“For all criticism is based on that equation: KNOWLEDGE + TASTE = MEANINGFUL JUDGMENT.” – Daniel Mendelsohn, The New Yorker
“The art critic, however, formalizes and deliberately exemplifies the role of the spectator who realizes the artist’s work—not by leaving it just as it is, but by adding something to it, making a personal contribution.” – Barry Schwabsky, The Nation
“[Criticism] means making fine distinctions. It means talking about ideas, aesthetics, and morality as if these things matter (and they do).” – Dwight Garner, The New York Times
I chose these three quotes because although I think they make wildly different claims about the role of criticism, they are all equally interesting to me and equally forceful. Each critic writing is clearly up on his soapbox, writing this particular line so it drips with emphasis and conviction. The concentration of “keywords” waiting to be unpacked is through the roof – taste, meaning, judgment, spectator, aesthetics, morality – which makes these quotes feel like the diamonds in the unfolding rough of these essays. Mendelsohn even incorporates an all-caps font to drive his point home. Yet after they manage to distill the act of cultural criticism to its simplest possible “sound-bite,” it is clear they have arrived at different conclusions with different levels of effectiveness.
Only one of these critics mentions what I might have thought was the linchpin of criticism: judgment. Mendelsohn holds up “meaningful judgment” as the desired end result of his equation, while Garner only talks about “distinctions.” Distinctions are important to make, but there is less of a connotation of assigning value with distinctions. Schwabsky moves even farther away from suggesting value judgments by calling criticism a “personal contribution” to an artist’s work. I have to admit I chafe a little at this; I do not want to believe that negative critical reviews give critics any ownership over a work. Call me old fashioned, but I think that it’s possible to view the discourse around a work of art as existing alongside the work rather than “adding something to it” or altering it. Further, I think that the notion of giving a subjective “contribution” might be at odds with Schwabsky’s idea of the critic as representing the Audience Member with capital letters.
But enough beating on Schwabsky. No quote works harder towards distillation than Mendelsohn’s equation, and I was really taken with its simplicity at first. However, on further thought, something started to seem a little off about it. I realized the problem was in one of his “keywords”: taste. Taste is pretty hard to define, but for me taste is not separate from knowledge (as the equation might suggest). I would define taste as having the knowledge to either justify or overcome your base feelings about a work of art in order to decide whether or not it has merit. Taste is not only knowing what you like to consume in culture, but also knowing what work is valuable (another word with many meanings). This sounds a lot like criticism. Maybe replacing “knowledge” with “context” or “teaching” would make the equation make more sense to me.
At the end of the day, I think Garner’s distilled take on the role of criticism speaks to me the most. As the humanities seem increasingly undervalued next to STEM fields, it is just nice to hear the simple statement that the intangible things I like to think about are, in fact, important. (I can overlook my slight problem with judging the “morality” of art to preserve this feel-good moment.) Garner only has to zoom out a little from the detailed debate on criticism to point out the fundamentally important aspects of critical thinking to the broadest human experience. Something that is exciting to me about criticism is the commitment to making important, nuanced ideas clear to an audience outside the ivory tower. Garner manages to do this gracefully and make a powerful point: “Our critical faculties are what make us human.”
2,333 Comments
Very interesting, it’s natural that many people like this blog, thank you, this blog adds to your insight, but we also found sites that are no less interesting, if you want to know, just visit this website.https://thinkvid.tv/
Very interesting, it’s natural that many people like this blog, thank you, this blog adds to your insight, but we also found sites that are no less interesting, if you want to know, just visit this website.https://7700s.com/
I frequently read short articles or reviews that effectively communicate their ideas. This is also true for the piece I’m currently reading. – 24k bet app
You can’t go back and change the beginning, but you can start where you are and change the ending. okvip
I appreciate the valuable insights you provide in your articles. I’ll be sure to bookmark your blog and return regularly for updates. I’m confident I’ll discover plenty of new information here! Best of luck with your future posts!
Taya365
Hello everyone! How’s everything going? This site offers great value to all of us, and your insights are incredibly helpful for newcomers. – 24k bet app
It’s extraordinary, it’s natural that many people are interested in this blog, we really appreciate sending it to this blog. For further information, just visit our website.https://www.nidr.nema.gov.mn/assets/?terbang=tribuntogel
Thank you for providing very interesting information, for further information just visit our website.https://www.nidr.nema.gov.mn/assets/?terbang=waktogel
Thank you for providing very interesting information, for further information just visit our website.https://www.akuhoki.org/
긍정적 인 사이트,이 게시물에 대한 정보를 어디서 얻었습니까? 나는 그것을 발견하게되어 기쁘다. 당신이 어떤 추가 포스트를 포함하는지 곧 확인하기 위해 곧 다시 확인할 것이다. 오피아트
Very interesting news and it’s not surprising that many people like this blog, for more information just visit our website.https://ampunsepuh.com
I have learn a few good stuff here. kubet88 zone
Thank you very much for this useful article kubet77 trade
Thank you for the information provided. It’s very interesting. It’s natural that many people like this blog. Our website also provides information that is no less interesting. If you want to find out, just visit our website.https://167.172.95.135
I truly welcome this superb post that you have accommodated us. I guarantee this would be valuable for the vast majority of the general population. จุดด่างดำ
I was surprised you’re not more popular because you most certainly have the gift. kubet rentals
You can’t have a better tomorrow if you are thinking about yesterday all the time. mb66
extraordinary, very interesting, we really appreciate this blog, thank you for the information provided, if you want to know further information, just visit our website.https://catinfor.com
Saya direkomendasikan situs web ini oleh sepupu saya. Saya m
tidak yakin apakah posting ini ditulis olehnya sebagai orang lain
tahu seperti rinci tentang kesulitan saya. Anda luar biasa! Terima kasih! 안전한 파워볼사이트
I haven’t any word to appreciate this post…..Really i am impressed from this post….the person who create this post it was a great human..thanks for shared this with us. 온라인카지노
Thank you for the very interesting information, it is natural that many people like this blog, for further information just visit our website.https://lab.stikesnurulhasanah-kutacane.ac.id/servers/?products=omutogel
Khelo24bet provides a vibrant and user-friendly platform for engaging in online sports betting and casinogames.
extraordinary, very interesting, we really appreciate this blog, thank you for the information provided, if you want to know further information, just visit our website.https://lab.stikesnurulhasanah-kutacane.ac.id/servers/?products=danatoto
Thank you for the information you share here, all of it is very important, really high quality. Don’t forget to entertain yourself on our site. Play your favorite online slot games now! Get the chance to win big prizes while enjoying the games provided with high-quality themes and music. If you are interested, you can go directly to the site we dedicate to you, don’t miss out, for more complete information visit the website https://slot88.akbidpantiwilasa.ac.id/probet88/
extraordinary, very interesting, we really appreciate this blog, thank you for the information provided, if you want to know further information, just visit our website.https://soundwell-official.com/
Thank you for the interesting information you provide here, it is very satisfying, and you make it very neat so it is easy to understand. Don’t miss out on sites that contain other interesting information, we provide interesting information that is currently trending. Don’t miss out. For more complete information, visit the website https://fifamatch.com/olimpiade-2024/
MonDesign Web se positionne comme une agence marketing digitale de premier plan au Maroc, offrant une gamme complète de services pour répondre aux besoins uniques de chaque client. De la création de sites web au référencement (SEO), en passant par la gestion des réseaux sociaux (SMM) et la conception graphique, nous mettons tout en œuvre pour propulser votre présence en ligne. Découvrez comment nous pouvons transformer votre entreprise en visitant notre agence marketing digitale.
Insanity is doing the same thing, over and over again, but expecting different results good. KU11
There is no failure except in no longer trying and very important. 789win06
I advise pupils to use this website to their advantage. 918kissauto
such as backwashing or rinsing. สล็อตออนไลน์
highly informative article. JILI WALLET
we ensure strong customer loyalty optimization JOKER AUTO WALLET
Wonderful article. JOKER WALLET
platform that provides a single, Live22 auto
Dynamics CRM is available in both on-premise and cloud-based versions. MEGA888 AUTO
You’re so cool! I don’t think that read something like this before. PG SLOT AUTO
Thanks for making my experience more beautiful. PG SLOT AUTO WALLET
secure, pussyslot
kept me engaged throughout my visit. เว็บสล็อต 168 ฝาก ถอน true wallet
The percentage of sales attributed to online shopping keeps growing, เว็บสล็อตวอเลท
Your suggestions are appreciated. slotxo wallet
The best option for medical practices practitioners สล็อต ฝาก-ถอน true wallet ไม่มี บัญชีธนาคาร
exude an air of cool confidence that never goes out of vogue. สล็อตเว็บตรง
Community Management Meta/Google LinkedIn Paid Ads. PUSSY888 เว็บตรง
This has been the most difficult subject I’ve had to 918KISS AUTO
organization that you can believe. สล็อตjili วอเลท
and HID kits, ສລ໊ອດອອນລາຍ
These Tailor made putter grip is used by Best Grip For Betflix wallet
Thank you! สล็อตฝากถอนวอเล็ท