Drawing from a rich collection at Chicago’s Museum of Contemporary Art, former Curatorial Assistant, Karsten Lund, crafts a dynamic exhibit featuring photographical portraits from the 1940s to 2006. According to Lund, Witness, explores the role of the photographer in perceiving people “unconventionally.” In displaying a wide-range of photographical styles—from Walker Evans’ subway vignettes, to Alfredo Jaar’s large-scale installation—the selection investigates the interactions between object and perspective. The exhibit’s temporal and stylistic diversity offers a historically recurring and significant question: how does a photograph reveal the relationship between subject and “witness.” Through comparing the work of Walker Evans and Thomas Ruff, I propose that the photographer’s perspective is fundamental to the photograph’s—and thus the human subject’s—representation of reality.
Walker Evans’ eight gelatin prints from the 1940s depict various strangers riding the subway in New York. Using a hidden camera, Evans glimpses subjects in moments of transition—lost in thought, waiting, observing others, all while he intently does the same. Placed in a technologically distant era from now, routine, intermediary phases offered a static stretch of time for passengers to either exist within one’s thoughts, or in the observation of one’s physical surroundings. With no pocket-sized window to the virtual and digital, people’s expressions during temporal in-betweens were much more diverse than today’s wash of screen staring. In discussing his untitled series, Evans writes, “The guard is down and the mask is off, even more than when in lone bedrooms (where there are mirrors). People’s faces are in naked repose down in the subway.” Through catching the “naked repose,” Evans’ photographs propose momentary viewings into complex lives. In 1988, German artist, Thomas Ruff, created a series of large-scale, chromogenic portraits. Unlike Evans’ small, unobtrusive windows, Ruff’s work is bold and domineering. The displayed portrait, Portrait (C. Kewer), is crafted to be as systematic and neutral as possible. It stands against the romantic and conventional trope that fine photography exposes a subject’s psychology, and instead presents a passport-like, standardized formula. In viewing the subject through enlarged, hyper-realistic definition, Ruff augments the faces’ porous details to a most grotesque level, exploring how photography can expose the underlying sameness of all human subjects.
The contextual vision of time is critical to the two projects’ conflicting approaches. Evans’ prints feature people static in motion. Though they are stuck still, both in the photograph and train, their environment is moving, bended to the speed of the subway’s transition. Therefore, the photographs investigate a seemingly paradoxical relationship between the stagnancy of photography and waiting, and the motion of history and transition. Motion, a product of time, glues the subjects to the ephemeral, to the mortal. With an inherent beginning, middle and end, motion implies context, narrative. Through freezing stolen moments of transition, Evans’ photographs represent subjects through the experiential. Though I do not know the subjects, nor the intricacies of their lives, I can relate to their contextualized experiences, their hidden, yet foundational narratives. The photographs strike me as deeply empathetic. The subtleties of my own experiences fill the misty gaps, while simultaneously probing the wonder of narratives not my own. Ruff’s portrait, on the other hand, is completely devoid of motion, and therefore, time. Like pressing my eyes up to a brick wall, the portrait is lifeless in its divorce from implied narrative. Its static, blunt presence offers a dull and simple view into a human’s existence. In it’s large-scale, hyper-realism, the undercurrents of a subject’s psychology are washed into a non-expression of neutral flesh.
Stepping outside the frame, Evans and Ruff paradoxically address their roles as “the witness.” While Evans approaches his series through spontaneously stylized snapshots, Ruff carefully positions his camera to veil the photographer’s integral and interjected perspective. Evans plays with moving shadows and ranging angles, defining his perspective as a fellow stranger from across the aisle. For example, his photograph of an elderly women (bottom row, far left) angles slightly up, emphasizing the hidden view from his camera. Thus, the angle portrays not only the photographer’s presence, but his method of secret snapping. Next, the elderly woman’s hands, and a man in the background are slightly blurred. Using a range of definition between the blurry forms and the precision of the woman’s face, Evans softens and veils the subject and environment’s ordinary realism. In black and white, Evans photographs represent a gesture of reality observed through a narratively-driven, cloaked lens. Ruff’s photographical perspective is based in the illusion of transparency. The camera faces its subject, perfectly still and perfectly straight—the effect: neutrality. The photographer’s looming gaze seems to be inexistent; the perspective, therefore, lies in that of an unfeeling, objective machine. In stealthily removing the giveaways of his artistic tinkering, the veil between the subject and viewer is seemingly eradicated. Because the photographer seems to be inexistent, the viewer gazes upon the subject not through the perspective of another feeling human being, but through a total objectivity.
Peering into Walker Evans’ series, I see glancing vignettes of real lives I feel I can relate to, but do not know. And shrinking under Ruff’s engrossing portrait, I see a face, composed of flesh and hair and nothing more. With two conflicting, artistic statements, I see room for synthesis. Perhaps humans are both. Perhaps we are a dynamic collection of thoughts and experiences, with a unifying base of flesh and existence. As I sit on the bus home, I witness the faces around me, and simply do not know.
1,721 Comments
Thanks so much for sharing this great info! I am looking forward to see more posts! 먹튀사이트
gunung388 has read all through this blog. Definitely will come back for more.
https://healthblog.id Panduan Menuju Kesejahteraan Optimal wajib dibaca oleh siapa saja yang ingin menjalani gaya hidup lebih sehat. Terima kasih telah memberikan wawasan dan tips yang sangat berharga!
Do you want to win some money? This game is really easy to play. Come and join us in the game. https://mukgumsa.com/ 카지노커뮤니티
Your article is a valuable contribution to the ongoing dialogue in [field or industry]. sagaming
Tidak ada yang bisa mengalahkan kegembiraan saat menang besar di sungaitoto.
Saya suka bagaimana https://foodblog.id menghadirkan resep yang praktis namun tetap lezat. Cocok untuk saya yang sibuk
Opini tentang https://newsblog.id ini benar-benar membuat saya berpikir. Senang ketika seorang penulis menantang perspektif saya!
https://jokes.id, Anda adalah pahlawan yang selalu menyelamatkan hari saya dengan leluconnya yang luar biasajokes.id
I as well as my buddies were digesting the nice items located on your site and so all of the sudden got a terrible suspicion I never expressed respect to the blog owner for those techniques. All of the ladies had been certainly passionate to study all of them and have pretty much been taking pleasure in these things. Thank you for genuinely really accommodating as well as for finding certain exceptional resources millions of individuals are really needing to know about. My very own honest apologies for not saying thanks to earlier. punjabi news paper canada
It laborious to seek out knowledgeable folks on this matter, but you sound like you already know what you are talking about! Thanks 먹튀검증사이트
카지노사이트의 장점은 무엇인지 살펴보겠습니다.
카지노사이트
Saya baru saja mendaftar di m88 dan saya sangat menikmati pengalaman taruhan online pertama saya di sini.
edit Game Unlocking Mathematical Genius with 99math Introduction to 99math In the current digital era, learning environments are always changing to accommodate the requirements of younger students. Among these creative fixes, 99math sticks out as a trailblazing platform that transforms the way mathematics is learned and taught. 99math
Saya selalu mencari slot dengan persentase RTP tinggi. Siapa yang tidak menginginkan peluang menang yang lebih baik, bukan?
togelhok mungkin satu – satunya tempat kamu bisa serius bermain dan akhirnya mencapai kesepakatan untuk mendapatkan harta bersama dalam maxwin slot online thailand
QQGacor mengucapkan terima kasih atas berdirinya blog atau situs Anda.
Nice to be here to read this article, thanks a lot
โปรโมทชั่น 123
Excellently written article, doubts all bloggers offered the identical content since you, the internet has to be far better place. Please stay the best! Van Escort
When visiting blogs, i always look for a very nice content like yours . 먹튀검증업체
In the world of e-commerce leaders, few images are as straight away familiar while the iconic arrow of Amazon. From their modest beginnings as an on the web bookstore to their recent position as an international behemoth encompassing from cloud computing to entertainment streaming, Amazon is now associated with convenience, innovation, and disruption. But behind their meteoric increase lies a carefully crafted company identification, of that your Amazon logo is a main element. In this information, we search to the progress and impact of the Amazon logo, exploring their design, symbolism, and enduring significance in the electronic landscape. Amazon logo
nasi campur88 pada kenyataannya itu sangatlah enak sekali mau itu campuran yang mana saja. Rasa dan khas Indonesia ini memang jadi perpaduan yang paling cocok untuk bermain judi online sambil bermain.
Wholesale Cheap Handbags Will you be ok merely repost this on my site? I’ve to allow credit where it can be due. Have got a great day! 먹튀검증사이트
Saya telah bermain di sungaitoto selama berbulan-bulan, dan saya tidak pernah mengalami masalah apa pun dengan keamanan. Sungguh melegakan mengetahui bahwa informasi saya aman dan terjamin.
Ada apa dengan kalian semua? sudah saatnya kita sebagai pemain setia lvonline menunjukkan kemampuan kita bermain slot
selamat datang di lvonline selaku situs bandar judi online terlengkap di Indonesia.
I am only commenting to let you know of the remarkable experience our girl encountered reading the blog. She noticed many pieces, which included how it is like to possess an amazing giving nature to get certain people really easily learn certain multifaceted things. You undoubtedly exceeded visitors’ desires. I appreciate you for rendering the important, healthy, informative as well as easy tips about the topic to Kate. local seo
This is exactly what I was looking for.. really simple to install, totally free just had to register to download, thanks Verhuislift Amsterdam
Your posts are always well organized and easy to understand.
카지노사이트
Very interesting discussion glad that I came across such informative post.
바카라사이트
It was wondering if I could use this write-up on my other website, I will link it back to your website though.Great Thanks.
바카라사이트
Excellent website you have here, so much cool information!..
바카라사이트
berdsarkan informasi yang saya terima dari baca koran, berita dan juga dari youtube. Katanya situs slot gacor hari ini jatuh pada tangan lvonline
QQGacorSaya sangat berterima kasih atas blog atau situs anda yang telah memberikan edukasi/artikel yang baik.
Dengan adanya artikel atau situs ini pastinya akan sangat membantu semua orang yang telah bergabung bersama QQGacor.
สล็อต888
meslot
Great website! I am loving it!! Will be back later to read some more. I am bookmarking your feeds also um curso em milagres
premier333 adalah pilihan terbaik untuk penggemar game online berlisensi.
Experience the thrill of gaming on the go with the 7inr casinoapp, where you can enjoy a wide range of ultimate games right at your fingertips.
Some times its a pain in the ass to read what blog owners wrote but this site is really user pleasant! . slot gacor
Hiya, I’m really glad I’ve found this information. Today bloggers publish only about gossips and internet and this is really irritating. A good website with interesting content, that’s what I need. Thanks for keeping this web site, I’ll be visiting it. Do you do newsletters? Can’t find it. um curso em milagres
Battle, loot, and conquer in our action-packed online world! Lucky Cola
areaslot tempat bermain slot dan situs game online terbaik 20224
dapatkan informasi terbaru tentang slot gacor terbaru dengan hanya dari informasi terbaru.
Thanks for every other excellent post. The place else may just anyone get that kind of info in such an ideal manner of writing? I’ve a presentation subsequent week, and I am at the look for such information. tradisi bet
rajasatu is everywhere. It’s one of the best things in life that you will never see in your entire life.
CMS Sekolahku menyederhanakan tugas pengelolaan sekolah dengan fitur-fiturnya yang lengkap. Kunjungi situs web ini smkpj.sch.id untuk informasi lebih lanjut.
One kind of slot game that is extremely well-liked worldwide is the slot machine game. A highly thrilling game with enormous prizes; visit the website for full details on slot games. 먹튀 검찰
OutSystems Development Company in India
Once you hire Outsystem developers from our Outsystems Development team, our goal is to assist enterprises in achieving enhanced productivity and efficiency while simultaneously broadening their operational capabilities. Prometheas Technologies boasts a team of seasoned OutSystems developers who harness the platform’s full potential to deliver enterprise applications tailored to both present and future market demands. We champion personalized enterprise solutions, offering clients an array of customization and scalability options to ensure solutions align perfectly with their unique needs. Our mastery of OutSystems extends to every phase, from consultancy to final app development, and ongoing support and maintenance services. Count on our unwavering expertise for your success. Visit- https://prometheastech.com , mail- hello@prometheastech.com