Drawing from a rich collection at Chicago’s Museum of Contemporary Art, former Curatorial Assistant, Karsten Lund, crafts a dynamic exhibit featuring photographical portraits from the 1940s to 2006. According to Lund, Witness, explores the role of the photographer in perceiving people “unconventionally.” In displaying a wide-range of photographical styles—from Walker Evans’ subway vignettes, to Alfredo Jaar’s large-scale installation—the selection investigates the interactions between object and perspective. The exhibit’s temporal and stylistic diversity offers a historically recurring and significant question: how does a photograph reveal the relationship between subject and “witness.” Through comparing the work of Walker Evans and Thomas Ruff, I propose that the photographer’s perspective is fundamental to the photograph’s—and thus the human subject’s—representation of reality.
Walker Evans’ eight gelatin prints from the 1940s depict various strangers riding the subway in New York. Using a hidden camera, Evans glimpses subjects in moments of transition—lost in thought, waiting, observing others, all while he intently does the same. Placed in a technologically distant era from now, routine, intermediary phases offered a static stretch of time for passengers to either exist within one’s thoughts, or in the observation of one’s physical surroundings. With no pocket-sized window to the virtual and digital, people’s expressions during temporal in-betweens were much more diverse than today’s wash of screen staring. In discussing his untitled series, Evans writes, “The guard is down and the mask is off, even more than when in lone bedrooms (where there are mirrors). People’s faces are in naked repose down in the subway.” Through catching the “naked repose,” Evans’ photographs propose momentary viewings into complex lives. In 1988, German artist, Thomas Ruff, created a series of large-scale, chromogenic portraits. Unlike Evans’ small, unobtrusive windows, Ruff’s work is bold and domineering. The displayed portrait, Portrait (C. Kewer), is crafted to be as systematic and neutral as possible. It stands against the romantic and conventional trope that fine photography exposes a subject’s psychology, and instead presents a passport-like, standardized formula. In viewing the subject through enlarged, hyper-realistic definition, Ruff augments the faces’ porous details to a most grotesque level, exploring how photography can expose the underlying sameness of all human subjects.
The contextual vision of time is critical to the two projects’ conflicting approaches. Evans’ prints feature people static in motion. Though they are stuck still, both in the photograph and train, their environment is moving, bended to the speed of the subway’s transition. Therefore, the photographs investigate a seemingly paradoxical relationship between the stagnancy of photography and waiting, and the motion of history and transition. Motion, a product of time, glues the subjects to the ephemeral, to the mortal. With an inherent beginning, middle and end, motion implies context, narrative. Through freezing stolen moments of transition, Evans’ photographs represent subjects through the experiential. Though I do not know the subjects, nor the intricacies of their lives, I can relate to their contextualized experiences, their hidden, yet foundational narratives. The photographs strike me as deeply empathetic. The subtleties of my own experiences fill the misty gaps, while simultaneously probing the wonder of narratives not my own. Ruff’s portrait, on the other hand, is completely devoid of motion, and therefore, time. Like pressing my eyes up to a brick wall, the portrait is lifeless in its divorce from implied narrative. Its static, blunt presence offers a dull and simple view into a human’s existence. In it’s large-scale, hyper-realism, the undercurrents of a subject’s psychology are washed into a non-expression of neutral flesh.
Stepping outside the frame, Evans and Ruff paradoxically address their roles as “the witness.” While Evans approaches his series through spontaneously stylized snapshots, Ruff carefully positions his camera to veil the photographer’s integral and interjected perspective. Evans plays with moving shadows and ranging angles, defining his perspective as a fellow stranger from across the aisle. For example, his photograph of an elderly women (bottom row, far left) angles slightly up, emphasizing the hidden view from his camera. Thus, the angle portrays not only the photographer’s presence, but his method of secret snapping. Next, the elderly woman’s hands, and a man in the background are slightly blurred. Using a range of definition between the blurry forms and the precision of the woman’s face, Evans softens and veils the subject and environment’s ordinary realism. In black and white, Evans photographs represent a gesture of reality observed through a narratively-driven, cloaked lens. Ruff’s photographical perspective is based in the illusion of transparency. The camera faces its subject, perfectly still and perfectly straight—the effect: neutrality. The photographer’s looming gaze seems to be inexistent; the perspective, therefore, lies in that of an unfeeling, objective machine. In stealthily removing the giveaways of his artistic tinkering, the veil between the subject and viewer is seemingly eradicated. Because the photographer seems to be inexistent, the viewer gazes upon the subject not through the perspective of another feeling human being, but through a total objectivity.
Peering into Walker Evans’ series, I see glancing vignettes of real lives I feel I can relate to, but do not know. And shrinking under Ruff’s engrossing portrait, I see a face, composed of flesh and hair and nothing more. With two conflicting, artistic statements, I see room for synthesis. Perhaps humans are both. Perhaps we are a dynamic collection of thoughts and experiences, with a unifying base of flesh and existence. As I sit on the bus home, I witness the faces around me, and simply do not know.
1,571 Comments
This was great to read! At first, I felt you took a very academic tone, but around the third paragraph you introduced your more personal thoughts and that made for a really nice trajectory through the piece. There’s nothing like portraiture for just musing on the human condition, right?
It’s clear that you have extensive experience in this subject, and the article reflects that. Thanks to the varied and informative dordle material you’ve provided, I can see this issue from new angles. In addition, dental service provider digital marketing. You should be proud of your writing since it is so uncommon to see such high quality online these days. People like you are why the world has to keep turning!
Your credit information must be accessed and updated via the MyCoverageInfo site in order to initiate your insurance policy management system. It is anticipated that this will provide you a better understanding of the procedure and supply other details that could be helpful.
Mycoverageinfo
A large number of workers are unaware of MyCVSHR. All of the HR data is tracked by the online interface. This is where you may get personal information about your employment. This website can be used by any employee, current or past. MyHR.CVS.Com
It’s a significant contributor to the global economy, with a growing influence on other entertainment sectors. 온라인홀덤 홀덤사이트 바로접속
Julia,
I really enjoyed this piece and hearing you talk through every large and small detail of the photography habits of both Walker Evans and Thomas Ruff. It’s not often enough that we think in more meta terms about photography – about what happens in the moment when that photograph is taken and what it means for its subject matter (and how the photographer’s style influences his/her relationship with his/her subject). I would say there may be a way to write tighter, more concise paragraphs; your great points sometimes get lost in longer ones. Keep up the great work!
The world has changed in many ways since the invention of the internet and social media. The idea that we live on a small planet, divided by countries is something new to most people. It was only after colonization started did these lines come into existence and shape our lives today. U Hindi
You may access the Efficenter Employee Login Portal by choosing Client Login from the menu when it launches. You must provide both your username and password in the Efficenter login portal form. You could avoid having to input your login credentials again in the future. Efficenter
Julia — Very interesting and sharp writing. I do think, as Linnea points out, that your essay has this fascinating tonal move from academic language to personal. So what would be intriguing would be to think about how you might find a tone that merges those two in some way. It will involve experimentation, but worth exploring I think. I do think that across both tones you reach a conclusion worth considering: that between the differences of Evans and Ruff’s work we arrive at a kind of synthesis about what the human (face especially) appears like in photography: at once familiar and alien, individualized and universalized, “character” as they used to say and skin and bones for all. Perhaps this is what Evans meant by the notion of “naked repose,” which is such a rich phrase. I love the closing line of being on the bus. Strong ending! Nice and rich writing and thinking here. Thanks.
Do you feel like your libido is taking over your life? Take back control with these innovative and effective ways on How To Stop Being Horny. From exploring new hobbies to connecting with others, find the tools and resources to help you balance your desires and live a more fulfilling life.
Julia, your essay is truly captivating!
Engaging writing: You showcase “very interesting and sharp writing”, engaging the reader with your analysis.
Merging tones: While Linnea raises a point about the shift in tone between academic and personal, it’s commendable that you experiment with both. Finding a way to blend these tones could be an interesting exploration, but both styles contribute to the overall effectiveness of your piece.
Thought-provoking conclusion: You arrive at a powerful conclusion, highlighting that through the contrasting works of Evans and Ruff, we gain a multifaceted understanding of the human face in photography. This concept of the face being “at once familiar and alien, individualized and universalized” is insightful and thought-provoking. You effectively connect this idea to the evocative phrase “naked repose”, further enriching the analysis.
Strong closing: The closing line about being on the bus is powerful and memorable, leaving a lasting impression on the reader.
khalidelarbi
————————————
Online Marketing Analysis
business for sale
에볼플레이 먹튀검증 안전노리터
보증카 먹튀검증 검증된메이저
चिया बीजों के लाभ हिंदी में! चिया बीजों के गुण, पोषण सामग्री और स्वास्थ्य पर प्रभाव से अवगत हों। Chia Seeds In Hindi से जानें और स्वस्थ रहें।
เพียงคุณกดลงทะเบียน ไม่ต้องฝาก ไม่ต้องแชร์ pg slot ก็สามารถรับเครดิตฟรี โดยทันที กล้วยๆสามารถเอาไปใช้เล่นเกมได้จริงทุกเกม เว็บไซต์ของพวกเรา pg slot เครดิตฟรี 50
PG-SLOT.GAME No. 1, the easiest way to play pg slot slots, PG games break often, promotions, free credits, PG SLOT GAME, free bonuses every day. available 24 hours
뱃할맛이 나는곳 먹튀검증 안전한메이져
I was looking for another article by chance and found your article majorsite I am writing on this topic, so I think it will help a lot. I leave my blog address below. Please visit once.
Dive into the world of Tadalafil Tablet Uses in Hindi and learn how they address both erectile dysfunction (ED) and symptoms of an enlarged prostate.
God, how can you fall guys write such good essays. It will definitely be the hottest comment on social media right now.
Your post is very interesting, Thanks for the awesome post I feel happy to read this post thanks for sharing this post. run 3
I am satisfied with framed 2 and waffle game all the content in this topic, it’s great, please try it with me
you all technicalss AUGUST1983Y solutions and staff we need for 에볼루션알가격
Sincere thanks to the owner of the website, this is a beautifully designed page with lots of good and rich content, which is joined by a lot of people.lol beans
Good job! You guys do a great blog and have some great content. Keep up the good work.Myntra Email Details
Sweta…….
This is a good post. This post gives truly quality information. I’m definitely going to look into it. Really very useful tips are provided here. Thank you so much. Keep up the good works. Buy Google Reviews
This is true that media assignment is a difficult task as you have to write using different frames briefly. However, there are many students who look for best assignment writers to buy assignment online. This is the only way through which they can ensure quality work.
Thank you so much for the post you do. I like your post and all you share with us is up to date and quite informative, i would like to bookmark the page so i can come here again to read you, as you have done a wonderful job.
Cell Phone
Savitri Singh
Thank you so much for the post you do. I like your post and all you share with us is up to date and quite informative, i would like to bookmark the page so i can come here again to read you, as you have done a wonderful job.MY Business Mart
Savitri Singh
Thank you so much for the post you do. I like your post and all you share with us is up to date and quite informative, i would like to bookmark the page so i can come here again to read you, as you have done a wonderful job
Jharkhand ranchi personal life
Savitri Singh
Thank you so much for the post you do. I like your post and all you share with us is up to date and quite informative, i would like to bookmark the page so i can come here again to read you, as you have done a wonderful job.
Jharkhand ranchi personal life
SAvitri Singh
Thanks for sharing such a great information.This post gives truly quality information.I always search to read the quality content and finally i found this in your post. keep it up! Visit for Buy Positive Google Reviews.
It’s very informative and you are obviously very knowledgeable in this area. You have opened my eyes to varying views on this topic with interesting and solid content. Also digital marketing for dentist service provider. It’s hard to find good quality writing like yours these days. I truly appreciate individuals like you!
Thanks for sharing such a great informative and knowledgeable content in this area .I always search to read the quality content and finally i found this in your post.keep it up! Visit for Plumbing SEO service provider.
It’s very informative and you are obviously very knowledgeable in this area. You have opened my eyes to varying views on this topic with interesting and solid content. Also Plumbing SEO service provider. It’s hard to find good quality writing like yours these days. I truly appreciate individuals like you!
If you are looking for the best astrologer in Virginia, then visit us at psychic-yogesh.com. Psychic Yogesh Guru ji is one of the great astrologers offering Indian astrology services in Texas. Call us at 929-810-8326 for more information.
I found this post very interesting and informative.
Thank you for sharing your special thoughts with us. I definitely share this with my peeps.
Visit this and have fun !
제이나인 온라인 카지노 사이트
제이나인 안전 카지노 사이트
제이나인 카지노 검증 사이트
제이나인 카지노 게임 사이트
제이나인 라이브 카지노
https://www.j9korea.com
Hello, I have browsed most of posts. This post is probably where I got the most useful information for my research. Thanks for posting.
Monoprice 110010 Headphones
HDMovie99
It is often seen that people investigate much about the online assignment sites because they have a very common question in their mind and that is whether the website is genuine or not, so the simple advice to this question is that, yes one should definitely verify the website till their satisfaction, so that they can get a quality Finance Assignment Help and complete their assignment in the best possible way and that too at a cheap rate as compared to the market. Read more: Benefits of studying Finance
Never think that Commercial Law Assignment Help is cheating rather it is a boon which can help you in getting good grades without doing much. What you should do is that, go to australianlawassignmenthelp.com and order your assignment and see how easily you get your assignment with the help of the experts.
I feel really happy to have seen your webpage backrooms and look forward to so many more entertaining times reading here. Thanks once more for all the details
More info visit our website: http://www.macwire.de
I am also encountering this issue. Don’t know why its happening. https://www.mycoverageinfo.biz/
Etisal is a leading Pakistani clothing brand that offers a wide range of stylish and trendy ready to wear dresses for women. With a team of experienced designers, Etisal provides its customers with high-quality dresses that are both fashionable and affordable. So what are you waiting for? Start shopping for your new dress today at Etisal.
If you are looking for the best eye pencil in Pakistan to draw a stunning eye look, Flormar is the best place for you. The brand has a wide variety of eye pencils in different colors. Flormar is the perfect eye pencil for you if you are looking for makeup products such as eye pencils, eyeliner, eyebrow pencils, and mascara.
If you have been looking for the perfect ladies’ wallets in Pakistan, then you have come to the right place. At ECS, you can find the best Wallets for women and girls in Pakistan. ECS brings the best colors and designs of Wallets for women and girls. ECS Wallets for girls are available in several designs, shapes, and sizes.
Shop the best sneakers shoes for boys online in Pakistan from Borjan. Our sneakers shoes are very comfortable and best for running around. So, get the latest and most amazing collection of sneakers for you from Borjan.
Chinyere is a clothing store selling velvet dress at reasonable prices. Chinyere gives you the best offers for buying velvet dresses in Pakistan. Their velvet dress collection is perfect for women to wear for comfort.
The site gives us useful information. Thanks for the above information. 카지노사이트킴
A Pinterest Virtual Assistant helps businesses, bloggers and brands increase their presence on the Pinterest platform, which in turn helps these entities to drive more traffic to their sites. To achieve this goal a PVA creates engaging content for companies’ boards and curates popular images from other social media platforms that are related to the company’s product or service. PVAs also provide pinning advice for clients who may be new to the world of social media marketing.
It was wondering if I could use this write-up on my other website, I will link it back to your website though.Great Thanks.
온라인카지노
카지노
It is very important for businesses to be able to offer an immersive experience for their customers. We provide 3d Product Rendering and 3D Jewelry Rendering services which help our clients create realistic renderings that impress potential buyers. Our team of experts can work with you on a wide range of projects, so get in touch today if you’re interested!
I like it. It’s interesting. Thanks for sharing. Thank you. หนังใหม่ชนโรง
along with enjoying our slot games with more than 500 games to choose from, which can be played easily Because the customer can use it in the language that the customer wants. since the first time of entering the service And we also have many services ready for customers to use. 15รับ100ทํา400ถอน200
You have great knowledge and expertise in writing such blogs. Keep up the great work!
카지노사이트
Excellent website you have here, so much cool information!..
바카라사이트
Attractive, post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wanted to say that I have liked browsing your blog posts.
바카라사이트
바카라사이트
It’s always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained!
Your article has answered the question I was wondering about! I would like to write a thesis on this subject, but I would like you to give your opinion once 😀 baccaratsite
يتم تحضير مصيدة علبة الصودا بسهولة عن طريق قطع الجزء العلوي من علبة الصودا ووضعها رأسًا على عقب مثل قمع داخل الجزء السفلي المتبقي من علبة الصودا وملء الجزء السفلي بمزيج السكر والقهوة. يمكن أن تسقط الصراصير وتموت بسهولة.
البورق طريقة فعالة للغاية للتخلص من الصراصير لأنها آمنة ورخيصة وصديقة للبيئة ، فقط امزج كميات متساوية من البورق والسكر وافرد الخليط في مناطق مختلفة من منزلك ، ويمكن استخدامه عن طريق فرده. البوراكس يدمر الجهاز الهضمي والغطاء الخارجي لجسم الصرصور بسبب السكر ويقتل الصرصور لأنه يجذب الشقوق وقيعان الخزانة والمصارف والصراصير.
املأ زجاجة عريضة بكمية كافية من الفازلين ، وأضف القليل من قشور الفاكهة مثل الموز أو المانجو أو التفاح ، ثم ضع الزجاجة في غرفتك أو مطبخك ، حيث تكثر الصراصير ، وفي المكان الذي تنجذب إليه هذه الوصفة. ضع الصراصير في زجاجة وفي اليوم التالي أفرغ الصراصير في وعاء به كمية كافية من الماء والصابون لقتل وإبادة الصراصير.
هذه الوصفة تمزج 1 ملعقة كبيرة من مسحوق الفلفل الحار و 1 فص ثوم ، يضاف ما يكفي من معجون البصل إلى 1 لتر من الماء ، تخلط المكونات جيداً ، تضاف 1 ملعقة كبيرة من الصابون السائل ، تخلط مرة أخرى ، يوضع الخليط على نوافذ ومداخل منزلك ودعه يجلس لمدة ساعة أو أكثر.
https://dmdbaj.wixsite.com/shohob
The weather has gotten a lot colder. I hope you dress warmly and drink lots of warm water so that you don’t catch a cold because it’s suddenly gets cold. This cold is very strong.메이저놀이터