PhLing: Christopher Vogel (University of Maryland)

DateMarch 10, 2017

Time: 1:30-3:30 pm

LocationKresge 5531

TitleExternalism’s Vagueness Problem

Abstract:

Many natural language expressions seemingly lead to Sorites paradoxes, in that we can construct a series of claims that make use of, or relate to, a given expression, each of which is intuitively plausible but cannot be mutually true. In this sense, many natural language expressions are vague.  If one accepts that the truth of `Donald is bald’ relates to the number of hairs on Donald’s head, one seems likewise committed to the implausible claim that the loss of a single hair can make someone bald.  But, to deny that baldness pertains to head hair count seems equally implausible.  I’ll argue that problems of this sort are merely apparent, and indeed not a consequence of natural language meanings.  Rather, these difficulties arise for a particular externalist commitment to the relationship between linguistic meaning and truth. That is, the long standing problems pertaining to vagueness are the consequence of a (likewise long standing) semantic theory which holds that the meaning of a linguistic expression determines the truth-conditions for that expression. Alternatively, if we deny that natural language expressions have truth-conditions, many of the problems posed by vagueness do not arise in the first place.  I’ll illustrate how an internalist semantics can account for natural language speaker judgments pertaining to vague expressions without generating Sorites paradoxes.

4 thoughts on “PhLing: Christopher Vogel (University of Maryland)

  • February 19, 2024 at 9:27 am
    Permalink

    As someone who has experienced multiple relocations, I can confidently recommend this moving and storage service provider. Their professionalism and efficiency stood out from the crowd. Visit it https://starvanlinesmovers.com/storage . They carefully listened to my requirements and tailored their services accordingly. The team handled my belongings with utmost care, ensuring everything arrived intact. With their competitive pricing and exceptional customer service, they are the go-to choice for all your moving and storage needs.

    Reply
  • February 26, 2024 at 2:03 pm
    Permalink

    The college essay writer service at https://writer24.com/college-essay-writer is an excellent option for assistance with essay writing. They have the best reputation for providing reliable and top-notch essay services. Their team of skilled experts, which includes certified college essay writers, guarantees that your papers are not only well-written but also carefully tailored to meet academic criteria. Regardless of how difficult the subject is or how much time you have available, their advice could be helpful. With their exceptional results, you can count on them to go above and beyond your expectations. Rather of allowing your academic stress hold you back, let their college essay writers help you achieve!

    Reply
  • March 16, 2024 at 12:28 pm
    Permalink

    I remember how on one of the bad weather days, when I didn’t want to go out, I started looking for entertainment on the Internet. I wanted something that would take and maybe even win a little. That’s how I found paradise-8.online. I tried it and did not regret it – the site is easy to navigate, the games are exciting, and the atmosphere is quite pleasant. I was able to rest and even win a little, which was a nice bonus.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *