1. “[…] an extended use of the adjectival form [cultural] in more specialist and academic languages. And whole fields of knowledge are now described as cultural. If cultural studies and cultural critique led the way here, the fields of cultural psychology, cultural history, cultural geography, and cultural evolution have followed in short order as part of the more general cultural turn in the humanities and social sciences.” (Bennett, 64)
2. “While criticism in its most general sense developed towards censure, criticism in its specialized sense developed toward taste, cultivation, and later culture and discrimination.” (Williams, 85)
“The notion that response was judgment depended, of course, on the social confidence of a class and later a profession. The confidence was variously specified, originally as learning or scholarship, later as cultivation and taste, later still as sensibility. […] Criticism becomes ideological not only when it assumes the position of the consumer but also when it masks this position by a succession of abstractions of its real terms of response.[…] The point would then be […] to get rid of the habit, which depends, fundamentally, on the abstraction of response from its real situation and circumstances: the elevation to ‘judgment,’ and to an apparently general process, when what always needs to be understood is the specificity of the response, which is not an abstract ‘judgment’ but even where including, as often necessarily, positive or negative responses, a definite practice, in active and complex relations with its whole situation and context.” (Williams, 86)
3. Three broad active categories of usage [of culture]: (i) the independent and abstract noun which describes a general process of intellectual, spiritual, and aesthetic development, (ii) the independent noun, whether used generally or specifically, which indicates a particular way of life, whether of a people, a period, a group, or humanity in general, and (iii) the independent and abstract noun which describes the works and practices of intellectual and especially artistic activity. (Williams, 90)
4. “[…] involving claims to superior knowledge, refinement, and distinctions between ‘high’ art (culture) and popular art and entertainment.” (Williams, 92)
5. “Criticism is or ought to be a cognitive activity and that it is a form of knowledge.” (Said, 224)
6. “What matters is the criticism to which such an ideological complex is subjected by the first representatives of the new historical phase. This criticism makes possible a process of differentiation and change in the relative weight that the elements of old ideologies used to possess. What was previously secondary and subordinate, even incidental, is now taken to be primary- becomes the nucleus of a new ideological and theoretical complex. The old collective will dissolve into its contradictory elements since the subordinate ones develop socially.” (Samuel, 237)
7. “Or should we rather bring the sword of criticism to criticism itself and do a bit of soul-searching here: what were we really after when we were so intent on showing the social construction of scientific facts? Nothing guarantees, after all, that we should be right all the time. There is no sure ground even for criticism. Isn’t this what criticism intended to say: that there is no sure ground anywhere?” (Latour, 227)
8. “If this were possible then we could let the critics come ever closer to the matters of concern we cherish, and then at last we could tell then: ‘Yes, please, touch them, explain them, deploy them.’” (Latour, 248)
9. “These ideas have a special interest for critics today who may wish to place themselves skeptically between culture as a massive body of self-congratulating ideas and system or method, anything resembling a sovereign technique that claims to be free of history, subjectivity, or circumstance. […] If it is not to be merely a form of self-validation, criticism must intend knowledge and, what’s more, it must attempt to deal with, identify, and produce knowledge as having something to do with will and with reason.” (Said, 202)
WHAT: A Broad Topic, but Concrete Talks
Williams discusses culture and criticism separately, but the discussions when taken together can help us shed new lights on cultural criticism as a whole. On the one hand, he redefines “culture” by investigating its genealogy, and on the other hand, he sets up requirements for “criticism.”
As for culture, Williams traces its usage to the 17th century when it still meant the tending of natural growth, and summarizes three main definitions of “culture” that derived throughout time, from the general process of intellectual, spiritual, and aesthetic development, to a particular way of life, to the work and practices of intellectual activity.
More importantly, after delineating the development of what the term “culture” refers to, Williams points out that we are not to favor one definition over another by choosing the one that is “true,” “proper,” or “scientific,” but should note and take into account the range and overlap of meanings. In understanding the term “culture,” he highlights the importance of acknowledging its complexity, such as its indication in the duality in material and symbolic production, and the significance of studying the relations between the different meanings.
That said, Williams broadens the subject of cultural criticism by pointing out the complexity that lies in the term “culture.” As a result, criticism of “culture” would not be limited to the usual sense, that is on the artistic activities and products, but also the ways of lives that people lead, and even the general process of human development.
As for criticism, Williams criticizes how criticism is conducted as an abstract judgement, and proposes that it should be about the “specificity […] in active and complex relations with its whole situation and context.”
That is, Williams requires criticism to be specific to both the subject itself and its context, and accordingly provide concrete responses instead of vague judgments.
HOW: One Name, Multiple Jobs
A critic is a teacher, a proxy, a criticizer, a coordinator, and more. With knowledge and taste, he leads its readers into the world of literature, music, and drama (Mendelsohn). With time and attention, he set up connections with the pieces, and convey his private experience to his readers (Ventura). With guts and insights, he points out the faults and pushes the development in the field where his passion lies (Garner). With his presence, as the representative of the spectator, he completes the art work (Schwabsky).
What I would like to elaborate here, however, is the critic as a philosopher. While Said acknowledges neither Derrida and Foucault is a literary critic, he introduces their ideas to explain literary criticism, which pursue philosophical inquiries.
Both Derrida and Foucault describe culture as influenced by some dominant force. Derrida’s idea of the “culture” in discussion is the Western culture which forms a “cultural domination” centering “metaphysics and its hierarchies,” manifested in “texts” ranging from Plato to Heidegger. Foucault sees the production of culture governed by “discourses,” which he describes as “impersonal, systematic, and highly regulated by enuciative formations.” (Said, 186)
Their criticism of culture, then, serves to challenge the authorities and influences exerted on it, whether it is the “metaphysics,” or the “discourses”. For Derrida, it is to uncover the “silent complicity between the superstructural pressures of metaphysics and an author’s ambiguous innocence about a detail at base level.” He stands up to challenge logocentric fallacies, such as “the nostalgia for presence,” (Said, 190) pointing out that language can never bring about presence, but is always representation. For Foucault, it is to make the text “assume its affiliation with institutions, offices, agencies, classes, academics, corporations, groups, guilds, ideologically defined parties and professions” by “redefining and reidentifying the particular interests that al texts serve.” (Said, 212) That is, he points out that the author is not isolated as he or she produces a text, but placed in a specific historical, social, and political context, all of which influences him or her. Thus it is not sufficient to understand the text in isolation, but should take into account the context, examine the influences, and decipher the meanings hidden due to these influences.
Both Derrida’s and Foucault’s stances encourage cultural critics to detach themselves from the dominate culture, challenge the orthodox way of thinking, and produce knowledge, which is contentious. In this sense, when producing a description of the original text, the critic, stripping away or at least acknowledging the forces acted upon the text, gets closer to the meaning of the original text than the original text itself, as if he or she deciphers it.
AND THEN: The Power of Words
The articles provide a broad range of understandings of culture, including subjects from literature (Said) to social conditions (Latour). While addressing different subjects, they all point out the radical power in criticism: Instead of cultivating “taste” on high arts, or arguing to favor some preferences over others, they describe criticism as a way to inform, as an intellectual inquiry in search of the true meanings of texts, and even as a weapon to bring about revolutions.
That said, the articles all convey the idea that words and understandings have power, and criticism has the capacity to alter, form, and communicate understandings. Just as orthodox beliefs constrain the way people think, criticism challenging these beliefs liberates them, or at least make them conscious about the restraint. From the words of critics, then, readers are taught, connected, and even intellectually challenged.
Key words
1. Authority: Authority bear different senses in the discussions. On the one hand, critics need to possess some sort of “authority,” that is, trust based on credential, in order to present their ideas to the viewers. On the other hand, critics, as Derrida and Foucault would argue, challenges the authorities, that is the established ideas.
2. Power: Critics, at least in idea, have the power of words. They make judgments or claims, which exerts influence on people given critics have the authority, and the people in turn carry out activities. In short, the production of authoritative ideas has the power to influence actions.
3. Knowledge: On the one hand, critics need knowledge in order to make judgments and provide responses. On the other hand, critics produce knowledge in their judgments and responses.
1,054 Comments
I truly enjoyed the top quality info you present to your visitors? 918KISS AUTO
Will be back again frequently to check up on new posts. JILI WALLET
We are leading 918kissauto
Fuel Bowser Manufacturers in India JOKER AUTO WALLET
involved in manufacturing of a high range of Tanker PUSSY888 AUTO
Truck fabrication which include Autom.MEGA888 AUTO
This type of message always inspiring Live22 auto
I prefer to read quality content, JOKER WALLET
so happy to find good place to many here in the post, PG SLOT AUTO
the writing is just great, JILI WALLET
thanks for the post. Betflix wallet
The assignment submission period was over and I was nervous, majorsite and I am very happy to see your post just in time and it was a great help. Thank you ! Leave your blog address below. Please visit me anytime.
Thanks for sharing this. Hughes Discount Code
However, playing online includes using real money to bet. Players should be careful and research the websites where they want to invest in games. Before applying for membership and betting To avoid wasting money สล็อต เว็บตรงไม่ผ่านเอเย่นต์ ไม่มี ขั้น ต่ํา วอ เลท
I really like how you incorporated the graphic novel element throughout the painting, having the comic panels as part of their clothing! Love it! 토토사이트
this post is extra charming.
카지노사이트
Flyme Aviation, a leading provider of aircraft chartering and leasing solutions. We specialize in connecting businesses, individuals, and organizations with the perfect aircraft to meet their unique needs.
Air Cargo Charter
There are other benefits to doing this online. Many more if we are a new player starting to play. What you will receive is knowledge in the field of…..and the playing style of the players who play the game…. New and สล็อต เว็บตรงไม่ผ่านเอเย่นต์ ไม่มี ขั้น ต่ํา วอ เลท different, it is not a player that ordinary players start playing the game.
This investigation serves as a reminder of the immense value that <a href="https://yourpetplanet.com/pet provides to our world, making it a better place to live.
The Critics: With the Power of Words is a compelling exploration of how critics shape our perceptions through language. With a user-friendly approach, it delves into the influential world of critique, inviting readers to ponder the impact of words on art and culture. A captivating read for anyone curious about the nuanced relationship between critics and the creative realms they traverse.
twitch ad block
Your explanation is organized very easy to understand!!! I understood at once. Could you please post about baccaratsite ?? Please!!
Of course, your article is good enough, slotsite but I thought it would be much better to see professional photos and videos together. There are articles and photos on these topics on my homepage, so please visit and share your opinions.
When I read an article on this topic, baccaratcommunity the first thought was profound and difficult, and I wondered if others could understand.. My site has a discussion board for articles and photos similar to this topic. Could you please visit me when you have time to discuss this topic?
Your writing is perfect and complete. casinocommunity However, I think it will be more wonderful if your post includes additional topics that I am thinking of. I have a lot of posts on my site similar to your topic. Would you like to visit once?
I’ve been looking for photos and articles on this topic over the past few days due to a school assignment, baccaratcommunity and I’m really happy to find a post with the material I was looking for! I bookmark and will come often! Thanks 😀
This blog is an amazing one, the contents here are always very educative and useful, the reason I make it my regular blog of visit so as to widen my knowledge every day, thanks for always sharing useful and interesting information, you can checkout this I’ve always wondered about this! Loved your advice!! Thanks so much for sharing your expertise 🙂
Regards :
Best PTE Test Centers, Fees, and Academic Excellence in UAE
A range of emotions are stirred by your words. Your own perspectives give the conversation more depth. We appreciate you contributing to this lively discussion by offering your ideas.
Regards: Mushroo
I actually like reading all of the blog posts on your website, sir. In general, this essay is pleasant and informational. Everything has a purpose and exists for a reason. Your article is really good.
Regards: al-mheiri laws
This concept is a good way to enhance knowledge and will be recommended this information to my friends. Thanks for explaining it perfectly continue to share your knowledge through articles like these, and keep posting more blogs.
As I read your words, I’m reminded that the power of storytelling can unite us all, transcending boundaries and differences.
Regards: Discover the fascinating world of insects with Insect Insider!
Thank you for sharing such important information, which is hard to come across in normal.
Politely Swear in French
French Truly
Your website is really cool and this is a great inspiring article.
You’re really a good webmaster. The site loading speed is incredible.
Thank you for the very useful information.
먹튀검증
I hope they find each other…simply gorgeous work!
스포츠토토사이트
I really like how you incorporated the graphic novel element throughout the painting, having the comic panels as part of their clothing! Love it! 메이저 토토사이트
i’ve never wanted a happy ending for a pair on missed connections more than now. i hope they find each other. and what book did you gleam inspiration from? the mini-illustrations on the boy and girl are adorable. is that a red lamb i see? 온라인카지노사이트
I’ve been searching for hours on this topic and finally found your post. safetoto Hopefully this corona will end soon. My blog is a blog that mainly posts pictures of daily life before Corona and landscapes at that time. If you want to remember that time again, please visit us.
First of all, thank you for your post. casin0 online I don’t know how grateful you are for posting on this topic. Thank you for the numerous articles on this site, I will subscribe to those links in my bookmarks and visit them often. Have a nice day
I’ve been looking for photos and articles on this topic over the past few days due to a school assignment, baccarat online Your posts are neatly organized with the information I want, so there are plenty of resources to reference. I bookmark this site and will find your posts frequently in the future. Thanks again ^^
I’ve been troubled for several days with this topic. casinosite, but I have stopped writing because there is no reference material. Then I accidentally found your article. I can refer to a variety of materials, so I think the work I was preparing will work! Thank you for your efforts.
First of all, thank you for your post. 메이저사이트 Your posts are neatly organized with the information I want, so there are plenty of resources to reference. I bookmark this site and will find your posts frequently in the future. Thanks again ^^
Best Mobile App Development Company in India
Prometheas Technologies is an android mobile app development company grass-roots for traversing your app development strategy, originating seamless interface, and developing an android app that adds significant value to your organization. We don’t restrict our services to smartphones only. Our trained android apps developers furnish optimized apps for various Android devices and floors. Visit- https://prometheastech.com , mail us- hello@prometheastech.com
Agen Slot Online JAYASPIN memberikan pelayanan terbaik kepada semua pemain sehingga semua pemain bisa bermain dengan sangat nyaman. Jayaspin berkomitmen untuk memberikan semua pemainnya pengalaman bermain yang baru.,
sebagai situs togel resmi dan memiliki lisensi Kudabet menyediakan layanan customer care dan layanan situs selama 24 jam nonstop setiap hari, sehingga Anda dapat bermain situs togel online terpercaya kapan pun Anda mau.
Dengan hadir agen slot Gaspoll88 kini situs judi Game Slot Gacor resmi dan terpercaya dengan winrate tertinggi,
Gaspoll88 sudah berkomitmen akan senantiasa memberikan pelayanan terbaik dan ternyaman untuk para membernya dengan menghadirkan custumer service terbaik dan sangat ramah.
Permainan terbaik dan agen terpercaya hadir dengan beragam game gacor yang memberikan member pilihan bermain. Raih Cuan dan Jackpot besar bersama kami. kini Dapat anda mainkan via link LELE247.
Hire ServiceNow Developers
Prometheas Technologies, an esteemed ServiceNow App Development Partner, specializes in crafting AI-powered custom apps on the cloud-based ServiceNow platform. Enhance your organization’s efficiency by optimizing digital workflows through our cutting-edge solutions. At Prometheas Technologies, one of the best ServiceNow development company in India, we prioritize top-notch quality and impeccable features, implementing rigorous quality assurance with multiple layers of checks. Our unwavering commitment to uncompromised quality and high-performing features has positioned us as one of the leading ServiceNow development companies in India.
Choose https://prometheastech.com as your ServiceNow development partner and unlock the full potential of the platform to drive your business forward.
It’s really great. Thank you for providing a quality article. There is something you might be interested in. Do you know 토토커뮤니티 ? If you have more questions, please come to my site and check it out!
I appreciated how you unpacked the intricate dance between critics and their subjects. Your insights into how a critic’s perspective can shape public opinion and the artist’s journey were enlightening. It’s like you peeled back the layers of the critic’s role, showcasing the impact their words can have beyond the immediate review.places to visit near nandi hills
“Absolutely love myEva Eyeglasses Spectacle Case – stylish, sturdy, and a perfect blend of fashion and functionality!”
What a remarkable article! It’s exceptionally well-written and brimming with valuable insights. I’m grateful for your sharing of such informative content.
As the Best SEO Agency in Karachi, we excel in providing customized digital marketing solutions supported by data-driven methodologies.
I’m eagerly anticipating more posts of this same high quality in the future!