The Role of a Critic

There is not a simple definition for cultural criticism. Criticism can change depending on the form being criticized, the time period, and of course the person defining it. While some find criticism to be more of a passive form of expression, others define it as more active. When looking at only two separate explanations of the concept, they both take very different approaches.

In “A Critic’s Manifesto,” Daniel Mendelsohn describes criticism as the intersection of knowledge and taste. For Mendelsohn, when a critic looks at a book, the critique should not be constrained to that one piece of work, but to the author’s entire repertoire to see “that book against all of the [author’s] other work” (Mendelsohn). That way, by reading the review, the reader gets “the tools to evaluate the description of the performance at hand” (Mendelsohn). This way the reader isn’t left helpless at the will of the critic, he can form his own opinion of the piece of work and of the critique itself.

Of course, expertise is not enough to form a worthy piece of criticism. Mendelsohn also suggests taste is an important part of the equation. This also implies subjectivity to criticism as everyone has different taste. Two men can both know everything there is to know about a certain artist, but if they have different taste in art, their criticism will be very different. What is important is that both critics had the evidence on which to base their critiques, making both critiques, no matter how much they contrast, very reliable.

Barry Schwabsky talks of a much more active critic in “A Critic’s Job of Work.” He calls the critic, “the self-appointed representative of the spectator.” This is interesting because the average critic probably knows a lot more than the average spectator, but then that goes back to Mendelsohn’s point of the critic inserting his expertise into the critique to bring the reader up to speed.

Schwabsky also states that as a spectator, the critic “realizes the artist’s work – not by leaving it just as it is, but by adding something to it, making a personal contribution” (Schwabsky). This means, “the work can never be completed because, as long as it still has life in it, others will always be making their own contribution to its ideal future” (Schwabsky).

So, to Schwabsky, the critic is more than someone with taste and knowledge. It does seem that he would agree with Mendelsohn in that these characteristics are necessary, but the critic’s role does not end there. A critique cannot just have background and an opinion – it must add something to the piece. According to Marcel Duchamp, “the spectator brings the work in contact with the external world by deciphering and interpreting its inner qualification and thus adds his contribution to the creative act.” Since Schwabsky’s critic is “the self-appointed representative of the spectator,” it is his job to begin the process of personal contribution.

These men are just two of the many we have studied in class, each one looking at criticism under a different light. While Mendelsohn points out the basic characteristics that a critic needs, Schwabsky brings it a step further. These are just two examples of the many ways that one can look at criticism and the role critics play. Both of these men obviously think highly of critics and see their role as an important one.

742 Comments

  • spotify mod commented on August 27, 2024 Reply

    This app spotify mod apk Tools boasts a wide streaming selection but comes with good security.

  • Ali commented on August 27, 2024 Reply

    This app capcut mod apk download Tools boasts a wide streaming selection but comes with good security.

  • bubud commented on August 27, 2024 Reply

    Howdy. Very nice web site!! Guy .. Excellent .. Wonderful .. I’ll bookmark your web site and take the feeds additionally…I am satisfied to locate numerous helpful information here within the article. Thank you for sharing. david hoffmeister

  • Mike Rooney commented on August 28, 2024 Reply

    It gives in depth information.
    Jack Harlow White Suit

  • jud commented on August 29, 2024 Reply

    bewin1688 Do you want extar money?

  • kardelen commented on August 29, 2024 Reply

    Haartransplantation Türkei : Fortschrittliche Techniken und Expertise
    Die Türkei hat sich als Vorreiter in der Anwendung moderner Haartransplantationstechniken etabliert. Kliniken im Land sind bekannt für ihre Expertise in Verfahren wie der Follicular Unit Extraction (FUE) und der Direct Hair Implantation (DHI). Diese minimalinvasiven Methoden garantieren nicht nur ästhetisch ansprechende Ergebnisse, sondern auch eine schnellere Heilung und weniger postoperative Beschwerden.

  • Jenny Eastwood commented on August 31, 2024 Reply

    Another outstanding post on your blog! Your dedication to share knowledge is admirable. I’m here to make sure students academic path is smooth in the event that they require do my assignment uk service from Global Assignnment Help. We provide 100% plagiarism free content and on time delivery of your assignments. We also offer case study help, thesis help, paper help and other services.

  • bubu commented on August 31, 2024 Reply

    Thank you, I’ve just been searching for information about this topic for a while and yours is the greatest I’ve discovered till now. But, what in regards to the conclusion? Are you sure concerning the supply? sbobet judi bola

  • snapchat plus mod apk commented on August 31, 2024 Reply

    Very efficiently written information. It will be beneficial to anybody who utilizes it, including me. Keep up the good work. For sure i will check out more posts. This site seems to get a good amount of visitors. snapchat plus mod apk

  • Jenny Eastwood commented on September 2, 2024 Reply

    After sharing my experience on their site, I received multiple positive comments from other students who had also found their services to be extremely valuable. As a student, I used Positive Comments for do my assignmenton Global Assignment Help to complete my assignment. Global Assignment Help significantly improved my academic experience.

  • melissa commented on September 3, 2024 Reply

    I found great and good information about The Role of a Critic from your blog and now I am telling you about drink. calamansi juice is a must try and this is her best advice.

    • Adil Murad commented on October 1, 2024 Reply

      Enter the amazing world of online secure sites with XNXUBD VPN Browser APK, the astonishing application that combines the power of a VPN and also a web browser.
      It offers a safer and more secure browsing experience. With this premium application, you can code your internet connections, open and discover the web anonymously, and easily pass over legal restrictions. Download the safest apk file ever found and enjoy.

      • APK Wides commented on October 1, 2024 Reply

        Minecraft APK is a pixel-based game, you will amazed to learn the all features of the game. I have checked out all these things, Now want to share all the information and the best game with you.

  • bubu commented on September 3, 2024 Reply

    Thank you , I’ve just been searching for information about this topic for a while and yours is the greatest I’ve discovered till now. But, what in regards to the conclusion? Are you sure concerning the supply? 娛樂城

    • APK Wides commented on October 1, 2024 Reply

      On the other hand, the Snaptube Mod Apk offers full HD quality of each type of content and is also free.

    • APK Wides commented on October 1, 2024 Reply

      Manok Na Pula Mod Apk is an adventurous chicken game in which you take control of a chicken and battle with other chickens. 

  • pp888 commented on September 5, 2024 Reply

    เว็บนาซ่า easy to play get real money

  • doyok commented on September 5, 2024 Reply

    Bandar togel resmi terpercaya hanya di JAMBITOTO

  • Simmonz commented on September 5, 2024 Reply

    Be patient: self-learning takes time and effort, so don’t be discouraged by the first difficulties, but keep moving forward.

  • Learn about office relocation in Dubai. commented on September 5, 2024 Reply

    I was reading some of your content on this website and I conceive this internet site is really informative ! Keep on putting up. Learn about office relocation in Dubai.

  • bubuegtrtghrtghr commented on September 8, 2024 Reply

    I am glad to be a visitant of this double dyed web site, appreciate it for this rare info! david hoffmeisterthank

  • Kinoxtoo commented on September 8, 2024 Reply

    Very efficiently written information. It will be beneficial to anybody who utilizes it, including me. Keep up the good work. For sure i will check out more posts. This site seems to get a good amount of visitors. Kinoxtoo

  • Jadenjustice commented on September 9, 2024 Reply

    Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if you knew of any widgets I could add to my blog
    that automatically tweet my newest twitter updates.
    I’ve been looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time and was hoping maybe you would have some experience with something like this.
    Please let me know if you run into anything. I truly enjoy reading your blog and I look forward to your new updates.

    Kreativitas.net

  • Samantha Chung commented on September 10, 2024 Reply

    Celebrate the power of women with women fostering communities of trust, collaboration, and empowerment in every aspect of life.

  • myflixerr commented on September 10, 2024 Reply

    Very efficiently written information. It will be beneficial to anybody who utilizes it, including me. Keep up the good work. For sure i will check out more posts. This site seems to get a good amount of visitors. myflixerr

  • แทงหวย commented on September 11, 2024 Reply

    In Thailand, what is the meaning of online lotto betting?

    Instead of purchasing lottery tickets at conventional lottery booths, online lottery betting involves doing so. For risk-takers, it makes things convenient because it allows them to do so anytime, anywhere, around the clock.
    แทงหวยออนไลน์

    แทงหวย

  • tiempos nica commented on September 11, 2024 Reply

    Very efficiently written information. It will be beneficial to anybody who utilizes it, including me. Keep up the good work. For sure i will check out more posts. This site seems to get a good amount of visitors. tiempos nica

  • Tori Aspinall commented on September 12, 2024 Reply

    Outsource your customer support outsourcing to improve service quality, reduce costs, and provide 24/7 assistance to your clients.

  • WSO55 commented on September 13, 2024 Reply

    WSO55 adalah situs slot gacor hari ini terbaru gampang menang yang bekerja sama dengan beragam jenis provider slot online termasuk provider paling populer sekalipun.

  • Raden138 commented on September 13, 2024 Reply

    Raden138 adalah situs judi slot online terpercaya yang menawarkan slot gacor hari ini dari server slot777 yang dikenal gampang menang dan berpotensi maxwin. Sebagai agen judi online yang telah beroperasi di Asia Tenggara selama lebih dari satu dekade, RADEN138 telah mendapatkan kepercayaan dari ribuan bettor di Indonesia.

  • PGPLAY commented on September 14, 2024 Reply

    PGPLAY999 รวมจบครบทุกการเดิมพัน
    ยุคที่ธุรกิจออนไลน์เติบโตอย่างรวดเร็ว PGPLAY999 ชื่อชื่อที่เข้ามาโดยตรงส่วนใหญ่จะรวมทุกคำขอของนักพนันในที่เดียว PGPLAY999 ไม่เพียงแต่เป็นเว็บออนไลน์ที่เปิดเผยทั่วไปเป็นแพลตฟอร์มที่ไม่จำเป็นสำหรับทุกๆ รูป เหตุผลที่ทำให้ PGPLAY999 โดดเด่นและโดดเด่นในตลาด

  • por commented on September 14, 2024 Reply

    bewin1688 Do you want extar money?

  • nft commented on September 14, 2024 Reply

    Very efficiently written information. It will be beneficial to anybody who utilizes it, including me. Keep up the good work. For sure i will check out more posts. This site seems to get a good amount of visitors. nft

  • bubu commented on September 15, 2024 Reply

    Just wanna remark on few general things, The website style is ideal, the topic matter is rattling good ROGTOTO

  • check here commented on September 16, 2024 Reply

    Very efficiently written information. It will be beneficial to anybody who utilizes it, including me. Keep up the good work. For sure i will check out more posts. This site seems to get a good amount of visitors. check here

  • Mike Rooney commented on September 17, 2024 Reply

    I am so happy to come across this piece of write up, very much advanced my understanding to the next top level. Great job and continue to do same.
    Yellowstone Merch

  • Wewe commented on September 18, 2024 Reply

    Excellent website you have here, so much cool information!.. URL

  • dm approvals commented on September 19, 2024 Reply

    This particular is usually apparently essential and moreover outstanding truth along with for sure fair-minded and moreover admittedly useful My business is looking to find in advance designed for this specific useful stuffs… dm approvals

  • dm approvals commented on September 19, 2024 Reply

    This particular is usually apparently essential and moreover outstanding truth along with for sure fair-minded and moreover admittedly useful My business is looking to find in advance designed for this specific useful stuffs… dm approvals

  • sam 8659960 commented on September 20, 2024 Reply

    Zodu ABA Services offers Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) to help individuals manage and overcome behavioral challenges. CBT is a structured, evidence-based approach that focuses on identifying and changing negative thought patterns and behaviors. Through this therapy, individuals learn cognitive behavioral therapy coping strategies and skills to improve emotional regulation, reduce anxiety, and foster positive behaviors, leading to better mental health and overall well-being.

  • casepr commented on September 21, 2024 Reply

    Merely a smiling visitant here to share the love (:, btw outstanding style. anru33

  • Frank commented on September 22, 2024 Reply

    I really got into this article. I found it to be interesting and loaded with unique points of interest. I like to read material that makes me think. Thank you for writing this great content. acim

  • fairfax hit and run commented on September 23, 2024 Reply

    The New School provides a dynamic, innovative learning environment that encourages creativity and critical thinking. Its diverse programs, interdisciplinary approach, and emphasis on real-world experience through internships make it an excellent choice for students seeking progressive education. fairfax hit and runYour go-to legal eagle, turning complex laws into simple solutions. Committed to fighting for your rights and securing the justice you deserve. Let’s navigate the legal maze together!

  • amanda commented on September 23, 2024 Reply
  • casper commented on September 23, 2024 Reply

    I really like your writing style, great information, thankyou for posting. anru33 login

  • casper commented on September 23, 2024 Reply

    I really like your writing style, great information, thankyou for posting. anru33

  • framnk commented on September 23, 2024 Reply

    i was just browsing along and came upon your blog. just wanted to say good blog and this article really helped me. 150 backlink

  • casepr commented on September 23, 2024 Reply

    I really like your writing style, great information, thankyou for posting. anru33 login

  • caspetr commented on September 23, 2024 Reply

    Pretty good post. I have just stumbled upon your blog and enjoyed reading your blog posts very much. I am looking for new posts to get more precious info. Big thanks for the useful info. slot gacor

  • Pance commented on September 24, 2024 Reply

    Online diyet, internet üzerinden yürütülen ve genellikle kişiye özel beslenme planlarını içeren bir diyet programıdır. Bu tür diyetler, beslenme uzmanları veya diyetisyenler tarafından sunulan çevrimiçi platformlar aracılığıyla uygulanabilir.

  • Frank commented on September 25, 2024 Reply

    hey there, your site is cheap. We do thank you for work dewatogel

  • Ufa1688 commented on September 26, 2024 Reply

    อีสปอร์ต นิยมเข้ามาใช้บริการกัน อย่างแพร่หลายและไม่เพียงเท่านี้ให้คุณได้เข้ามาร่วมสนุกกับทางเว็บของเราได้

  • new release OC commented on September 28, 2024 Reply

    new release OC claim Free bonus up to 777 just sign up and download the app..withdrawable!!! NO DEPOSIT REQUIRED!!! just reach P777 amount or higher!!!
    click and register now!

  • endoboost commented on September 28, 2024 Reply

    Wow, that’s what I was exploring for, what a data! present here at this web site, thanks admin of this site.

    Feel free to surf to my site – endoboost

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *