“For all criticism is based on that equation: KNOWLEDGE + TASTE = MEANINGFUL JUDGMENT. The key word here is meaningful. People who have strong reactions to a work—and most of us do—but don’t possess the wider erudition that can give an opinion heft, are not critics. (This is why a great deal of online reviewing by readers isn’t criticism proper.) Nor are those who have tremendous erudition but lack the taste or temperament that could give their judgment authority in the eyes of other people, people who are not experts. (This is why so many academic scholars are no good at reviewing for mainstream audiences.) …The role of the critic, I repeat, is to mediate intelligently and stylishly between a work and its audience; to educate and edify in an engaging and, preferably, entertaining way. (Critics, more than any other kind of writer, should have a sense of humor.)” – Daniel Mendelsohn
“What the critic has to give is the fruits of looking laggardly, an attention that appears in increasingly lesser quantities today, a long and sustained commitment to coaxing meaning from mute objects. Though we “pay” attention, our attention need not be regulated by the industrial logic of clock time. What the critic has to offer is her own subjectivity, her own careful, glacial experience of a work of art, especially ones that do not immediately break open to the spectator’s gaze…But for now, what I’m calling for is criticism as temporary communion rather than appraisal. A criticism that’s slow, descriptive, subjective, a criticism that values process and experience over judgement and whose language is as intricate as its looking. Our eyes still have to adjust. We have to slow down. We have to lose ourselves.” – Anya Ventura
Most people have experiences with cultural criticism through critiques on writings, films, music, dances and many other different forms of art. The questions are: Who are the critics and what are they criticizing for? What are they supposed to do for us? There are certainly a number of different opinions on what cultural criticism is and what a cultural critic does.
The quotes above from Daniel Mendelsohn and Anya Ventura represent two of the different opinions on cultural criticism and critics. They both agree in their view of the critic as a positive force for both an artwork and its audiences. On the contrary, while Mendelsohn sees the critic as someone who edifies and educates its audience and provides judgment, Ventura sees the critic as someone who helps other spectators to focus slow attention toward an artwork. Together, both views shed light on whether the critic’s priority is to provide a judgment on a work, or to evoke a slow, descriptive attention toward work.
Mendelsohn sees the critic’s role in educating and edifying audience by providing a meaningful judgment through one’s critique. As the quote shows, he believes that a critic is someone who possess both knowledge and taste, or sensibility, that either of the scholars or the general spectators have. Therefore, in Mendelsohn’s view, a critic is positioned completely differently from both an artwork and its audience; he is the mediator who stays in between them to provide judgment. In this relationship, the critic’s priority is to judge an artwork.
On the other hand, Anya Ventura sees the critic as someone who assists spectators in slowly and attentively experiencing a work, before rushing to its judgment. Furthermore, she believes criticism to be a “temporary communion” rather than “appraisal.” Although Ventura’s view states critics as people who “offer” their own subjectivity or experience of a work of art to other spectators, and are therefore somewhat superior to the general spectators in experiencing art, they are never teachers or judges of art. Criticism, to Ventura, is the redirection of attention toward work of art, and the experience of work itself, rather than a judgment on a work of art.
Throughout both articles, judgment, or appraisal, emerges as one of the key issues in defining criticism. Mendelsohn puts the highest priority in judgment while Ventura stresses the importance of process and experience over judgment. The idea of judgment further opens up the discussion of the power relationship between the critic and a work’s audience. The idea of judgment is crucial since if one is believed to be in the position of judging something, that person obtains the power to rule something; however, that judgment can also be flawed. As Bruno Latour writes in “Why Has Critique Run Out of Steam?”, some critics write critiques that are at the level of groundless conspiracy theory. Therefore, as in Mendelsohn’s case, if the critic’s main goal is to judge a work of art and to teach its audience, there should be a more discussion on who is qualified to teach and judge, since teaching and judging are more dangerous than simply offering one’s subjectivity to help others better experience a work of art.
To sum up, Mendelsohn believes that the critic’s job is to provide a meaningful judgment capable through the critics’ expertise and taste in a work of art. Anya Ventura sees the cultural critic and the cultural criticism as something that puts process and experience of a work of art before the judgment of it. It is important, overall, to note that judging something and teaching someone should always be approached carefully, as wrong judgment and teachings would always be highly detrimental to the art of criticism.
- Anya Ventura, “Slow Criticism: Art in the Age of Post-Judgement,” Temporary Art Review, 15 February 2016, http://temporaryartreview.com/slow-criticism-art-in-the-age-of-post-judgement/
- Daniel Mendelsohn, “A Critic’s Manifesto,” New Yorker, 28 August 2012, http://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/a-critics-manifesto
- Bruno Latour, “Why Has Critique Run Out of Steam? From Matters of Fact to Matters of Concern,” Critical Inquiry30 (2004), 225–48.
1,920 Comments
It feels great when you bet at s66 . Access now and receive great promotions every day.
This article offers such insightful perspectives! I particularly resonated with specific point mentioned in the article. It aligns perfectly with the ideas I’ve been exploring on my website mcgift.giftcardmall. Great read, thank you for sharing!
I loved diving into this topic! Your breakdown of topic is comprehensive and engaging. I’ve actually covered a similar angle on my website five back gift card Your article adds another layer of depth to the conversation. Well done!
What an intriguing post! Your take on topic is thought-provoking. I’ve been exploring a similar viewpoint on my site my balance now, especially regarding specific aspect. Your insights have given me more to consider. Thanks for sharing your expertise!
This article is a gem! I appreciate the way you’ve outlined topic with such clarity. Your analysis of specific point is spot-on. It resonates with the discussions I’ve been having over on my website tải sunwin. Keep up the fantastic work!
The Best gaming club: https://www.howin888.com/
s666, the most reputable bookmaker in the betting market today. Visit now to receive crazy promotions from: s66
It feels great when you bet at s66 live. Access now and receive great promotions every day. Good luck
Thanks forVZ99
Fantastic post! The ideas shared resonate deeply. I’ve actually written about in more detail on cá heo .link
This article is a gem! I appreciate the way you’ve outlined topic with such clarity philippe troussier đội huấn luyện
Link alternatif 1 Barbar69
Link alternatif 2 barbar69
Demo Slot Pragmatic Play
Slot Gaming Gacor
Live Bacarrat Terbaru
Barbar C4sino Online
Hot games Special Natal 2023
Promo Natal 2023
Main Slot Di Pinjamin Modal Di barbar69
I loved diving into this topic bảng xếp hạng league 1 .
What an intriguing post! Your take on topic is thought-provoking. câu lạc bộ leeds united.
Best N4GM
Great site: 78WIN
Thank for watching Thantaiapp
Watching Win898.com
See Nohu alo789
Read Camp88 club
See now Su789.live
Hey, you used to write wonderful, but the last few posts have been kinda boring¡K I miss your super writings. Past several posts are just a little bit out of track! come on! KHUYÊN MÃI 789WIN
Frustrated with complex assignments? We’ll write them for you! Professional assistance to write my assignment for me at unbeatable prices. Try us now!
Tired of searching ‘write my assignment for me’? Our dedicated team is here to provide reliable, high-quality writing services tailored to your needs. Contact us today! https://www.bestwritemyassignment.co.uk
This article offers such insightful perspectives! I particularly resonated with specific point mentioned in the article. It aligns perfectly with the ideas I’ve been exploring on my website thông cống nghẹt hoàng long. Great read, thank you for sharing!
I stumbled upon your blog, and I must say, I’m impressed by the diversity of topics you cover. From travel to food to trendytoggle personal development, there’s something for everyone here. Keep up the great work, and I’ll definitely be a regular visitor!
I love how your blog provides a fresh perspective on various subjects. It’s a breath of fresh air in the world of MBA Colleges in Chennai online content. Your writing style is captivating, and I can’t wait to see what you’ll explore next
I appreciate the time and effort you put into each post. The depth of your knowledge is evident, and it’s a pleasure to learn from you Also check insidercraze.
78win, the most reputable bookmaker in the betting market today. Visit now to receive crazy promotions from: 78win
Excellent and decent post. It is brilliant blog. I like the way you express information to us. Thanks for such post and please keep it up.Walking Dead Negan Jacket
I can’t get enough of your blog! The quality of your content is consistently top-notch, and your passion for the subject matter shines through in every post. You’ve inspired me to delve deeper into this topic. Thank you for sharing your expertise also check Indian matka!
I’ve been playing EverQuest for years, and I must say that the community is one of the friendliest I’ve ever come across. It’s always a pleasure to group up with helpful and kind players. Also don’t forget visit this blog best erp for schools.
Wonderful article. Fascinating to read. I love to read such an excellent article. Thanks! It has made my task more and extra easy. Keep rocking.
Blade Runner Coat
Your blog has become my go-to resource for insightful and well-researched articles. I appreciate the time and effort you put into each post. The depth of your knowledge is evident, and it’s a pleasure to learn from you Also check e transfer loans canada.
keep sharing such useful information
really useful information that you shared with us
https://onebusinessnews.com/
I’ve been playing EverQuest for years, and I must say that the community is one of the friendliest I’ve ever come across. It’s always a pleasure to group up with helpful and kind players. Also don’t forget visit this blog mycasinoguru.com.
Your blog has become my go-to resource for insightful and well-researched articles. I appreciate the time and effort you put into each post. The depth of your knowledge is evident, and it’s a pleasure to learn from you Also check Buy Antique Jewellery Online.
I appreciate the time and effort you put into each post. The depth of your knowledge is evident, and it’s a pleasure to learn from you visit https://mywordle.net/.
I can’t get enough of your blog! The quality of your content is consistently top-notch, and your passion for the subject matter shines through in every post. You’ve inspired me to delve deeper into this topic. Thank you for https://gstinfo.net/ sharing your expertise!
I’ve been surfing on-line greater than three hours as of late, but I by no means found any interesting article like yours. It¡¦s pretty worth enough for me. In my opinion, if all website owners and bloggers made good content as you probably did, the internet can be much more useful than ever before. keonhacai
I like your blog it is a amazing blog Travel Guest Post.