حصر لها للتعلم والنمو الشخصي. كل رحلة تمنحنا شغفاً جديداً للمغامرة والاكتشاف، مهما كانت وجهتنا القادمة. السفر هو استثمار ثمين لن يتركنا أبداً دون مكاسب ثمينة ومفيدة.رحله سبانجا
من الجوانب الرائعة للسفر هي فرصة بناء روابط إنسانية جديدة. عندما نزور أماكن غريبة، غالباً ما نلتقي بأشخاص لامعين يشاركوننا حكاياتهم ويفتحون أعيننا على وجهات نظر مختلفة. هذه اللقاءات العابرة تُظهر لنا جمال التنوع البشري وتعزز فهمنا للعالم من حولنا. في بعض الأحيان، تتحول هذه الصداقات إلى علاقات دائمة تغني حياتنا.رحلة سبانجا ومعشوقية
Wow i can say that this is another great article as expected of this blog.Bookmarked this site.. Debt help
Mega888 Game The Ultimate Destination for Online Slot Games
Please let me know if you’re looking for a author for your site. You have some really good posts and I believe I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d really like to write some content for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please blast me an e-mail if interested. Regards! custom socks wholesale
Splendid post. We learn brand new stuff upon various blogs daily. Couple of revitalizing to determine content material using their company writers as well as grow to be familiar having a little some thing their own certain. I’d believe to make use of a few inside the information on my blog need to don’t mind. Normally I’ll provides a link back up in internet internet site. Thanks sharing. t shirt printing machine
Informative insights. Thank you for posting this blog. philboss
Rattling wonderful info can be found on weblog . Cheap Garden Sheds Under £100
I really liked your content now if you want to know about your net worth you can visit my site. yalla shoot
Available 24 hours a day, can be played on your mobile phone anywhere, anytime.wm787
That is the excellent mindset, nonetheless is just not help to make every sence whatsoever preaching about that mather. Virtually any method many thanks in addition to i had endeavor to promote your own article in to delicius nevertheless it is apparently a dilemma using your information sites can you please recheck the idea. thanks once more. albino rocker with a 1973 number one hit
Your blog is one of a kind, i love the way you organize the topics.:’-”‘ the christ
https://kwork.com/offpageseo/32985132/50-homepage-da-50-plus-dofollow-pbn-backlinks?ref=17233225
https://kwork.com/offpageseo/32917064/i-will-do-200-blog-comment-backlinks-on-high-da-pa-and-dr-websites?ref=17233225
Slot Bet 100
Slot Bet 100 Perak
New web site is looking good. Thanks for the great effort. daftar dadu online
You really make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this topic to be really something which I think I would never understand. It seems too complicated and very broad for me. I am looking forward for your next post, I will try to get the hang of it! Rai88
OUTSYSTEMS DEVELOPMENT COMPANY IN INDIA
Prometheas Technologies boasts a team of seasoned OutSystems developers who harness the platform’s full potential to deliver enterprise applications tailored to both present and future market demands. We champion personalized enterprise solutions, offering clients an array of customization and scalability options to ensure solutions align perfectly with their unique needs. Our mastery of OutSystems extends to every phase, from consultancy to final app development, and ongoing support and maintenance services. Count on our unwavering expertise for your success. Visit- https://prometheastech.com , mail- hello@prometheastech.com
Great post! philboss
Is this a new post? i ask because i think i read the same article a month ago on hubpages. taka77 log in
You have done a great job on this article. It’s very readable and highly intelligent. You have even managed to make it understandable and easy to read. You have some real writing talent. Thank you. FORTUNE TIGER
국내에서 가장 믿을 수 있는 출장마사지와 출장마사지 출장서비스를 원하시면 새로운 마사지 서비스를 선택해주세요. 안마사 전문교육과정 수료 20대 전문관리사
수도권(서울,인천,경기) 어디든 30분내 방문해드립니다. 선입금 없는 새로운 출장 마사지, 안전한 후불 시스템으로 안심하고 출장 서비스를 이용해 보세요.
출장안마
Thanks for every other excellent post. The place else may just anyone get that kind of info in such an ideal manner of writing? I’ve a presentation subsequent week, and I am at the look for such information. zeus gacor
Thanks for the informative post. taya365
I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative.. Superman68
The internet has been considered as one of the best ways to find a reputed and known SEO company. Apart from high quality services, its response towards customers is prompt and satisfactory. Search a company and get associated with it for your SEO services. non dual teachers
What’s Happening i am new to this, I stumbled upon this I’ve found It positively useful and it has helped me out loads. I hope to contribute & help other users like its helped me. Great job. nondual teacher
Thanks for a very interesting blog. What else may I get that kind of info written in such a perfect approach? I’ve a undertaking that I am simply now operating and I have been at the look out for such info. Dollar rate today in Pakistan
TOGEL88 | DAFTAR TOGEL88 | LOGIN TOGEL88 | TOGEL88 ASIA Daftar segera di situs Togel88 untuk mulai bermain permainan online terlengkap. Situs gacor gampang maxwin. Berapapun kemenangan Anda pasti akan terbayar lunas. Jaminan 100% Privasi dan keamanan Anda terjaga dengan baik bersama situs terbaik dan terpercaya Togel88.
I am glad that I discovered this blog, just the right information that I was looking for! non dual teachers
I high appreciate this post. It’s hard to find the good from the bad sometimes, but I think you’ve nailed it! would you mind updating your blog with more information? slot maxwin
No doubt this is an excellent post I got a lot of knowledge after reading good luck. Theme of blog is excellent there is almost everything to read, Brilliant post. ovo88bet
Keep up the fantastic work! philboss
Wonderful article. Fascinating to read. I love to read such an excellent article. Thanks! It has made my task more and extra easy. Keep rocking. sex